Astrophysicists tackle the Sun and one of physics' biggest unsolved problems

November 18, 2013 by Beth Kwon
Astrophysicists Tackle the Sun and One of Physics' Biggest Unsolved Problems
picture of the sun with a coronal hole (the large dark region at the bottom). Credit: NASA

Daniel Wolf Savin and Michael Hahn have been fascinated by the universe since they were boys. For Savin, a senior research scientist in the Columbia Astrophysics Laboratory, discovering Albert Einstein at age 12 spurred the desire to "learn everything about the universe." Years later, Hahn, an associate research scientist who grew up 40 miles from Savin's home town in Connecticut, started gazing at the stars as a teenager; he eventually became president of the astronomy club at his alma mater, Carnegie Mellon.

Now the two have made a big leap toward cracking one of the biggest mysteries in astrophysics—why the , or plasma surrounding the sun, is so much hotter than the sun's surface.

The coronal heating problem, as it is known, is important because the corona is the source of , which is responsible for the northern and southern lights and can also disrupt telecommunications and power grids. "Satellites can be slowly pushed out of their orbits if they're deflected by the solar wind so if we can better understand the cause, we can create better models for space weather," says Savin, referring to conditions beyond the atmosphere.

Scientists have proposed two main theories to explain why the temperature of the gas in the corona, which lies above the solar surface, soars to over 1 million degrees Kelvin even though the surface of the sun is a relatively cool 6,000 degrees. (The center of the sun is 15 million degrees.)

This unexpected phenomenon has puzzled researchers since 1939, when scientists first discovered the temperature difference; it's as if a flame were coming out of an ice cube.

Astrophysicists Tackle the Sun and One of Physics' Biggest Unsolved Problems
The lines show where the researchers took their data. Credit: NASA

One theory attributes the excessive heat to loops of magnetic fields that span the solar surface and can snap, releasing energy. The other ascribes it to emanating from below the solar surface, which carry magnetic energy and deposit it in the corona, a process called damping.

Both of these processes occur on the sun. But scientists had previously been unable to determine if either mechanism released sufficient energy to heat the corona to such high temperatures.

As observational physicists, Savin and Hahn don't conduct research by looking up at the sky as experimental physicists do. Instead, they examine public domain data, much of it collected by satellites. Their team analyzed data from the Japanese satellite Hinode, which carries an Extreme Ultraviolet Imaging Spectrometer that measures wavelengths by determining where they lie on the color spectrum.

They used observations of a polar coronal hole, a region of the sun where the magnetic fields stretch from the far into interplanetary space, and found that damping was the most likely explanation.

The magnetic waves contained enough energy to heat the corona, the team discovered, and the waves deposited most of their energy at a level that allowed the heat to spread throughout the corona. By examining the width of the spectral lines, Savin and Hahn were able to infer the temperature emitted by the waves, as well as how much energy the waves had lost. And they determined an amount equivalent to about 90 percent of the energy needed to heat the corona. The findings were published in the Sept. 30 edition of The Astrophysical Journal.

"Our work is a major advance in solving the coronal heating problem, though it doesn't resolve every issue," says Hahn. Chief among them is the cause of the wave damping—the next mystery the team will tackle.

Savin, whose office is in Pupin Hall, graduated from Columbia College in 1985 with a degree in physics. He got his Ph.D. from Harvard and returned to Columbia in 1996 as an associate research scientist. Hahn graduated from Carnegie Mellon in 2005 with a degree in physics and came to Columbia for graduate school, receiving his doctorate in applied physics in 2009—the same year he joined Savin's team.

The two decided to focus on coronal holes because they are the simplest structures in the corona and therefore the ones they were most likely to understand best.

As teenagers captivated by the movement of stars and planets, neither could have pictured their professional lives as scientists. "If you had asked me at the age of 12 what I thought being a scientist meant, I would not be able to tell you it was close to what I do today," Savin admits, referring to the papers, journal reviews, proposals, conferences and endless planning—not just working in a lab wearing a lab coat or staying up late looking at stars. "All of those aspects are critically important for creating an environment where one can do science but it's not 'doing science' as I imagined as a child."

Explore further: Solving a mystery of the Sun's corona

Related Stories

Solving a mystery of the Sun's corona

February 4, 2013

(—The corona of the sun is the hot (over a million kelvin), gaseous outer region of its atmosphere. The corona is threaded by intense magnetic fields that extend upwards from the surface in braids that are twisted ...

New research brings light to star mystery

February 4, 2013

(—Scientists at Northumbria University have begun to unlock the mystery of why the outer edge of the Sun is much hotter than its surface for the first time.

Heating the solar wind

April 3, 2013

( —The Sun glows with a surface temperature of about 5500 degrees Celsius. Meanwhile its hot outer layer (the corona) has a temperature of over a million degrees, and ejects a wind of charged particles at a rate ...

Large coronal hole near the sun's north pole

July 20, 2013

The European Space Agency/NASA Solar and Heliospheric Observatory, or SOHO, captured this image of a gigantic coronal hole hovering over the sun's north pole on July 18, 2013, at 9:06 a.m. EDT. Coronal holes are dark, low ...

It's hot... super hot: Finding answers around the sun

November 13, 2013

( —Astronomers have collectively puzzled over two working theories for a conundrum involving the sun that have been discussed in Astronomy 101 classes for decades: Why is the sun's corona (the atmosphere beyond ...

Recommended for you

Rosetta captures comet outburst

August 25, 2016

In unprecedented observations made earlier this year, Rosetta unexpectedly captured a dramatic comet outburst that may have been triggered by a landslide.

ALMA finds unexpected trove of gas around larger stars

August 25, 2016

Astronomers using the Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array (ALMA) surveyed dozens of young stars—some Sun-like and others approximately double that size—and discovered that the larger variety have surprisingly ...

35 years on, Voyager's legacy continues at Saturn

August 25, 2016

Saturn, with its alluring rings and numerous moons, has long fascinated stargazers and scientists. After an initial flyby of Pioneer 11 in 1979, humanity got a second, much closer look at this complex planetary system in ...

Rocky planet found orbiting habitable zone of nearest star

August 24, 2016

An international team of astronomers including Carnegie's Paul Butler has found clear evidence of a planet orbiting Proxima Centauri, the closest star to our Solar System. The new world, designated Proxima b, orbits its cool ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

1 / 5 (15) Nov 18, 2013
Closer to an admission that our sun is a magnetar.
1 / 5 (14) Nov 18, 2013
Re: "Our work is a major advance in solving the coronal heating problem, though it doesn't resolve every issue," says Hahn. Chief among them is the cause of the wave damping—the next mystery the team will tackle.

Note that there is a difference between quantitatively explaining *how* it might work, and offering an explanation for what underlying cause exists to make this occur, compared with all of the other possibilities. It's possible to answer that first question without making any progress at all on the second. And this is the real heart of the mystery here: The mystery does not go away just because we figure out equations which can be made to work. The mystery pertains just as much to the WHY as the HOW.

Scientists who don't appreciate this point can lead us into more situations like quantum mechanics -- where we can compute, but the theory exhibits all sorts of explanatory issues.
Nov 19, 2013
This comment has been removed by a moderator.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.