UK taxpayers 'ripped off' by rural broadband roll-out

Sep 26, 2013
File picture shows farm buildings pictured near Otterburn in northeast England on July 8, 2010.

Taxpayers have been "ripped off" by the government's broadband roll-out in rural areas, the head of a powerful spending watchdog said as its damning report was released Thursday.

Senior Labour MP Margaret Hodge, of the House of Commons Public Accounts Committee (PAC), said the awarding of all 26 rural broadband contracts to British Telecom (BT) had left the company in a "quasi-monopolistic position".

The PAC report said the Department for Culture, Media and Sport (DCMS) mismanaged the project, and BT was exploiting its dominant position by restricting access to cost and roll-out information.

"Too many people will not be able to access super-fast broadband because BT will have failed to deliver it to them," Hodge told BBC Radio 4.

"The taxpayer has been ripped off with £1.2 billion going to the shareholders of BT."

The tender process which began in 2011 drew criticism when just two service providers - BT and Fujitsu - were named as approved bidders, with Fujitsu eventually dropping out.

Hodge claimed BT was using its to keep details of local projects confidential, "preventing other suppliers from developing schemes aimed at reaching the remaining 10 percent of premises" still without broadband.

The report said that the remaining 18 contracts, due to be granted by 2017, are also likely to go to BT.

File photo taken on December 18 2012 shows fibre-optic internet cables in the sewers of Paris.

Hodge said are contributing over £230 million more to the programme than forecast in the department's business case, while BT is committing over £200 million less.

She said this, combined with the DCMS admitting the programme would be delivered two years later than planned, meant consumers were "getting a raw deal despite the generous public subsidy".

The report said the department accepted contract terms that were "overly generous" to BT but the government argued the tendering process had been fair, while a BT spokeswoman said it was "disturbed" by claims in the which were "wrong".

She said the company had been "transparent from the start and willing to invest when others have not.

"It is therefore mystifying that we are being criticised for accepting onerous terms in exchange for public subsidy - terms which drove others away. The taxpayer is undoubtedly getting value for money."

A DCMS spokesman said: "We disagree with the views expressed by the PAC which are at odds with the findings of the National Audit Office.

"They found our approach reduced the cost to the taxpayer and reduced risk."

Explore further: Why the SIM card has had its day

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

BT sells 14.1% stake in India's Tech Mahindra

Aug 30, 2012

British telecoms group BT said Thursday that it has completed the sale of a 14.1-percent stake in Indian IT group Tech Mahindra to institutional investors for £158.6 million.

Benefits of Bt corn go beyond rootworm resistance

Feb 06, 2013

Engineered to produce the bacterial toxin, Bt, "Bt corn" resists attack by corn rootworm, a pest that feeds on roots and can cause annual losses of up to $1 billion. But besides merely protecting against these losses, the ...

Researchers identify insect resistance to Bt pesticide

Aug 30, 2011

For the first time, researchers have identified how cabbage looper caterpillars in the field develop resistance to the bacterium Bacillus thuringiensis (Bt), which naturally occurs in the soil and on plants ...

Recommended for you

Why the SIM card has had its day

19 hours ago

The small microchips known as "subscriber identity modules" or SIM cards that are required for mobile phones to log on to a phone network will soon be 25 years old. While mobile phones and network technology ...

The UK doesn't yet need net neutrality regulations

Mar 04, 2015

The net neutrality debate in the US has ended, at least for now, with the Federal Communications Commission ruling for stricter regulation of telecoms and internet service providers (ISPs) in order to maintain ...

Italy adopts plans to shift into Internet fast lane

Mar 04, 2015

Italy's government adopted a six-billion-euro plan Tuesday to modernise its Internet network and improve access to broadband in hopes of shedding its reputation as one of Europe's online laggards.

Phone firms and the quest for the 5G Holy Grail

Mar 03, 2015

Lightning-quick downloads, driverless cars and remote surgery: telecom firms are racing to develop a new generation of "5G" mobile networks that could start to change the world in five years.

User comments : 0

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.