Satellite failures threaten hurricane forecasts, Senate panel is told

December 17, 2013 by Mark K. Matthews

There's a storm brewing in the world of U.S. weather forecasting, and - much like the hurricanes that meteorologists are trained to predict - there's not much anyone can do about it.

The U.S. faces the likely prospect that a critical tool used in predicting the weather, a fleet of civilian satellites that orbit the poles, could fail completely in less than four years.

With no ready backup and a replacement satellite not expected to launch any earlier than 2017, experts warned Thursday that U.S. forecasters could face at least a 17-month gap in meteorological data vital to weather prediction, including hurricane forecasting.

"This is an unacceptable position for data so critical to lives, property and the economy," warned Thomas Young, a former NASA official who recently led a review of the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration's satellite program.

He was one of several witnesses who testified Thursday at a U.S. Senate hearing about the future of weather forecasting, though Young was the most vocal about the looming gap in satellite coverage.

"There's an unacceptably high probability of a gap in ... polar-orbiting data that could have a duration of months or years," he said.

Right now, NOAA relies on several polar satellites for weather data, but most of them are beyond their "design life" and could fail anytime. Worse, the newest satellite in the fleet only is expected to last until 2016 - well before the planned 2017 launch of a replacement.

If the NOAA were to lose the entire fleet, then the consequences could be disastrous. According to one government report: "NOAA's forecasts of Superstorm Sandy's track could have been hundreds of miles off without polar-orbiting satellites ... (and) would have shown the storm remaining at sea."

Though the Pentagon also runs a polar-satellite program, officials with the Government Accountability Office - the investigative arm of Congress - have warned of similar "gap" risks on the military side.

Yet neither lawmakers nor agency officials have offered much in the way of concrete solutions.

One possibility - using satellite data from China - was suggested in a NOAA-commissioned study earlier this year, but the idea has faced stiff resistance from lawmakers worried about the U.S. being beholden to a rival foreign power.

It also was recommended by Young's group that the Obama administration try to develop a "filler" satellite as a backstop in case there's a coverage gap in mid-decade. But the quick turnaround and potential cost - likely in the hundreds of millions of dollars - are daunting prospects at a time of sharp budget cuts.

Much of the blame for the current situation can be attributed to a failed effort in the 1990s to combine military and civilian programs. Because of schedule delays and ballooning costs, the initiative was canceled in 2010 - leaving the U.S. with few options.

Explore further: Metop-B weather satellite is ready for launch


Related Stories

GOES-R satellite program undergoes successful review

November 27, 2012

The GOES-R Series Program, which is leading the effort to replace and upgrade NOAA's existing fleet of geostationary satellites that track severe weather across the United States, received a favorable appraisal conducted ...

After 10 years of service, NOAA retires GOES-12 satellite

August 20, 2013

GOES-12 has seen it all, from Hurricane Katrina that hit the Gulf Coast in 2005, to the Christmas blizzard that crippled the Central United States in 2009. It even traveled south of the equator to provide coverage for South ...

Recommended for you

Peeking into our galaxy's stellar nursery

October 5, 2015

Astronomers have long turned their telescopes, be they on satellites in space or observatories on Earth, to the wide swaths of interstellar medium to get a look at the formation and birth of stars. However, the images produced ...

Researchers find a new way to weigh a star

October 5, 2015

Researchers from the University of Southampton have developed a new method for measuring the mass of pulsars – highly magnetised rotating neutron stars formed from the remains of massive stars after they explode into supernovae.

How to prepare for Mars? NASA consults Navy sub force

October 5, 2015

As NASA contemplates a manned voyage to Mars and the effects missions deeper into space could have on astronauts, it's tapping research from another outfit with experience sending people to the deep: the U.S. Navy submarine ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.