Telecommunications data show civic dividing lines in major countries

Dec 18, 2013 by Peter Dizikes
Telecommunications data show civic dividing lines in major countries
Analysis of telecom data globally (shown above for Portugal) shows the extent to which communications networks (at left) may correspond to existing political or geographic regions (represented at right). Credit: MIT Senseable City Lab

Many residents of Britain, Italy, and Belgium imagine there to be a kind of north-south divide in their countries, marking a barrier between different social groups and regional characteristics. Now a new study by MIT researchers reveals that such divides can be seen in the patterns of communication in those countries and others.

Telecommunications data in Britain, for instance, show that only about 9.5 percent of communications cross a line about 100 miles north of London. In Italy, only 7.8 percent of communications cross a line roughly along the northern border of the Emilio-Romagna region, above which lie the industrial and commercial metropolises of Milan and Turin.

These invisible borders, the researchers say, help us grasp the social, civic, and commercial interactions that exist in contemporary nations, and may be of use to government officials and other policy experts.

"We are looking at networks to think about how communities are structured over space," says Carlo Ratti, an associate professor in MIT's Department of Urban Studies and Planning, director of MIT's Senseable City Lab, and a co-author of a new paper summarizing the results. The study is part of a larger effort, he adds, to see "how we can use these technologies to better understand the extent of constituencies and communities."

The paper, "Delineating geographical regions with networks of in an extensive set of countries," is being published this week in the journal PLoS ONE. The findings show that, for all the digital connectivity in civic life today, people still connect in "a geographically cohesive, connected set of communities," says Stanislav Sobolevsky, a researcher at the Senseable City Lab and a co-author of the paper.

Sobolevsky emphasizes that the study, which covers seven countries, shows that examining communications networks allows analysts to reconstruct the regional nature of nations across a wide variety of geographic settings. The work builds on a previous analysis of Great Britain alone.

Mapping the linguistic divide

The paper was co-authored by Ratti, Sobolevsky, Senseable City Lab researcher Michael Szell, and Thomas Couronne and Zbignew Smoreda of Orange Labs, which is the research arm of the French telecommunications firm Orange.

In addition to Great Britain, Italy, and Belgium, the researchers examined France, Portugal, the Ivory Coast, and Saudi Arabia. The researchers used aggregated, anonymized data provided by Orange, British Telecom, Telecom Italia, and the Saudi Telecom Company. The researchers mapped the connections in two iterations: first at a larger scale, and then at a more local level, to see network patterns across and within regions and communities.

Some of the findings reaffirmed the strength of existing political and linguistic barriers. Belgium has long had a linguistic and social divide between the Flemish-speaking Flanders region, in the north, and French-speaking Wallonia, in the south. The study found that only 3.5 percent of the communications links in Belgium run between Flanders and Wallonia.

In France, patterns of communication closely mirrored the nation's historical administrative regions, although the data also reveal a larger east-west divide running almost the length of the country.

"What's impressive about this work is that they show that using phone calls in this way produces clusters and subdivisions that make great economic and political sense," says Michael Batty, a professor emeritus of planning at University College in London, who has read the paper.

Even when patterns of communication reflect pre-existing political or administrative lines, Ratti says, they can still represent "a more natural geography that emerges from people," and can be studied over time.

The researchers think this kind of mapping could be useful for governmental purposes, in cases where, say, lawmakers are rethinking political or administrative boundaries.

"You can see in advance how well newly proposed borders match with the actual human interactions," Szell says.

Ratti acknowledges the work might also have private-sector uses for firms conducting new types of market analysis or other forms of research. Still, he says the Senseable City Lab is primarily interested in further studies along the lines of the current one.

"We're more interested in the theory behind it," Ratti says, "and in how this can contribute to a 'science of cities.'"

Explore further: Cruising high seas, engineers detect fake GPS signals

More information: Delineating geographical regions with networks of human interactions in an extensive set of countries." Stanislav Sobolevsky, Michael Szell, Riccardo Campari, Thomas Couronné, Zbigniew Smoreda, Carlo Ratti PLOS ONE, 2013. Available: arXiv:1310.1829. arxiv.org/abs/1310.1829

Related Stories

'Wiki City Rome' to draw a map like no other

Aug 31, 2007

Residents of Italy's capital will glimpse the future of urban mapmaking next month with the launch of "Wiki City Rome," a project developed at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology that uses data from ...

Recommended for you

Microsoft unveils Xbox in China as it faces probe

1 hour ago

Microsoft on Wednesday unveiled its Xbox game console in China, the first to enter the market after an official ban 14 years ago, even as it faces a Chinese government probe over business practices.

Teens love vacation selfies; adults, not so much

1 hour ago

(AP)—Jacquie Whitt's trip to the Galapagos with a group of teenagers was memorable not just for the scenery and wildlife, but also for the way the kids preserved their memories. It was, said Whitt, a "selfie ...

Tiny UAVs and hummingbirds are put to test

2 hours ago

Hummingbirds in nature exhibit expert engineering skills, the only birds capable of sustained hovering. A team from the US, British Columbia, and the Netherlands have completed tests to learn more about the ...

US spy agency patents car seat for kids

5 hours ago

Electronic eavesdropping is the National Security Agency's forte, but it seems it also has a special interest in children's car seats, Foreign Policy magazine reported Wednesday.

User comments : 0