Fees cancel tax advantage of college savings plans

Aug 28, 2013 by Bill Steele
Fees cancel tax advantage of college savings plans
The final value of a college savings plan depends on management fees. Parents purchasing a mutual fund portfolio for a newborn child and investing $10,000 each year until the child starts college (18 years) would finally have almost $415,000 (solid line). But the future value of a 529 tax-exempt college savings plan with the same amount invested depends on the additional fees -- beyond those charged by the underlying mutual funds -- charged by the 529 plan (dashed line). A Cornell study shows that the higher the tax savings in your state, the more 529 plans charge. (The example assumes a 25 percent federal income tax rate, 5 percent state tax rate and a 10 percent annual gross return on investment.)

(Phys.org) —Government efforts to make it easier to save for college have unintended consequences, according to a Cornell economist. When you get a tax deduction for contributing to a college savings plan, your savings may be more than consumed by higher fees charged by plan administrators, according to research by Vicki Bogan, associate professor in the Charles H. Dyson School of Applied Economics and Management. Parents may be better off putting their money in ordinary, non-tax-exempt investments, she suggested.

"The government policies designed to make college more affordable could be creating market frictions which enable investment firms to charge excess fees," Bogan said, adding that federal regulation may be needed "to preclude financial management companies from appropriating the benefits intended for individuals."

Bogan's analysis will appear in a forthcoming issue of the journal Contemporary Economic Policy.

In the early 2000s, Section 529 of the Internal Revenue Code was amended to create investment plans that would encourage parents to save for their children's education. As a result almost every state offers "529 plans" that allow parents to deduct contributions from their . Like 401(k) retirement plans, 529 plans usually invest in a group of mutual funds.

Analyzing data from 2002 to 2006, Bogan found that the greater the tax advantage a state offered, the higher the fees charged by investment managers, even after controlling for such factors as the amount of competition in a state and the administrative structure of the plan. The statistics support an assertion that investment management companies set their fees based on the amount of tax saving offered by the state, she said. And if the state is receiving a share of the fees charged by plan administrators, Bogan added, it has an incentive not to regulate those fees, creating a " risk."

Bogan offers the example of parents investing $10,000 a year in a typical plan, starting when a child is born. Tax savings will amount to around $500 a year, depending on the investor's federal bracket, and the parents would invest that money back in the plan. But fees – based on the growing value of the fund – will quickly reach $585 a year. "By year four or five…the annual asset-based fees completely cannibalize the state taxable income benefit," Bogan reported. At the end of 18 years, the 529 fund could be worth thousands less than an ordinary mutual fund, depending on the fees charged.

"Households would be well advised to educate themselves about each specific educational savings plan prior to investing," Bogan concluded.

Explore further: Economist probes the high cost of health care

Related Stories

Expert: Taxation of retirement income in need of reform

Aug 12, 2013

Although planning for a comfortable retirement is a mainstay of public discussion, far less attention has been paid to the tax consequences of generating retirement income, says a University of Illinois expert on taxation ...

Mental health affects investment decisions, study shows

Jun 24, 2010

(PhysOrg.com) -- A paper co-authored by Cornell economist Vicki Bogan suggests that mental health issues or substance abuse in a household may have an effect on investment decisions and management of retirement assets.

Recommended for you

Do government technology investments pay off?

4 hours ago

Studies confirm that IT investments in companies improve productivity and efficiency. University of Michigan professor M.S. Krishnan wondered if the same was true for government.

Study finds assisted housing works, but it could be improved

4 hours ago

Two researchers from the University of Kansas Department of Urban Planning have just completed a study on the locations of assisted housing units and assisted households across the nation. It examines one of the key issues ...

Economist probes the high cost of health care

Mar 27, 2015

When Zack Cooper arrived at Yale as assistant professor of public health and economics, he gained access to a first-of-its-kind dataset. Working with the non-profit Health Care Cost Institute, Cooper and ...

Cash remains king in Chile but its days could be numbered

Mar 26, 2015

For more than a year now, Chileans have endured a crisis of cash access. Despite global moves toward new forms of payment such as contactless and mobile transfers, the crisis in Chile highlights the continuing ...

User comments : 0

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.