Study finds TV shows with ethnically diverse casts, writers have higher ratings

Oct 09, 2013 by Cynthia Lee

Television viewers are more likely to watch shows that employ racially diverse casts and writers, according to a new study done at UCLA's Ralph J. Bunche Center for African American Studies.

In an analysis of more than 1,000 shows that aired on 67 and during the 2011–12 season, UCLA researchers studying in the entertainment industry found that more viewers were drawn to shows with ethnically diverse lead cast members and writers, while shows reflecting less diversity in their credits attracted smaller audiences.

Racial diversity does make a marked and measurable difference to television's bottom line, said Bunche Center director Darnell Hunt, a professor of sociology in the UCLA College of Letters and Science and author of the new study, "Hollywood Diversity Brief: Spotlight on Cable Television."

"It's clear that people are watching shows that reflect and relate to their own experiences," said Hunt, who has worked for two decades on several projects exploring issues of access and diversity in Hollywood.

Yet, according to the study, released on Oct. 8 at the 27th annual National Association for Multi-Ethnicity in Communications conference in New York, ethnic minorities and women remain woefully underrepresented on both cable and broadcast programs as lead actors, writers and show creators.

"This is one of the first studies, to my knowledge, that attempts to flesh out the relationship between the issue of diversity among cast members and writers and the bottom line," Hunt said. "While this brief is just the first snapshot in what we envision as a multi-year study, it certainly lends support to an argument we have been making for a long time. Everyone in the industry talks about the importance of diversity, but it clearly isn't priority one when decisions are made. And it's not going to be a priority until people realize how it affects the bottom line."

The study is the first in a series of analyses that will be done for the center's Hollywood Advancement Project. The project will track over time whether the TV-and-film industry is employing diverse groups of lead actors, writers, directors, producers and talent agents, and it will identify best practices for widening the pipeline for underrepresented groups.

Researchers found that for cable television shows, median household ratings were highest among those programs with casts that were 31 to 40 percent minority. Only dramas and comedies—not reality shows—were included in this part of the analysis. Examples of shows that reflected this level of diversity were "A.N.T. Farm" (Disney), "The Closer" (TNT) and "Falling Skies" (TNT).

At the other end of the spectrum, ratings were the lowest among shows with casts that were 10 percent minority or less, a category that included 52 shows—the largest number of cable shows in the analysis.

The importance of diversity to the bottom line was just as pronounced in broadcast television as it was in cable during the 2011–12 season, the researchers found. Median household ratings peaked among broadcast that were 41 to 50 percent minority, while ratings took a dive for shows with casts that were 10 percent minority or less.

The study also showed a ratings slump for those shows on with writing staffs that were 10 percent minority or less—the vast majority of shows in the analysis. Median household ratings were lowest for these shows. By contrast, ratings peaked among cable shows with writing staffs that were 11 to 20 percent minority and 41 to 50 percent minority. "In Plain Sight" (USA), "Common Law" (USA) and "Southland" (TNT) were among the eight shows included in these two categories.

This same relationship, however, did not hold completely true for broadcast television. Broadcast shows with the least diverse staffs did not post the lowest ratings. But broadcast shows with the highest ratings had writing staffs that were significantly more diverse—from 21 to 30 percent minority—than those of most broadcast shows.

Researchers also looked at who did a better job in the 2011–12 season—cable or broadcast networks—in reflecting diversity among lead actors and show creators.

"It's a mixed bag when it comes to who did better at this, depending on the variables we looked at," Hunt said. But women and minorities working as actors in lead roles and show creators were underrepresented on both cable and network television, based on their percentage in the U.S. population in 2010, he noted.

With the changing nature of television, the dominance of the networks is clearly waning, according to Hunt. "The fact that we had 61 cable networks in our study would have been unimaginable just a few years ago," he said. "Every network is getting smaller and smaller audiences. Shows can now be produced locally on a cheap budget for the Internet."

With the competition for ratings heated, Hunt said, "It makes sense that if the industry wants to keep up with these changes, it really has to pay close attention to what the audience is looking for."

And, as the researchers point out in the report, with the U.S. population becoming more diverse, "this new emerging America will undoubtedly continue to express its diversifying experiences and tastes by making programming choices that resonate more faithfully with them."

Hunt is the author of the "Hollywood Writers Report," an ongoing analysis for the Writers Guild of America focusing on employment, access and earnings among television and film . He was also the principal investigator on "The African American Television Report," released by the Screen Actors Guild in 2000. In 1993, he served as a media researcher for the U.S. Commission on Civil Rights hearings on diversity in Hollywood.

Explore further: More Canadians streaming television shows via Netflix

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Women, minority writers still face obstacles in Hollywood

May 19, 2011

A new report prepared by a UCLA sociology professor for the Writers Guild of America–West reveals that diverse writers continue to face significant obstacles to employment in Hollywood, particularly in light of ...

More Canadians streaming television shows via Netflix

Sep 26, 2013

More and more Canadians are tuning into online movie streaming websites such as Netflix, but it has not impacted traditional television viewing as feared, according to a report published Thursday.

Viacom, Time Warner Cable settle dispute over app

May 17, 2012

(AP) -- Viacom Inc., the parent of pay TV networks MTV and Comedy Central, has settled a dispute with Time Warner Cable Inc. over whether its subscribers can watch shows like "Jersey Shore" on mobile devices while at home.

Mexico moves to end telecom monopolies

Mar 11, 2013

Mexico's government introduced a draft constitutional reform Monday to end monopolies in telecoms industries that have built some of the country's biggest fortunes.

Recommended for you

Modern population boom traced to pre-industrial roots

12 hours ago

The foundation of the human population explosion, commonly attributed to a sudden surge in industrialization and public health during the 18th and 19th centuries, was actually laid as far back as 2,000 years ...

Researcher looks at the future of higher education

12 hours ago

Most forecasts about the future of higher education have focused on how the institutions themselves will be affected – including the possibility of less demand for classes on campus and fewer tenured faculty members as ...

Now we know why it's so hard to deceive children

13 hours ago

Daily interactions require bargaining, be it for food, money or even making plans. These situations inevitably lead to a conflict of interest as both parties seek to maximise their gains. To deal with them, ...

User comments : 3

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

julianpenrod
1.4 / 5 (10) Oct 09, 2013
The flaws in this "study" are embarrassing.
Among other things, why limit the review to only one season, 2011 – 2012? Also, how many know that a season is only about 4 months on television? The entire collection of material for a series, from September to June, is called a "year".
How diverse were the forms of diversity? How many shows examined didn't have racially diverse casts? How many of those non diverse shows were by smaller ventures, which likely wouldn't get much by way of ratings, anyway?
And, if declared popularity is any key, "Cheers", "The Golden Girls", "The Mary Tyler Moore Show", "Newhart", "The Sopranos", "Breaking Bad", "Mad Men", "The Big Bang Theory", "Two And A Half Men", "How I Met Your Mother" did extremely well with all white casts and, in reruns, may do better than many first run shows with "diverse" casts.
TheGhostofOtto1923
1.4 / 5 (5) Oct 09, 2013
How many questions do you need to ask before it might occur to you that the answers you are looking for might be found in the original paper and not in the freeking press release printed above? Are you really that freeking dense julia?
The flaws in this "study" are embarrassing
The flaws in your thinking processes are embarrassing I think.
Doug_Huffman
1.6 / 5 (9) Oct 09, 2013
Of course pandering to the lowest common denominator will bring higher ratings.

The meanest of the bell curve occupies more area than any other cohort; on the left they are too stupid to operate the on/off switch, and on the right they're too smart to operate the on/off switch.