No peak in sight for evolving bacteria

Nov 14, 2013
Sample competition plates. Bacteria compete in the same liquid environment in which they evolve; a sample of each competition is diluted and spread on an agar plate to enumerate the competing populations. The left plate is from the start of a competition; the right plate is from the end of the same competition. The relative concentration of the lighter-colored (Ara+ ) population has increased over this competition, indicating its higher fitness. Credit: Michael Wiser

There's no peak in sight – fitness peak, that is – for the bacteria in Richard Lenski's Michigan State University lab.

Lenski, MSU Hannah Distinguished Professor of Microbiology and Molecular Genetics, has been running his evolutionary bacteria experiment for 25 years, generating more than 50,000 generations. In a paper published in the current issue of Science, Michael Wiser, lead author and MSU graduate student in Lenski's lab, compares it to hiking.

"When hiking, it's easy to start climbing toward what seems to be a peak, only to discover that the real peak is far off in the distance," Wiser said. "Now imagine you've been climbing for 25 years, and you're still nowhere near the peak."

Only the peaks aren't mountains. They are what biologists call fitness peaks – when a population finds just the right set of mutations, so it can't get any better. Any new mutation that comes along will send things downhill.

The bacteria in Lenski's lab are still becoming more fit even after a quarter century, living in the same, simple environment.

Biologists have known that organisms keep evolving if the environment keeps changing, but they've previously thought that adaptation would eventually grind to a halt if the environment stayed constant for a long time.

Wiser pulled hundreds of samples from the deep freezer that contains a frozen fossil record – bacteria all the way back to generation 0 in Lenski's 25-year experiment. And these fossils, unlike dinosaurs, are alive. So they can be competed against samples from different generations to measure the trajectory – the path – of the bacteria as they climbed for 50,000 generations toward the fitness peaks.

"There doesn't seem to be any end in sight," Lenski said. "We used to think the bacteria's fitness was leveling off, but now we see it's slowing down but not really leveling off."

Wiser found that the trajectories matched a type of mathematical function called a power law. Although the slope of the power-law function gets less and less steep over time, it never reaches a peak.

Noah Ribeck, co-author and MSU postdoctoral researcher, built a model using a few well-understood principles.

"It was surprising to me that a simple theory can describe the entirety of a long evolutionary trajectory that includes initially fast and furious adaptation that later slowed to a crawl," Ribeck said. "It's encouraging that despite all the complications inherent to biological systems, they are governed by general principles that can be described quantitatively."

When will it end?

"I call this the experiment that keeps on giving," Lenski said. "Even after 25 years, it's still generating new and exciting discoveries. From the models, we can predict how things will evolve – how fit the will become – if future generations of scientists continue the experiment long after I'm gone."

Lenski hopes that an endowment could be secured to keep the experiment going forever, he added.

Explore further: Evolution of snake courtship and combat behavior

More information: "Long-Term Dynamics of Adaptation in Asexual Populations," by M.J. Wiser et al Science, 2013

Related Stories

E. coli offers insight to evolution

Jun 20, 2011

(PhysOrg.com) -- Evolutionary biologist Richard Lenski occasionally thinks of his 12 original flasks of E. coli as the experiment that keeps on giving.

Time in a bottle: Scientists watch evolution unfold

Oct 18, 2009

A 21-year Michigan State University experiment that distills the essence of evolution in laboratory flasks not only demonstrates natural selection at work, but could lead to biotechnology and medical research ...

Slower evolving bacteria win in the end

Mar 18, 2011

(PhysOrg.com) -- Scientists in the US have found bacteria that evolve slowly are more likely to survive in the long term than those evolving more quickly.

Recommended for you

World's first microbe 'zoo' opens in Amsterdam

46 minutes ago

The world's first "interactive microbe zoo" opened in Amsterdam on Tuesday, shining new light on the tiny creatures that make up two-thirds of all living matter and are vital for our planet's future.

Study shows how chimpanzees share skills

2 hours ago

Evidence of new behaviour being adopted and transmitted socially from one individual to another within a wild chimpanzee community is publishing on September 30 in the open access journal PLOS Biology. This i ...

User comments : 2

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

beleg
not rated yet Nov 14, 2013
Which begs the question:
If there is no peak, then what keeps fitness without adaptation going?
Torbjorn_Larsson_OM
not rated yet Nov 15, 2013
It will be interesting to read. If and then adaptation will find the exact fitness peak is an open question AFAIK.

But it went to the bottom of a long pile. :-/

[And FWIW, the creationist troll got it backwards 2 times over. We all know they don't read the articles.]