Plant cladding keeps the temperature cool indoors despite the heat outside

Aug 06, 2013
Aitor Erkoreka-Gonzalez, industrial engineer and holder of a PhD in thermal engineering from the UPV/EHU-University of the Basque Country. Credit: UPV/EHU

Aitor Erkoreka, a UPV/EHU lecturer and researcher, has shown that green roofs are ideal for places where it is very hot in summer. So, by means of these claddings less air conditioning is needed than with conventional roofs; the same degree of comfort is achieved and therefore energy consumption is reduced. However, a suitable irrigation system is essential to obtain good results.

Having plants on the roofs of buildings instead of the usual gravel offers a range of advantages. Beyond the aesthetic aspect, the existence of many buildings of this type prevents the formation of an island of heat in towns and cities, and reduces the risk of floods in the . What is more, green roofs usually support many and are useful for tackling atmospheric and acoustic pollution.

Aitor Erkoreka, a PhD holder in thermal engineering from the UPV/EHU, has studied whether they are advantageous from the perspective, and has confirmed that they are suitable in some cases, but not all.

This was in fact the subject chosen for his thesis: to compare green roofs with gravel ones in terms of their thermal and hygroscopic behaviour. It was in fact a building contractor that wanted to carry out a study into the two kinds of roofing for a prefabricated modular construction project. The units measuring 6.6m long, 3.3m wide and 3m high, are mass produced and assembled at the final destination (buildings of up to 8 floors can be built). Erkoreka used the Paslink methodology to conduct the study of the two roofing types and carried out experiments under extreme .

That way he was able to show that there are basically two factors that make green roofing useful on an energy and economic level. Firstly, in the place where the building is located the use of cooling systems has to be extremely necessary, and secondly, the roof must have a suitable .

Evapotranspiration is the key

Erkoreka conducted simulations in different climates and observed that in very sunny places the plant roofing is more effective than traditional insulation to protect against the interior heat of the houses.

According to the researcher, this is due to the evapotranspiration of the plants: "In summer, a considerable proportion of the solar energy entering houses does so through the roof. However, if we landscape a roof that already has traditional insulation, to a certain extent we can prevent the house from heating up. Plants absorb water through their roots and release water in the form of vapour through their leaves. And they get the energy they need for this from the sun. That way, rather than getting inside houses, solar energy is used by the plants for photosynthesis and . That prevents the temperature on the outside surface of the house from rising. According to the data obtained by Erkoreka, with this method the heat that gets into buildings through the roof can be reduced by 75%, resulting in reduced use of cooling systems.

But, as Erkoreka points out, it is "essential" that the plants are watered: "We have seen that in very sunny places and in the absence of rain the green roof dries out completely within a week unless it is watered (with a green roof about 10cm thick or less and most of them have these features). And in that case it is of no use whatsoever. What is more, the plants and earth absorb radiation better than gravel so the need for increases." Specifically, a dry green roof can increase the need for cooling by 65% compared with a traditional roof."

That is why Erkoreka has also taken into account the cost of irrigation when comparing the green roof with the gravel one. And he has reached the conclusion that more savings are made in the consumption of a cooling system than through what is spent on the watering system. In other words, from the economic perspective, in places that have very hot summers, it is worthwhile having a green roof fitted, despite the fact that it needs watering and proper care.

However, the researcher believes that in winter it is not so advantageous. "In winter we're after the opposite; in other words, we don't want the heat to get out. During that season the plants are not very active, the earth tends to be damp because it usually rains. That makes the external surface of the roof colder than if it had no earth, so the heat loss with a green roof may be greater than with a traditional one." So the use of a landscaped roof is only recommended in places with mild, fairly dry winters.

Erkoreka sums up the results of his thesis thus: "Just bearing in mind the thermal functioning of the roof, in places where it is not too hot in summer, it is not a good idea to have a green roof fitted, because it would be cheaper to have insulation that is 1 or 2 cm thicker both in the summer and in the winter. But in very sunny places where there is a great need for cooling, a is recommended as it would reduce the demand for cooling considerably. Finally, he points out that a suitable watering system is necessary.

Explore further: Imaginative ideas for a 'greenlight district' in Amsterdam

Provided by Universidad del Pais Vasco

5 /5 (5 votes)
add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Solar panels keep buildings cool

Jul 18, 2011

Those solar panels on top of your roof aren't just providing clean power; they are cooling your house, or your workplace, too, according to a team of researchers led by Jan Kleissl, a professor of environmental ...

Recommended for you

Image: Testing electric propulsion

7 hours ago

On Aug. 19, National Aviation Day, a lot of people are reflecting on how far aviation has come in the last century. Could this be the future – a plane with many electric motors that can hover like a helicopter ...

Where's the real value in Tesla's patent pledge?

8 hours ago

With the much-anticipated arrival next month of electric vehicle manufacturer Tesla's Model S to Australian shores, it's a good time to revisit Tesla's pledge to freely share patents. ...

New type of solar concentrator desn't block the view

22 hours ago

(Phys.org) —A team of researchers at Michigan State University has developed a new type of solar concentrator that when placed over a window creates solar energy while allowing people to actually see through ...

Asian inventions dominate energy storage systems

23 hours ago

In recent years, the number of patent applications for electrochemical energy storage technologies has soared. According to a study by the Technical University Munich, the largest volume of applications is ...

User comments : 0