Impending species loss opens 'compelling' genetic discussion

Oct 09, 2013
Impending species loss opens ‘compelling’ genetic discussion

Somewhere between the ideas of resurrecting extinct species and engaging in genetic engineering of existing ones lies space for a conversation about a third potential approach to fending off conservation disaster.

"Facilitated adaptation" is the name given this concept, and the suggestion to talk about it comes in part from Brett Dickson, assistant research professor at Northern Arizona University.

As coauthor of a comment piece in Nature, Dickson helps bring the topic to the forefront of scientific discussion. As a researcher, his dual affiliation and multiple pursuits illustrate the complexity of proactively facing the potential loss of 40 percent of species by 2050.

At NAU, Dickson directs the Lab of Landscape Ecology and Conservation Biology in the Landscape Conservation Initiative. But he is also president and chief scientist of Conservation Science Partners, a nonprofit organization that brings together experts in various disciplines to address conservation issues such as habitat fragmentation, landscape connectivity and the spread and distribution of infectious diseases across animal populations.

Considering the looming loss of species, Dickson said it is surprising that facilitated adaptation—essentially, taking a genetically proactive approach to improve the prospects of a particular animal population—has not gotten much attention.

"My colleagues and I thought this would be a compelling idea ready for debate, although it's not necessarily ready to be put immediately into widespread practice," Dickson said.

Rather than taking the "very challenging" step of physically moving threatened by climate change, which has been tried with mixed success, facilitated adaptation entails "moving adaptive alleles from one population to another," Dickson said. Alleles determine traits (such as a thick coat of hair versus thin in mammals). So traits that bolster a well-adapted population of a particular species could be transferred to a population under stress.

From a technical standpoint, Dickson said, the science is already being demonstrated with in the plant world. Although facilitated adaptation does not go as far as , the Nature coauthors agree that even such a mitigated step would be drastic, with profound ethical implications.

"If we feel strongly as a society this is something we should explore, then perhaps piloting a program would be warranted," Dickson said, with a caveat: "Facilitated adaptation should not be considered a substitute for preventing the loss of habitats or the that depend on them."

But that's an issue for science and the public to decide after a thorough vetting. For now, Dickson is turning his focus back to efforts he has pursued throughout his career, which puts his dual roles into play; he is drafting language to formalize CSP's already-established connection to NAU.

"The Nature article is part of a larger set of objectives that ties into Conservation Science Partners and me personally," Dickson said. "We're trying to raise the bar for ."

Explore further: Using genes to rescue animal and plants from extinction

More information: www.nature.com/news/ecology-ge… conservation-1.13790

Related Stories

Using genes to rescue animal and plants from extinction

Sep 25, 2013

(Phys.org) —With estimates of losing 15 to 40 percent of the world's species over the next four decades – due to climate change and habitat loss, researchers ponder in the Sept. 26 issue of Nature whether science should ...

Delta picks Microsoft for pilot tablets

Sep 30, 2013

Delta Air Lines plans to buy 11,000 Microsoft Surface 2 tablets for its pilots to replace the heavy bundles of books and maps they haul around now.

Brain rehearsal time ensures lasting memory performance

Feb 14, 2012

University of Alberta researchers have established that the ability of the brain to rehearse or repeat electrical impulses may be absolutely critical in order to make a newly acquired memory more permanent.

Sore thumbs? US text messaging declines

May 02, 2013

Americans are saying goodbye to text messaging, a wireless industry group says, as Internet-based applications such as Apple's Messages are starting to taking over from what was once a cash cow for phone companies.

Hot spells threaten ringtail habitat

Sep 20, 2013

THE potential impacts of anthropogenic global warming on the western ringtail possum (Pseudocheirus occidentals) have been explored in a recent Edith Cowan University research paper.

Recommended for you

Study indicates large raptors in Africa used for bushmeat

19 hours ago

Bushmeat, the use of native animal species for food or commercial food sale, has been heavily documented to be a significant factor in the decline of many species of primates and other mammals. However, a new study indicates ...

Noise pollution impacts fish species differently

21 hours ago

Acoustic disturbance has different effects on different species of fish, according to a new study from the Universities of Bristol and Exeter which tested fish anti-predator behaviour.

User comments : 3

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

Sinister1811
2.1 / 5 (10) Oct 09, 2013
Speeding up evolution? I like that idea. The moment that ethical/moral stuff is placed into science is the moment that it just doesn't go anywhere.
GSwift7
5 / 5 (1) Oct 09, 2013
You can see examples of nature doing this on its own all over the place. One good example is how territorial ranges of polar bears and grizzly bears move north and south from century to century. The two species can interbreed and the grizzly genes seem to dominate, so any time the arctic starts to warm, the grizzly population expands north. (They call the grizzly polar bear hybrid a grolar bear IIRC)

Speeding up evolution? I like that idea. The moment that ethical/moral stuff is placed into science is the moment that it just doesn't go anywhere


I agree. It's just a tool that we can use to survive and be successful, like any other technology. Even if we decide that it's too risky to do on a large scale, there's no harm in figuring out how to do it, just in case we ever need to.

Maybe they can even do something like this to save the honey bees.
rufous
5 / 5 (1) Oct 11, 2013
This is a phenomenon that has occurred since life began exchanging genetic material.

Humans have done this since the time of domestication of both plants and animals.

This needs clarification, if it is to take root.