Change thinking to keep animal welfare on agenda

September 17, 2013 by Denise Cahill
Change thinking to keep animal welfare on agenda
Prof Dawkins says providing good welfare simply means the animal is healthy and has what it wants. Credit: Andy Purviance

To keep animal welfare on the political and societal agenda, there needs to be a change in the way we present the argument, a leading international animal ethicist says.

Oxford University's Marian Stamp Dawkins made the claim during the public lecture "Is more efficient food production in conflict with animal welfare?" at UWA this month as part of 2050 Food, a series of three lectures targeting key issues likely to shape the nature of human food.

Professor Dawkins says to make sure animal welfare stays on the agenda, we need to focus on the argument that animals provide a service to humans rather than that animals are conscious, intelligent beings.

"The problem for us is that we do not understand our own human consciousness," Prof Dawkins says.

She also says many other cultures do not share the Western view of animals.

"To convince the unconvinced we need to stress the service value of ," she says.

"Animals matter because they are useful to us."

Using this argument could lead to a reduction in new human diseases, reduce the and also allow food producers to make a living, Prof Dawkins says.

"Seventy-five per cent of new human diseases over the last 10 years have originated from animals or ," she says.

Prof Dawkins says providing good welfare simply means the animal is healthy and has what it wants.

To argue her point, Prof Dawkins used a study she did at a commercial duck farm in the UK, that did not have access to a pond and whose only water was supplied via a nipple.

"Many at commercial farms are kept without bathing water," she says.

"The argument from producers was that if they gave ducks they would get in and dirty the water straight away.

"We asked two questions—do they want it and do they need it?"

Working with the commercial duck farmer, Prof Dawkins gave groups of ducks a choice between a shower, pond or trough or nipple (for drinking water).

"They loved the showers," she says.

"They spent much more of their time under the showers. The nipples they spent very little time with. They clearly want water that they can splash over."

Importantly, she found the ducks with access to showers had better overall health including eyes and feathers than those denied water.

She says it was important to realise may be willing to improve the welfare of the animals they breed for human consumption, but are constrained by costs.

Explore further: How farm animals 'feel' contributes to productivity

Related Stories

Science measures animal welfare

July 16, 2013

A RECENT forum has questioned whether science can inform and improve animal welfare in research and production. The concept was explored at a joint Ag Institute Australia and Australian Society of Animal Protection seminar, ...

Why lab-grown meat is a good thing

August 5, 2013

While the sight of someone eating a very expensive burger is clearly something of a publicity stunt, the underlying idea behind laboratory-grown meat is sound. The research is highly laudable, because what it promises is ...

Recommended for you

Scientists overcome key CRISPR-Cas9 genome editing hurdle

December 1, 2015

Researchers at the Broad Institute of MIT and Harvard and the McGovern Institute for Brain Research at MIT have engineered changes to the revolutionary CRISPR-Cas9 genome editing system that significantly cut down on "off-target" ...

Study finds 'rudimentary' empathy in macaques

December 1, 2015

(—A pair of researchers with Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique and Université Lyon, in France has conducted a study that has shown that macaques have at least some degree of empathy towards their fellow ...

Which came first—the sponge or the comb jelly?

December 1, 2015

Bristol study reaffirms classical view of early animal evolution. Whether sponges or comb jellies (also known as sea gooseberries) represent the oldest extant animal phylum is of crucial importance to our understanding of ...

Trap-jaw ants exhibit previously unseen jumping behavior

December 1, 2015

A species of trap-jaw ant has been found to exhibit a previously unseen jumping behavior, using its legs rather than its powerful jaws. The discovery makes this species, Odontomachus rixosus, the only species of ant that ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.