Movement without muscles study in insects could inspire robot and prosthetic limb developments

July 18, 2013
Movement without muscles study in insects could inspire robot and prosthetic limb developments
The image shows the head and part of the front legs of a female horsehead grasshopper (Pseudoproscopia scabra) used in the Current Biology article. The insect has an elongated body-form that closely resembles that of a stick insect, but it is actually a grasshopper, and can jump surprisingly well considering its ungainly appearance. Credit: Tom Matheson.

Neurobiologists from the University of Leicester have shown that insect limbs can move without muscles – a finding that may provide engineers with new ways to improve the control of robotic and prosthetic limbs.

Their work helps to explain how insects control their movements using a close interplay of neuronal control and 'clever biomechanical tricks,' says lead researcher Dr Tom Matheson, a Reader in Neurobiology at the University of Leicester.

In a study published today in the journal Current Biology, the researchers show that the structure of some insect causes the legs to move even in the absence of muscles. So-called 'passive joint forces' serve to return the limb back towards a preferred resting position.

The passive movements differ in limbs that have different behavioural roles and different musculature, suggesting that the joint structures are specifically adapted to complement muscle forces. The researchers propose a motor control scheme for insect limb joints in which not all movements are driven by muscles.

The study was funded by the Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council (BBSRC), The Royal Society, and the Heinrich Hertz-Foundation of the German State of North Rhine-Westphalia.

Dr Matheson, of the Department of Biology, said:

"It is well known that some animals store energy in elastic muscle tendons and other structures. Such energy storage permits forces to be applied explosively to generate movements that are much more rapid than those which may be generated by muscle contractions alone. This is, for example, crucial when grasshoppers or fleas jump.

Movement without muscles study in insects could inspire robot and prosthetic limb developments
The image shows a locust (Schistocerca gregaria) used in the Current Biology article. The insect has greatly enlarged hind legs which propel the animal into the air when it jumps. The femur-tibia joints ("knee" joints) are clearly visible in all the legs, and it is evident that those of the hind leg are enlarged and strengthened with dark cuticle to withstand the forces involved in jumping. This specimen is 7cm long. Credit: Tom Matheson

"This University of Leicester study provides a new insight into the ways that mechanisms can operate in a much wider range of movements.

"Our work set out to identify how the biomechanical properties of the limbs of a range of insects influence relatively slow movements such as those that occur during walking, scratching or climbing. The surprising result was that although some movements are influenced by properties of the muscles and tendons, other movements are generated by forces that arise from within the joints themselves.

"Even when we removed all of the muscles and associated tissues from a particular joint at the 'knee' of a locust, the lower part of the limb (the tibia) still moved back towards a midpoint from extended angles."

Dr Matheson said that it was known from previous studies that some movements can be generated by spring-like properties of limbs, but the team was surprised to find passive forces that contribute to almost all movements made by the limbs that were studied - not just the highly specialised rapid movements needed to propel powerful jumps and kicks.

"We expected the forces to be generated within the muscles of the leg, but found that some continued to occur even when we detached both muscles – the extensor and the flexor tibiae – from the tibia.

"In the locust hind leg, which is specialised for jumping and kicking, the extensor muscle is much larger and stronger than the antagonist flexor muscle. This enables the animal to generate powerful kicks and jumps propelled by extensions of the tibia that are driven by contractions of the extensor muscle. When locusts prepare to jump, large amounts of energy generated by the extensor muscle are stored in the muscle's tendon and in the hard exoskeleton of the leg.

"Surprisingly, we noticed that when the muscles were removed, the tibia naturally flexed back towards a midpoint, and we hypothesised that these passive return movements might be counterbalancing the strong extensor muscle."

Jan M. Ache, a Masters student from the University of Cologne who worked in Matheson's lab and is the first author on the paper, continues: "To test this idea we looked at the literature and examined other legs where the extensor and flexor muscles are more closely balanced in size or strength, or where the flexor is stronger than the extensor.

"We found that the passive joint forces really do counterbalance the stronger of the flexor or extensor muscle in the animals and legs we looked at. In the horsehead grasshopper, for example, passive joint forces even differ between the middle legs (which are primarily used for walking) and the hind legs (which are adapted for jumping), even in the same individual animal. In both pairs of legs, the passive joint forces support the weaker muscle.

"This could be very important for the generation of movements in insects because the passive forces enable a transfer of energy from the stronger to the weaker muscle."

This work helps to explain how insects control their movements using a close interplay of neuronal control and clever biomechanical tricks. Using balanced passive forces may provide engineers with new ways to improve the control of robotic and , say the researchers.

Dr Matheson concluded: "We hope that our work on locusts and grasshoppers will spur a new understanding of how limbs work and can be controlled, by not just insects, but by other animals, people, and even by robots."

Explore further: Frogs' amazing leaps due to springy tendons

Related Stories

Frogs' amazing leaps due to springy tendons

November 16, 2011

Some species of frogs and many other animals are able to jump far beyond what appear to be their capabilities. The trained contestants in the frog-jumping competition in Calaveras County, Calif., come to mind, but even ordinary ...

It's all in the way we move

March 13, 2013

When, how and why modern humans first stood up and walked on two legs is considered to be one of the greatest missing links in our evolutionary history. Scientists have gone to the far ends of the earth – and the wonderful ...

Muscle power: Bats power take-off using recycled energy

July 5, 2013

Bats are uniquely able to stretch and store energy in their bicep and tricep tendons during take-off and climbing flight, giving them an extra power boost. A new study on fruitbats, to be presented at the meeting of the Society ...

The evolution of fins to limbs in the land invasion race

July 5, 2013

Why did animals with limbs win the race to invade land over those with fins? A new study comparing the forces acting on fins of mudskipper fish and on the forelimbs of tiger salamanders can now be used to analyze early fossils ...

Recommended for you

Study suggests fish can experience 'emotional fever'

November 25, 2015

(—A small team of researchers from the U.K. and Spain has found via lab study that at least one type of fish is capable of experiencing 'emotional fever,' which suggests it may qualify as a sentient being. In their ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.