Google's Motorola misstep could be Lenovo's boon

Jan 30, 2014 by Michael Liedtke
In this Wednesday, Sept. 5, 2012, file photo, Eric Schmidt, Google's chairman, speaks during a press conference in New York, where Motorola introduced three new smartphones, the first since it became a a part of Google. Google said Wednesday, Jan. 29, 2014, it is selling Motorola's smartphone business to Lenovo for $2.9 billion, a price that makes Google's biggest acquisition look like its most expensive mistake.(AP Photo/Bebeto Matthews, File)

An expensive mistake by Google could turn into a golden opportunity for China's Lenovo Group as it expands beyond its success in the personal computer industry.

Google is ridding itself of a financial headache by selling Motorola Mobility's smartphone business to Lenovo for $2.9 billion. The deal announced late Wednesday comes less than two years after Google bought Motorola Mobility for $12.4 billion in the biggest acquisition of Google's 15-year history.

While Google Inc. is backpedaling, Lenovo Group Ltd. is gearing up for a major expansion. Already the world's largest PC maker, Lenovo is now determined to become a bigger player in smartphones as more people rely on them instead of laptop and desktop computers to go online.

Lenovo already is among the smartphone leaders in its home country, but it has been looking for ways to expand its presence in other markets, especially the U.S. and Latin America. The company had been rumored to be among the prospective buyers for BlackBerry Ltd. when that troubled smartphone maker was mulling a sale last year.

"We will be going from an emerging-market player to a worldwide player in smartphones," Lenovo CEO Yang Yuanqing said in an interview with The Associated Press.

This marks Lenovo's second high-profile deal this month. The company announced plans last week to buy a major piece of IBM Corp.'s computer server business for $2.3 billion.

For Google, the sale is a tacit admission that a company that prides itself on employing some of the world's smartest people miscalculated how much Motorola was worth.

Google previously recovered some of the money that it spent on Motorola by selling its set-top operations last year to Arris Group Inc. for $2.35 billion.

And Google is holding on to most of Motorola's more than 20,000 mobile patents, providing Google with legal protection for its widely used Android software for smartphones and tablet computers. Gaining control of Motorola's patents was the main reason Google was willing to pay so much for a smartphone maker that was already losing money and market share.

The Motorola patents were valued at $5.5 billion at the time Google took over, according to regulatory filings.

Factoring all that, there's a gap of roughly $1.65 billion between what Google paid for Motorola and what Google is getting from its sales to Arris and Lenovo, plus the original value of the patents. What's not known is the value of the patents Google is keeping, as Lenovo is picking up about 2,000 Motorola patents in addition to the phone manufacturing operations.

It's also unclear if Google will have to absorb a charge to account for its apparent miscalculation of Motorola Mobility's value. The Mountain View, Calif., company may address the issue when it announces its fourth-quarter earnings after the market closes Thursday.

Most investors viewed Motorola as an unnecessary drain on Google's profit, a perspective that was reflected by Wall Street's reaction to the sale. Google's stock gained $33.04, or 3 percent, to $1,139.96 in midday trading Thursday.

A cellphone pioneer, Motorola Mobility had its last big hit with the Razr flip phone, which came out in 2004. Its product line became outmoded after Apple Inc. released the iPhone in 2007, unleashing a new era of touch-screen phones. Motorola hasn't been able to catch up yet, even as last summer's Moto X received positive reviews.

Motorola's losses are likely to dampen Google's earnings at least for the first half of this year. That's because it's expected to take six to nine months before the proposed sale gets the necessary approvals from regulators.

Buying Motorola will enable Lenovo to join Apple Inc. as the only major technology companies with global product lines in PCs, smartphones and tablets, putting Lenovo in a better position to become a one-stop shop for companies to buy all their devices from the same vendor, said Forrester Research analyst Frank Gillett.

"This makes Lenovo a company to watch," Gillett said in an email. "The personal device manufacturer business is consolidating—and manufacturers must compete in all three device markets, plus emerging wearable categories, or get left out of the next market shift."

Lenovo plans to keep both smartphone brands, selling under Motorola's name in developed markets such as the U.S. and Europe and under its own in developing countries where it already is established, Chief Financial Officer Wong Waiming told reporters.

Lenovo's annual smartphone revenues are about $4 billion and, with the addition of Motorola, the company hopes to increase that quickly to $10 billion, Wong said in a conference call.

The Chinese company is paying a portion of the purchase price to Google with $750 million in Lenovo shares. Wong said that was part of a "strategic relationship the two groups want to establish." He said details still are being discussed.

Explore further: Google selling Motorola phone business to Lenovo for $2.9 billion (Update 2)

2.5 /5 (6 votes)
add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Recommended for you

Alibaba makes Wall Street debut

Sep 19, 2014

Alibaba made its long-awaited Wall Street debut Friday on the heels of a record stock offering that opens the door to global expansion for the Chinese online retail giant.

Alibaba IPO to boost employee fortunes to $8 bn

Sep 19, 2014

Employees of Chinese e-commerce giant Alibaba will see their fortunes swell to nearly $8 billion as the company prepares a massive US stock offering that could be valued at $25 billion.

Alibaba mega IPO caps founder Jack Ma success tale

Sep 19, 2014

When Jack Ma founded Alibaba 15 years ago he insisted the e-commerce venture should see itself as competing against Silicon Valley, not other Chinese companies. That bold ambition from a time when China was ...

User comments : 4

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

BSD
not rated yet Jan 30, 2014
This is finance, not science.
I don't care who own's what, or who is up who's corporate arse.
Urgelt
not rated yet Jan 31, 2014
What mistake did Google make?

They shelled out over $12 billion for Motorola's patent portfolio. Now they're shedding the hardware business, which they never really wanted in the first place, for a couple billion.

The only mistake in sight is American patent law, which is utterly ridiculous at this point. If not for patent law insanity, companies like Google would be investing in something useful instead of patent ammunition.
_ilbud
not rated yet Jan 31, 2014
I've never seen such a stupid tech article, is this guy ten years old or something?
COCO
not rated yet Jan 31, 2014
good move - Lenovo and the Chinese know the importance of controlling even the manufacturing of devices - too bad they did not save RIM.