Abolish 'profiteering' Train Operating Companies, says report

Sep 05, 2013

University of Manchester experts have called for the abolition of the rail franchising system which they say allows Train Operating Companies to profiteer from hidden public subsidies, in a new report.

The team at the University's ESRC Centre for Research of Socio-Cultural change (CRESC) says the Association of Train Operating Companies (ATOC) is wrong to argue the system is working.

The report also casts doubt on the TOCs' claims that it is their marketing effort rather than GDP growth which drives increasing passenger numbers.

In a vociferous reaction to CRESC's earlier TUC sponsored research entitled The Great Train Robbery , Richard Branson defended Virgin's record in a Guardian column.

And ATOC weighed in with its own report, Growth and Prosperity, based on KPMG research.

Professor Karel Williams, from The University of Manchester and co-Director of CRESC said: "The TOCs do not confront the issue of why we need private train operators who receive large subsidies, invest almost no capital and take very little risk because they can and do walk away from loss making franchises with modest penalties and no claw back.

"Our research challenges ATOC claims about the success of the private and shows how the franchising system allows TOCs to distribute profit from an undisclosed public subsidy.

"The financial outcome is that TOCs return on capital employed is 121.6% -an annual return of £1.21 for every £1 invested. So why is the taxpayer licensing this level of returns? We say it would make sense to stop the extraction from the public purse by abolishing the private Train Operating Companies. That would cost the taxpayer nothing if it was done as franchises expired.

"We need to stop consuming ATOC narratives about success and make plans to integrate train and track operations within a new not for profit company."

According to CRESC's latest report, ATOC cannot explain away the low track access charges, which provide a large indirect subsidy to all train operators.

The 'dysfunctional system' allows the state and the taxpayer to fund rail investment and guarantees Network Rail's increasingly unsustainable debt mountain.

He added: "The train operators defend themselves by restating what we call a "trade narrative" about how private operators deliver social benefits.

"This is part of a much larger political problem about how privatisation and outsourcing entrenches corporate players with self- serving narratives that overestimate their contribution"

Virgin Railways, for example, is hugely subsidy dependent according to the researchers. Net direct subsidy alone amounts to nearly £2billion and indirect subsidy through low track access charges has increased in recent years as direct subsidy declines. These subsidies have allowed £460 million to be paid out as dividends.

The new report aggregates the results of all the private train operators and shows they have just £219 million of capital employed on which they earn a pre-tax return on capital employed of 121.8%

The publicly funded Network Rail has £36 billion of capital employed on which it has a wafer thin return of 1.34%.

A report is titled 'The Conceit of Enterprise: train operators and trade narrative .'

Explore further: Economist probes the high cost of health care

More information: www.cresc.ac.uk/news/news-from… ilways-reform-agenda

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Japan's maglev train runs test at over 310 mph (w/ Video)

Sep 02, 2013

(Phys.org) —Moving toward its goal of building a high-speed magnetic levitation (maglev) train line between Tokyo and Osaka, Central Japan Railway Co has resumed testing of its L0 (L Zero) train—demonstrating ...

New 311mph maglev train in Japan passes initial tests

Jun 06, 2013

(Phys.org) —Engineers with Central Japan Railway Co. have put their newest maglev L0 train through initial testing and report the new high-speed train is on course for commercial deployment by 2027. The ...

Recommended for you

Economist probes the high cost of health care

Mar 27, 2015

When Zack Cooper arrived at Yale as assistant professor of public health and economics, he gained access to a first-of-its-kind dataset. Working with the non-profit Health Care Cost Institute, Cooper and ...

Cash remains king in Chile but its days could be numbered

Mar 26, 2015

For more than a year now, Chileans have endured a crisis of cash access. Despite global moves toward new forms of payment such as contactless and mobile transfers, the crisis in Chile highlights the continuing ...

Will you ever pay off your student loan?

Mar 25, 2015

Would-be participants of higher education must be given full and transparent advice before they accumulate debts as students that follow them into the workplace, according to a report published in the International Journal of ...

User comments : 1

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

1 / 5 (1) Sep 05, 2013
Hmm - maybe this contains some truth but the system is (rightly or wrongly) a subsidised public service so somebody somewhere will get the taxpayers bit. And the train operators have set the pace in reducing delays, breakdowns etc. with the "not for profit" infrastructure manager trailing behind.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.