Remembering a famous debate 400 years ago and water's still-unsolved mysteries

Aug 28, 2013

For online and print audiences deep into lazy late-summer-day reading, yearning for diversions from everyday cares, how about a glimpse 400 years back in time at a famous clash between Galileo and an arch-enemy over why ice floats on water? That debate, between a giant in the history of science and a little-remembered naysayer who challenged Galileo's idea that Earth revolves around the sun, is the topic of a story in the current edition of Chemical & Engineering News. C&EN is the weekly newsmagazine of the American Chemical Society, the world's largest scientific society.

Sarah Everts, C&EN senior editor, focuses on a 3-day debate between Galileo and Lodovico delle Colombe that was a sensation among the literati of 17th century Florence, Italy. Though Galileo correctly argued that ice floats because it is less dense than liquid water, delle Colombe stole the show on the last day by placing a thin wafer of ebony, a material more dense than water, on top of water, where it floated. Scientists now know that some materials denser than water—such as a paper clip—can sometimes float if placed carefully on the surface. That's because of a property of liquids termed "surface tension." But it did not invalidate Galileo's explanation.

The story describes how scientists met in Florence in July to commemorate the 400th anniversary of the debate. That meeting focused on the surprising mysteries and scientific controversies that still persist about . Water, H2O, may be a very simple molecule, made of two atoms of hydrogen bonded to one atom of oxygen. But scientists still are striving to understand some of the properties of the substance that covers 70 percent of Earth's surface and makes up almost 60 percent of an adult human body.

Explore further: Chemists tackle battery overcharge problem

More information: "Galileo on Ice" cen.acs.org/articles/91/i34/Galileo-Ice.html

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Galileo didn't invent thermometer that bears his name

Sep 05, 2012

The great Italian scientist Galileo may have been the first person to use a telescope to observe the heavens, helping spark the scientific revolution of the 16th century, but Galileo definitely did not in ...

Mapping the chemistry needed for life at Europa

Apr 05, 2013

(Phys.org) —A new paper led by a NASA researcher shows that hydrogen peroxide is abundant across much of the surface of Jupiter's moon Europa. The authors argue that if the peroxide on the surface of Europa ...

A new sense of urgency for energy cane and other energy crops

Aug 14, 2013

"Energy cane" may sound like a trendy sports drink, but it actually is among a new generation of energy crops that could yield up to 5 times more ethanol per acre than corn. They are the topic of the cover story in this week's ...

Chemical company giants stall with global economy

Jul 31, 2013

The world's 50 largest chemical companies—with combined 2012 sales of almost $1 trillion and products that touch the lives of people everywhere—are the topic of the cover story in the current edition of Chemical & En ...

Meeting the 'grand challenge' of a sustainable water supply

May 22, 2013

Scientists and engineers must join together in a major new effort to educate the public and decision makers on a crisis in providing Earth's people with clean water that looms ahead in the 21st century. That's the focus of ...

Recommended for you

Chemists tackle battery overcharge problem

Oct 17, 2014

Research from the University of Kentucky Department of Chemistry will help batteries resist overcharging, improving the safety of electronics from cell phones to airplanes.

Surface properties command attention

Oct 17, 2014

Whether working on preventing corrosion for undersea oil fields and nuclear power plants, or for producing electricity from fuel cells or oxygen from electrolyzers for travel to Mars, associate professor ...

User comments : 0