Who's the ace among aces? New tool helps identify astronauts with better spatial skills

Oct 18, 2013 by Jennifer Chu

On Oct. 30, 2007, astronauts aboard the Space Shuttle Discovery set out on a routine mission: installing two solar panels on the truss, or backbone, of the International Space Station. While the first panel deployed successfully, astronauts noticed a two-foot-wide tear in the second panel.

To repair the tear, crewmembers devised a risky plan, sending an astronaut on a spacewalk while tethered to the shuttle's inspection arm. The mission marked the first time an astronaut had used the robotic arm in such a way—a potentially dangerous undertaking, as a wrong move could have electrocuted the spacewalker. In the end, the mission was a success, due partly to the robotic arm's operators, who were trained to maneuver the multijointed arm with high precision.

Today, all incoming astronauts complete extensive training to learn to operate a similar robotic arm on the space station. But the operation isn't intuitive, and there's a steep learning curve for some.

MIT researchers in the Man Vehicle Laboratory (MVL) are looking for ways to streamline this lengthy training process. They administered standard cognitive spatial tests to 50 astronauts, and compared these initial results with the astronauts' performance in NASA's 30-hour Generic Robotics Training (GRT) course. The researchers found that the initial spatial tests were able to predict the top performers in the more extensive course.

The results, says MVL director Charles Oman, suggest that the initial spatial tests may be used as a screening tool to place low-scorers on an in-depth training track, while accelerating high-scorers through a shortened course.

"Astronaut training time is a precious resource, and we want to use it as efficiently as we can," says Oman, who is a senior research engineer in the Department of Aeronautics and Astronautics. "We want to see if there is an objective way of picking people who may be stars, or identifying people who maybe shouldn't be doing robotics."

Oman and his colleagues have published their results in the journal Acta Astronautica. The paper's co-authors are research scientists Andrew Liu and Alan Natapoff, and graduate research assistant Raquel Galvan.

New tool helps identify astronauts with better spatial skills. Credit: Donna Coveney

Turning the world over

Operating robots in space requires a degree of mental dexterity, as there are few landmarks with which to orient an object. A zero-gravity environment can also add to spatial confusion.

"On Earth, we don't have to remember what things look like upside down," Oman says. "We don't have to be able to turn the world over in our mind to remember which way to turn when we're trying to follow a route."

But mental rotation is an essential spatial skill for maneuvering objects in space, particularly with the space station's . Controlling the arm is a fairly unintuitive process, unlike some other robots whose arms can be moved by a person who makes the same motion.

Instead, astronauts must manipulate the 's arm via two joysticks—one that moves the arm up, down, and sideways, and another that controls the arm's attitude, or tilt. Complicating matters is the system of cameras aboard the station, which view the arm from different angles.

"You're looking at the task and the arm from each camera, and each time, you have to reorient your mind to figure out what you're looking at," Oman says. "If you move the controller to the right, the arm might move another way because the camera is tilted. So that's one of the things that makes it challenging."

Predicting the top of the class

The researchers determined that the spatial skills involved in such robotic operation generally break down into two categories: object rotation, or the ability to imagine how an object looks when rotated, and perspective taking, the ability to imagine how an object or scene looks from different viewpoints. While the two tasks seem similar, Oman says they appear to operate via different pathways in the brain.

He and his team chose three pen-and-paper cognitive spatial tests and one computer-based test to gauge astronauts' skills in object rotation and spatial visualization. Each test involved a number of timed exercises in which an astronaut chose a correct object orientation, given a set of instructions. All four tests were completed in one hour or less.

"Even within the astronaut community, there was a distribution of how good their spatial abilities are, according to the tests we gave them," says Liu, who administered the tests at NASA's Astronaut Training Office in Houston.

Liu worked the test data into a model to predict astronaut performance in NASA's GRT course. The model was able to predict the top performers in the class, as measured by the astronaut's final GRT exam scores.

Daniel Burbank, chief of the extravehicular activity and robotics branch of NASA's Astronaut Office, says that the amount of training receive has increased significantly since the days of space shuttle missions, given the complexity of robotic maneuvers on the International Space Station. Astronauts today are also expected to assume multiple roles, from operating robotics to performing spacewalks.

"It's very helpful and crucial for the crews to be able to build in their head a 3-D model of where all the obstructions are," says Burbank, who has flown as a mission specialist on two shuttle missions, and as a commander on the ISS. "Before expending a lot of resources on training, you'd like some predictive tools to guarantee they would be successful in robotics."

While the researchers caution that such a screening tool is not meant to determine an astronaut's career direction, the spatial tests and model may be used to help customize training. For example, if an astronaut scores low on initial tests, he may be assigned to a more comprehensive course, with extra practice. If he aces the tests, he may be considered for a more abbreviated version of the course.

"An astronaut's schedule is really packed with traveling and other training," Liu says. "So being able to know who's going to require more time is a real boon for planning their schedule."

Explore further: Astronauts exploring the depths

Related Stories

MIT studies robotic training for astronauts

May 29, 2008

The space shuttle's 45-foot robotic arm may look simple and automatic as it gracefully lifts a multi-ton satellite from the cargo bay and lets it drift off into space. Far from it.

Underwater astronaut on the Moon

Sep 12, 2013

ESA astronaut Jean-François Clervoy and ESA astronaut instructor Hervé Stevenin slipped into the roles of Neil Armstrong and Buzz Aldrin last week for an underwater simulation of the historic mission to ...

Astronauts exploring the depths

Oct 07, 2013

Usually, ESA sends astronauts to outer space, but last week six astronauts from around the world spent six days underground to get a taste of working together in extreme conditions.

Space Image: Another view of ISS spacewalker

May 30, 2011

A fish-eye lens attached to an electronic still camera was used to capture this image of NASA astronaut Greg Chamitoff during the mission's fourth STS-134 spacewalk.

Croatian pupils mark EU entry with astronaut chat

Jun 26, 2013

A group of pupils at a Zagreb high school on Wednesday marked their country's July 1 entry into the European Union by talking to an astronaut at the International Space Station (ISS).

Next generation of explorers takes the stage

Aug 21, 2013

NASA Administrator Charles Bolden on Tuesday formally welcomed the eight newest candidates to the astronaut corps and unveiled a space exploration roadmap that makes clear the global community is working together on a unified ...

Recommended for you

Europe sat-nav launch glitch linked to frozen pipe

8 hours ago

A frozen fuel pipe in the upper stage of a Soyuz launcher likely caused the failure last month to place two European navigation satellites in orbit, a source close to the inquiry said Wednesday.

Cyanide ice in Titan's atmosphere

9 hours ago

Gigantic polar clouds of hydrogen cyanide roughly four times the area of the UK are part of the impressive atmospheric diversity of Titan, the largest moon of Saturn, a new study led by Leiden Observatory, ...

Video: Alleged meteor caught on Russian dash cam (again)

13 hours ago

Thanks to the ubiquity of dashboard-mounted video cameras in Russia yet another bright object has been spotted lighting up the sky over Siberia, this time a "meteor-like object" seen on the evening of Saturday, Sept. 27.

User comments : 1

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

philw1776
1 / 5 (7) Oct 18, 2013
Makes sense. I remember doing poorly on a freshman engineering spacial aptitude test administered by the mechanical engineering department. Back then colleges flunked out 2/3rds of engineering students. Fortunately Tufts had an excellent liberal arts program for many of the dropouts. I assured the prof that I was going for an EE degree, not ME. Sad to know that I most probably lacked the right stuff spacial visualization skills for astronaut training as well.