The goldfish test that can change your behaviour

Feb 04, 2014 by Miriam Sullivan, The Conversation
One memorable goldfish. Flickr/ Benson Kua

The average Australian spends more than five hours watching YouTube every month.

With such high viewership, it's no surprise that interest groups are reaching out with YouTube to try to change people's behaviour, including well known campaigns such as Beyond Blue's Man Therapy and Tourism Australia's Best Jobs in the World. But how successful are they?

What influence?

It's well established that television and movies can influence audience behaviour. For example, medical dramas can increase the number of people signing up for organ donation and encourage women to get breast cancer screenings, while movies that feature smoking increase the number of teenagers taking up smoking.

There's even a Hollywood charity dedicated to using television and films for promoting public health messages. However, YouTube videos are much shorter than television shows or movies, meaning that people have less time to become involved and persuaded to change their behaviour.

In our study we looked at whether a single viewing of a YouYube could influence a person's behaviour a month later. More specifically, we looked at whether watching a 50-second YouTube clip could encourage pet fish owners to regularly clean out their aquariums.

The experiment

Why pet fish? In many behavioural studies results can be biased by outside influences. If we studied exercise or smoking the participants would have been exposed to similar advertising campaigns elsewhere and might be tempted to lie about their behaviour to feel better about themselves. We were fairly confident that fish owners wouldn't come across any other videos on cleaning fish tanks.

Fish are also the forgotten family pet. Just like cats and dogs, fish are intelligent, long-lived and can feel pain, but you would never flush your dead cat down a toilet or win puppies at carnivals.

With 1.5 billion pet fish sold globally every year, it's time we started taking better care of them and regularly cleaning out an aquarium is one of the most effective ways to keep your fish healthy.

Nearly 200 fish owners took part in our online experiment. After answering a few short questions about keeping fish and how often they cleaned their tank, they were randomly assigned to one of three groups.

Two of the groups were shown different videos designed to improve their tank cleaning habits, either a sad video about pets dying or a funny video of fish pooing. The remaining control group were shown no video at all.

One month later, they were asked again how often they cleaned their tanks and what they remembered about the video.

What they remembered

Initially, it looked as if watching the YouTube video made no difference to their behaviour. About a third of people cleaned their tank more often after the experiment, a third less often and a third stayed the same.

However, a closer examination revealed that the results were slightly more complex. People who watched a video but did not improve were already doing the right thing and cleaning out their aquariums regularly.

So, rather then being unaffected by the video, they simply didn't have room for improvement. But for the one-quarter of respondents who agreed they needed to improve, the videos made a big difference.

This video is not supported by your browser at this time.
Goldfish survey video: the sad version.

The group of owners who said they needed to improve but did not see either YouTube video actually got worse over the following month. Half cleaned their tank the same number of times and the other half cleaned their tank less often. None of the participants in this group improved their habits.

This video is not supported by your browser at this time.
Goldfish survey video: the funny version.

By comparison, 60% of fish owners who intended to improve and watched a YouTube video started cleaning out their tanks more often. Only 6% cleaned their tank less after watching the video.

Make 'em laugh to remember

When it comes to remembering the message, comedy appears to beat tragedy, with 88% of people who saw the funny video recalling it after one month compared to 60% who recalled the sad video.

Our results suggest that YouTube videos can affect a person's behaviour, if only by reinforcing what you already intended to do. For example, a YouTube video encouraging people to quit smoking won't help people who don't smoke, and won't stop determined smokers. But it could help people who were thinking about quitting to start taking action.

This video is not supported by your browser at this time.

So for people thinking of making a YouTube video there is some evidence to suggest that a funny video will be remembered better, which is possibly why Melbourne's Metro Trains Dumb Ways to Die was a YouTube hit despite dealing with a serious topic.

Our results, while promising, represent a small sample and may not apply to all topics or all groups of people. YouTube is an important feature of modern life and more research needs to be done to determine its full potential to influence our behaviour.

Explore further: PSY and Ylvis top YouTube 2013 video hit list

More information: This is an edited version of Miriam Sullivan's presentation "Can we change behaviour using YouTube?", delivered today at the Australian Science Communicators national conference in Brisbane.

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

YouTube adds online video editing tool

Jun 17, 2010

YouTube users can now edit their own videos online. The Google-owned video-sharing site added an online editing tool this week that allows YouTube users to combine multiple videos, shorten a video or add soundtracks ...

YouTube adds video editing tool

Sep 15, 2011

YouTube on Wednesday added an editing tool that lets creators of videos make changes to snippets after they have been uploaded to the popular website.

Recommended for you

Fighting cyber-crime one app at a time

2 hours ago

This summer Victoria University of Wellington will be home to four Singaporean students researching cyber threats. The students have been working with Dr Ian Welch, a lecturer in Victoria's School of Engineering and Computer ...

Is big data heading for its 'horsemeat moment'?

4 hours ago

There have been so many leaks, hacks and scares based on misuse or misappropriation of personal data that any thought that "big data" could provide benefits rather than only opportunities for harm may be ...

User comments : 1

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

Ralph
not rated yet Feb 04, 2014
Recently I have been advising everyone I know that youtube has become the medium of a radical new human connectedness. Just as the web made it easy for anyone to learn anything, youtube now allows us to stand side by side with people all around the globe as they live every kind of human experience.

Moving beyond text with universal free uploads for videographers via their ever-present cell phones, the extra dimensions of audio and video open up an overwhelming new world of public intimacy. With no additional neural hardware or other anatomical modification necessary, we are already roaring into the transhuman age.