Environmental subsidies inadequate for agricultural nutrient load reduction

Dec 10, 2013

About half of Finland's contribution to the nitrogen and phosphorus load on the Baltic Sea comes from agriculture. Agriculture is thus considered to be of key importance in efforts to improve water quality. However, a recent doctoral study shows that nutrient abatement measures currently being undertaken in agriculture are not sufficient to meet the targets set.

MTT Agrifood Research Finland researcher Janne Helin explored in his dissertation the effectiveness and costs of various means for reducing the nutrient load generated by Finland's agriculture. The focus was on economic analysis. In addition to various measures undertaken on the fields, the study evaluated abatement options such as reducing the nutrient balance through feeding changes on dairy farms.

The analysis relied on numerical models based on microeconomic theory for calculating the combined effects of the studied measures, for both animal husbandry and crop farming.

Benefits of filter strips already exhausted?

The costs of nutrient abatement varied greatly, depending on the level of abatement, environmental factors, the market situation and production sector. Creating permanent plant cover on erosion-sensitive areas such as steep slopes where nutrients are easily leached is a relatively low cost means of nutrient abatement. This, however, was not enough to attain the percentagewise relatively high abatement targets.

"Furthermore, filter strips and buffer zones have already been set up at the most vulnerable locations through the environmental subsidy system, so nutrient abatement will not be as easy in the future," explains Helin.

For cultivated fields carrying less of a runoff risk, plant cover is not as effective a tool for nutrient abatement.

"Extensive green fallow does decrease the nutrient load, but it is costly, either for society or for the farmers," says Helin.

Unattainable targets?

The Government Resolution on Water Protection Policy Outlines to 2015 sets the bar high for nutrient abatement. The nutrient load from is expected to be reduced by one third from what it was between 2001–2005.

"Achieving such a significant reduction in the phosphorus load remains challenging," says Helin.

Answers have been sought in , but the impact of changing livestock feeding practices is not enough for attaining national abatement targets or meeting the timetable of the EU Water Framework Directive. In dairy production, increasing the area of grassland and reducing the use of artificial fertilisers were shown to be the economically most sensible means.

Explore further: Large lakes in Finland OK, coastal water quality poor

More information: Read the complete report: www.mtt.fi/mtttiede/pdf/mtttiede24.pdf

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Large lakes in Finland OK, coastal water quality poor

Oct 03, 2013

A new assessment of the ecological status of Finland's waters shows that 85% of the surface area of our lakes and 65% of our rivers are in a good or very good state. However, three-quarters of the surface area of our coastal ...

Making manure work for agriculture

Sep 30, 2013

Livestock manure represents a valuable resource in the agriculture sector. As fertilizer it is a source of nitrogen, phosphorous and organic matter, all crucial for the sustainability of European farming.

Native trees will ease the carbon credit crunch

Aug 11, 2011

If Australia stopped logging native forests it would meet almost half of its five per cent carbon emission reduction target for 2020, according to an expert from the Australian National University.

Researchers suggest plan to address hypoxia in Gulf of Mexico

Nov 07, 2013

Despite a 12-year action plan calling for reducing the hypoxia zone in the Gulf of Mexico, little progress has been made, and there is no evidence that nutrient loading to the Gulf has decreased during this period. University ...

Analyzing agroforestry management

Jun 28, 2011

The evaluation of both nutrient and non-nutrient resource interactions provides information needed to sustainably manage agroforestry systems. Improved diagnosis of appropriate nutrient usage will help increase yields and ...

Recommended for you

Shell files new plan to drill in Arctic

2 hours ago

Royal Dutch Shell has submitted a new plan for drilling in the Arctic offshore Alaska, more than one year after halting its program following several embarrassing mishaps.

Reducing water scarcity possible by 2050

3 hours ago

Water scarcity is not a problem just for the developing world. In California, legislators are currently proposing a $7.5 billion emergency water plan to their voters; and U.S. federal officials last year ...

User comments : 0