'Horror film' puts Internet privacy under spotlight

Jul 19, 2013 by Robert Macpherson
File picture shows a woman using her mobile phone. Independent filmmaker Cullen Hoback's film "Terms and Conditions May Apply," raises disturbing questions about the mountains of online data being collected, shared and stored by governments and Internet giants alike.

Stalking isn't Cullen Hoback's style, but the chance to confront Mark Zuckerberg about the dark side of the Internet was just too good to pass on.

"Mr Zuckerberg? I'm working on a documentary," the independent filmmaker asked the Facebook founder, strolling in a T-shirt and jeans on the leafy sidewalk outside his southern California home.

"I was wondering if I could just ask you a couple of questions? Do you still think privacy is dead? What are your real thoughts on privacy?"

"Are you guys recording?" Zuckerberg sheepishly replied. "Will you please not?"

"I can stop," said Hoback, switching off his video camera, prompting Zuckerberg to loosen up, smile and invite Hoback to connect with Facebook's PR team—unaware that Hoback was still recording with a pair of spy glasses.

It's a telling scene in "Terms and Conditions May Apply," in which Hoback raises disturbing questions about the mountains of online data being collected, shared and stored by governments and Internet giants alike.

The title derives from the rambling fine print most Internet users never bother to read when they sign on to a new online service or app—blissfully ignoring that they're entering into a legally binding contract.

"I think the craziest thing about this whole experience is that I didn't realize I was making a ," the Los Angeles-based Hoback told AFP in a telephone interview.

Its release dovetails, by coincidence, with revelations from former National Security Agency (NSA) contractor Edward Snowden about the global scale of US online surveillance.

Snowden, currently stuck in a Moscow airport hoping for asylum, has revealed how major telephone companies are sharing customers' call data with the NSA, the secretive US electronic intelligence service.

Independent film maker Cullen Hoback and John Ramos attend the Terms And Conditions May Apply: Privacy Invasion Party at the Fender music lounge on January 21, 2013 in Park City, Utah. Hoback's film "Terms and Conditions May Apply," raises disturbing questions about the mountains of online data being collected, shared and stored by governments and Internet giants alike.

He also lifted a veil on the PRISM program that enables the NSA to issue directives to Internet services like Google or Facebook for access to non-Americans' emails, online chats, pictures, files and videos.

"I think there was already a pretty strong concern in the population" about online privacy, Hoback told AFP.

"But everything that's happened around Snowden and the PRISM scandal and the consistent revelations that are coming out right now are, I think, elevating interest in the film to a whole new level."

Two years in the making, "Terms and Conditions" was pretty much complete by the time Snowden came forward, leaving Hoback just enough time to tack a quick mention of the whistleblower onto the end of his film.

"The story is constantly evolving, and it's hard sometimes to put the keyboard down and stop editing," he said.

While it makes no blockbuster revelations, "Terms and Conditions" succeeds in weaving a series of Internet privacy issues over the years into a single narrative that's still playing itself out in real life.

For a typical Internet user, it says, it would take 180 hours—the equivalent of one full month of work a year—to fully read all the terms and conditions attached to his or her favorite websites.

"They're poorly written and they're exhaustive. They take into perpetuity everything you could ever imagine," said Hoback, for whom Internet privacy is "the biggest civil liberties issue of our time."

File picture shows a woman using Google on her tablet. Independent filmmaker Cullen Hoback's film "Terms and Conditions May Apply," raises disturbing questions about the mountains of online data being collected, shared and stored by governments and Internet giants alike.

Google's terms of service, for instance, clocks in at 1,711 words, according to an AFP count, not including a separate 2,382-word privacy policy that is still about 1,000 words shorter than the Google Chrome browser policy.

"Terms and Conditions" also explains how Internet users, by clicking on a website's "agree" button, consent to their online lives being archived, shared with third parties or passed on to government agencies without notice.

"I really think of the audience as the main character, because this has been happening to us for all of these years," said Hoback, whose 2007 documentary "Monster Camp" examined the cult world of action-figure enthusiasts.

"The problem is, right now, you either get the service (you want to use on the Internet) or you don't," he said. "There's no one sitting at your side of the table negotiating these contracts."

File picture shows the splash page for Internet social media giant Facebook. Independent filmmaker Cullen Hoback's film "Terms and Conditions May Apply," raises disturbing questions about the mountains of online data being collected, shared and stored by governments and Internet giants alike.

As for his sidewalk encounter with Zuckerberg, whose social media colossus has come under fire for modifying its user policies without notice, Hoback said he wanted to make a point.

"I just wanted him to say, 'Look, I don't want you to record me,' and I wanted to say, 'Look, I don't want you to record us'," he said. "That was really the motive there."

The film's website is tacma.net.

Explore further: Ecuador heralds 'digital currency' plans

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

EU wants privacy guarantees from US amid Prism crisis

Jun 11, 2013

The EU said Tuesday it will seek a strong commitment from the United States to respect the rights of European citizens, following revelations that Washington is running a worldwide Internet surveillance programme.

Venezuelans told to 'unfriend' Facebook over US spying

Jul 11, 2013

A government minister in Venezuela, which has offered fugitive US intelligence leaker Edward Snowden asylum, is urging her countrymen to cancel their Facebook accounts lest they be targeted by US snooping.

Google, Facebook condemn online spying

Jun 08, 2013

Google chief Larry Page and Facebook co-founder Mark Zuckerberg condemned online spying Friday and called for governments to be more revealing about snooping on the Internet.

Recommended for you

'SwaziLeaks' looks to shake up jet-setting monarchy

12 hours ago

As WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange prepares to end a two-year forced stay at Ecuador's London embassy, he may take comfort in knowing he inspired resistance to secrecy in places as far away as Swaziland.

Ecuador heralds 'digital currency' plans

12 hours ago

Ecuador is planning to create the world's first government-issued digital currency, which some analysts believe could be a first step toward abandoning the country's existing currency, the U.S. dollar, which ...

WEF unveils 'crowdsourcing' push on how to run the Web

Aug 28, 2014

The World Economic Forum unveiled a project on Thursday aimed at connecting governments, businesses, academia, technicians and civil society worldwide to brainstorm the best ways to govern the Internet.

Study: Social media users shy away from opinions

Aug 26, 2014

People on Facebook and Twitter say they are less likely to share their opinions on hot-button issues, even when they are offline, according to a surprising new survey by the Pew Research Center.

User comments : 1

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

alfie_null
3 / 5 (1) Jul 19, 2013
"They're poorly written and they're exhaustive. They take into perpetuity everything you could ever imagine," said Hoback, for whom Internet privacy is "the biggest civil liberties issue of our time."

They're not poorly written. They are written in a foreign language, Legal, whose purpose isn't to communicate.