Ex-CIA boss: Telecoms should store metadata, not NSA

January 14, 2014
Former CIA Director Michael Morell is seen November 28, 2012 in the Senate Visitors Center of the US Capitol in Washington

Telephone "metadata" controversially scooped up by a US intelligence agency should not be destroyed but stored by private telecom giants, a former CIA chief said Tuesday days before President Barack Obama announces new reforms.

Former Central Intelligence Agency acting director Michael Morell testified before the US Senate with the four other members of a committee Obama appointed to propose reforms.

Their report, published in December, recommended 46 changes.

"The program only has to be successful once to be invaluable," Morell told lawmakers, adding that the National Security Agency's deeply divisive program "does carry the potential going forward to prevent a catastrophic attack on the United States."

Last month, experts called for the program, which allows the NSA to store five years of data on all US calls—including numbers dialed and time and duration of calls, but not content of conversations—to be amended to improve transparency and prevent future abuse.

According to the experts, the storage of such data should be held by telecommunication operators and not on NSA servers.

Under such reforms, the NSA would have access to the data only after validation by a judge.

Women use their cellphones on January 7, 2014 in Los Angeles, California

"The concerns of our constitutional history is that government can do far more harm if it abuses the info in its possession than the private entities can," said Geoffrey Stone, a law professor and constitutional expert at the University of Chicago.

Should government maintain the data, "there's always the possibility of someone coming along, down the road, seeing this as a great opportunity to get political dirt on individuals, on their activities, their organizations, their associations," Stone said.

"That's a danger we want to avoid."

The Obama administration, like that of president George W. Bush before it, believes the metadata storage is not a violation of privacy since conversations are not recorded.

But Morell said the boundary "between metadata and content" remains tenuous.

"When you have the records of the phone calls that a particular individual made, you can learn an awful lot about that person," he told lawmakers.

Obama is set to make a speech Friday outlining his paths to reform the surveillance programs, which were the subject of months of international criticism after fugitive intelligence contractor Edward Snowden revealed the depths of the programs in June.

Explore further: NSA defends global cellphone tracking as legal (Update)

Related Stories

NSA defends global cellphone tracking as legal (Update)

December 6, 2013

The National Security Agency on Friday said its tracking of cellphones overseas is legally authorized under a sweeping U.S. presidential order. The distinction means the extraordinary surveillance program is not overseen ...

Obama to meet with lawmakers, intel leaders on NSA

January 7, 2014

President Barack Obama is inviting lawmakers and intelligence officials to the White House to discuss National Security Agency programs as Obama prepares to unveil what changes he's prepared to make to the programs.

Obama nearing a decision on intelligence review

January 8, 2014

President Barack Obama is hosting a series of meetings this week with lawmakers, privacy advocates and intelligence officials as he nears a final decision on changes to the government's controversial surveillance programs.

Proposed spy phone record shift draws resistance

January 14, 2014

Telephone companies are quietly balking at the idea of changing how they collect and store Americans' phone records to help the National Security Agency's surveillance programs. They are worried about their exposure to lawsuits ...

Recommended for you

Smart home heating and cooling

August 28, 2015

Smart temperature-control devices—such as thermostats that learn and adjust to pre-programmed temperatures—are poised to increase comfort and save energy in homes.

Smallest 3-D camera offers brain surgery innovation

August 28, 2015

To operate on the brain, doctors need to see fine details on a small scale. A tiny camera that could produce 3-D images from inside the brain would help surgeons see more intricacies of the tissue they are handling and lead ...

Team creates functional ultrathin solar cells

August 27, 2015

(Phys.org)—A team of researchers with Johannes Kepler University Linz in Austria has developed an ultrathin solar cell for use in lightweight and flexible applications. In their paper published in the journal Nature Materials, ...

Interactive tool lifts veil on the cost of nuclear energy

August 24, 2015

Despite the ever-changing landscape of energy economics, subject to the influence of new technologies and geopolitics, a new tool promises to root discussions about the cost of nuclear energy in hard evidence rather than ...

1 comment

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

Returners
5 / 5 (2) Jan 14, 2014
Telephone "metadata" controversially scooped up by a US intelligence agency should not be destroyed but stored by private telecom giants


Why? They get hacked too, and it makes no sense to give a corporation that kind of power.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.