ChemWiki takes on costly textbooks

Oct 23, 2013

The hefty college textbook, weighty in both pounds and dollars, has long been a staple of student life. But UC Davis chemistry professor Delmar Larsen is on a mission to replace textbooks with an online, open e-textbook network. Larsen's "ChemWiki," launched in 2008 on a shoestring budget, now nets over 2 million visitors a month, making it the most visited domain among the university's websites.

"We're addressing a need out there for vetted information," Larsen said.

ChemWiki recently received its first major funding—a grant of $250,000 from the National Science Foundation to a consortium including UC Davis, Sonoma State University, Diablo Valley College, Contra Costa Community College, Hope College (Michigan) and the University of Minnesota, Morris. The money will support further expansion of the wiki network and the first side-by-side comparison of the ChemWiki versus a standard in classroom teaching.

In spring quarter 2014, half of a UC Davis general chemistry class, about 200 students, will use the standard textbook as their principal reference: The rest, hearing the same lectures from the same professors and studying the same material, will use the ChemWiki. The results will be evaluated by researchers from the Center for Education and Evaluation Services at the UC Davis School of Education.

A single general chemistry textbook for undergraduates can cost hundreds of dollars, with new (and more expensive) editions appearing regularly, Larsen said. Yet the material in such textbooks is well established, in some cases for decades, if not centuries.

"The content hasn't changed, so how do we justify these costs?" he said.

ChemWiki began with entries written by students. Then Larsen realized that much of the material he needed already resides online, scattered across the Internet, in course notes, on professors' websites, and other locations.

"All the content we need for the first two years of undergraduate chemistry already exists online—so we went out and asked for it," Larsen said. When authors responded positively, Larsen and his student wiki-editors worked to adapt the material into the wiki format.

Anyone can contribute to ChemWiki: "Just email me," Larsen says.

Larsen now offers extra credit to students who submit entries, occasionally holding pizza parties to bring in volunteers to write or review pages. He assigns a rating system to new articles based on the author's expertise and experience, with articles moving up as they are edited and vetted. The ChemWiki team is setting up a formal system of volunteer curators responsible for maintaining pages and expanding the wiki.

So far, students are using ChemWiki as a reference and a supplement to, rather than a replacement for, their traditional textbooks, Larsen believes.

ChemWiki is planning a partnership with UC Irvine's OpenChem project, a collection of free, open-access video lectures in undergraduate and graduate level chemistry.

Larsen and collaborators are also developing wikis for other fields, including math, physics, statistics and geology. He envisions an interconnected "STEMWiki hyperlibrary" across science, technology and engineering that meets the needs of both faculty and students.

"Let's say I want to teach enzymology. I might start in biology in the BioWiki, but then I need kinetics from general chemistry in the ChemWiki, and for that I also need calculus from the MathWiki—so I can link from one to the other as a centralized resource," Larsen said.

He has a vision of students reared on video games progressing through a chemistry course by completing tasks, gathering points and "leveling up," just as they would in a video game. It's a style of learning that might suit some , Larsen said.

Ultimately, Larsen hopes to transform the textbook industry. "It's a labor of love," he said.

Explore further: The pig, the fish and the jellyfish: Tracing nervous disorders in humans

Related Stories

Cruise tourists spend less

Apr 30, 2013

More and more cruise ships visit the fjords of Western Norway. But cruise tourists only spend a fraction of what other tourists spend.

The constitutionality of health care reform

Feb 15, 2011

President Obama’s health care reform legislation has been the subject of lively political and legal debate. Many lawsuits have been filed to prevent the implementation of the legislation. These lawsuits claim that ...

Sonification of microbial data

Sep 28, 2012

(Medical Xpress)—Soft horns and a tinkling piano form the backbone of "Fifty Degrees North, Four Degrees West," a jazz number with two interesting twists: it has no composer and no actual musicians. Unless ...

Recommended for you

Nature inspires a greener way to make colorful plastics

5 hours ago

Long before humans figured out how to create colors, nature had already perfected the process—think stunning, bright butterfly wings of many different hues, for example. Now scientists are tapping into ...

New catalyst converts carbon dioxide to fuel

7 hours ago

Scientists from the University of Illinois at Chicago have synthesized a catalyst that improves their system for converting waste carbon dioxide into syngas, a precursor of gasoline and other energy-rich products, bringing ...

Bullet 'fingerprints' to help solve crimes

7 hours ago

Criminals don't just have to worry about their own fingerprints these days: because of a young forensic scientist at The University of Western Australia, they should also be very concerned about their bullets' ...

User comments : 5

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

shavera
3 / 5 (2) Oct 23, 2013
VendicarE
2 / 5 (4) Oct 23, 2013
Excellent.

Think big. Collaborate with others to get the job done.

Destroy Capitalism.
Humpty
1 / 5 (9) Oct 24, 2013
I am always as cynical as, when the same content gets republished for exhorbitant prices, with almost no real change in content.

Who are the cretins giving kick backs to who, in the education system, to get this garbage into the cirriculum?

Bring on the consolidated up to date, E books.
Humpty
1.4 / 5 (10) Oct 24, 2013
Ummmmmm I also express reservation on the issue - as the books SHOULD be available as a PDF for dowload, instead of people HAVING to constantly be hooked into it by a fucking internet connection....

You know????

Or don't the egg heads get it?
DrBookman
not rated yet Oct 25, 2013
Will the students using the textbook get it free too? If not, then you have introduced another variable in the study. Otherwise when examining how the ChemWiki group does in comparison to the textbook group, that group will include many who may not have bought the textbook, or may not buy it until late into the start of the class, or studied from an old edition, or were sharing a textbook, etc. So, it won't answer the question as to which is the best format for students to successfully learn chemistry (ChemWiki vs. standard textbook). In a truly equal comparison study it may turn out that textbooks are still the best format, and other ways need to be addressed as to how to make them less expensive, or possibly how to convince students that they are actually worth the investment in their education and not an optional/deferrable expense.