License to Ill

Nov 21, 2013 by Sean Nealon

In 2008, the CEO of British Petroleum, Tony Hayward announced that BP's safety record was among the best in the industry. Under his leadership, BP ran operational safety training sessions for its employees and encouraged a culture of safety to satisfy its stakeholders, including employees, the community, and the environment.

However, in 2010, the Deepwater Horizon explosion shattered BP's positive safety record when managers missed key safety warning signs, resulting in the loss of 11 lives and creating the worst offshore oil spill in United States history. Moreover, Hayward's reaction to the spill was seen as cold and perceived as minimizing BP's responsibility for the spill and the environmental damage to the Gulf of Mexico.

This dynamic – espousing good actions but then taking steps in the opposite direction – is surprisingly common among CEOs of Fortune 500 companies, researchers have found in a just published paper.

They found firms that engaged in prior socially responsible behavior are more likely to then engage in socially irresponsible behavior and that this tendency is stronger in firms with CEOs who attempt to put forth a moral image.

"The finding is very counterintuitive," said Elaine Wong, an assistant professor of management at the University of California, Riverside School of Business Administration who co-authored the paper. "You wouldn't think doing well by one's would set the stage for actions that harm stakeholders in the future."

Wong co-authored the paper, "License to Ill: The Effects of Corporate Social Responsibility and CEO Moral Identity on Corporate Irresponsibility," with Margaret Ormiston, a faculty member at the London Business School. It was just published in the winter 2013 issue of the journal Personnel Psychology.

With many recent examples of corporate wrongdoing, academics have increasingly studied firms' corporate social responsibility, that is behavior beyond compliance and legal requirements to provide social good, such as charitable giving and providing employees flexible work arrangements. That research has found that firms with high levels of corporate social responsibility perform better financially.

But, there has been little research on corporate social irresponsibility, which refers to actions that negatively impact the interests of stakeholders. Wong and Ormiston set out to expand on the limited research in that field by examining whether corporate social responsibility influences later corporate social irresponsibility.

In their study, using the 2002 Fortune 500 list, they examined firms' longitudinal corporate and corporate social irresponsibility. They also examined the role of CEOs by focusing on those who received a reasonable amount of media coverage (at least 10 articles of approximately 1,000 words). That ended up being 49 firms, including companies such as IBM, Nike and Pepsi.

They found that prior was related to subsequent corporate social irresponsibility. More specifically for roughly every five positive actions that a firm takes, this gives them license to commit one negative action.

"These findings show that CEOs should be aware of this tendency so that they can prevent their companies from slipping into this pattern," Wong said. "Additionally, corporate boards can't allow CEOs to rest on their laurels. They need to be vigilant in monitoring CEOs."

Explore further: Churchgoers mostly favor socially responsible companies, study finds

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Wide-faced men make others act selfishly

Sep 16, 2013

Two assistant professors of management at the University of California, Riverside and several other researchers have previously shown that men with wider faces are more aggressive, less trustworthy and more ...

Many companies fall short of social responsibility promises

Feb 09, 2012

( -- Whether eliminating child labor, creating environmentally friendly technology or working against all forms of corruption, many corporations fail to become socially responsible despite promises to change, ...

Founder of Taiwan's Acer returns as chairman

Nov 21, 2013

Taiwan's struggling personal computer maker Acer announced Thursday that it has named its founder Stan Shih as the new chairman and interim corporate president.

Recommended for you

'Patent trolls' jeopardize innovation, study finds

10 hours ago

( —New research co-authored by a Naveen Jindal School of Management accounting professor suggests that companies that don't manufacture goods or products but sue companies that do threaten innovation and economic ...

Sustainability reporting falling short

11 hours ago

Once on the fringe of institutional investors' considerations, reporting on environmental, social and governance related issues is now common practice among major listed companies.

Marcellus drilling boom may have led to too many hotel rooms

Sep 18, 2014

Drilling in Pennsylvania's Marcellus Shale region led to a rapid increase in both the number of hotels and hotel industry jobs, but Penn State researchers report that the faltering occupancy rate may signal that there are ...

Entrepreneurs aren't overconfident gamblers

Sep 17, 2014

Leaving one's job to become an entrepreneur is inarguably risky. But it may not be the fear of risk that makes entrepreneurs more determined to succeed. A new study finds entrepreneurs are also concerned about what they might ...

User comments : 0