The long history of 'Eurasian' identity

Jul 19, 2013 by Peter Dizikes, Mit News Office
The long history of ‘Eurasian’ identity
Mae Watkins Franking and her children Credit: Jon Sachs

In 2001, a Time magazine story heralded a "Eurasian Invasion" in the United States, symbolized by multiethnic celebrities such as golfer Tiger Woods and model Li Jiaxin. People of mixed Asian and Western descent, the piece stated, had become "the poster children of globalization" at the turn of the millennium.

Perhaps, although as MIT historian Emma Teng chronicles in a new book, relationships and marriages between Westerners and Asians constitute a far older and richer phenomenon than is usually recognized. The issue of Eurasian identity was already a matter of discussion among public intellectuals in the 19th century, and became more common by the first decades of the 20th century.

Consider the case of Mae Watkins, an American who in the early 1900s met Tiam Hock Franking, a Chinese youth, at Ann Arbor High School in Michigan. As students at the University of Michigan they married, and in so doing, stepped into a legal minefield. While intermarriage between whites and Chinese was allowed in Michigan at the time, a 1907 U.S. law removed American citizenship from women who married foreign nationals. So the couple moved to China in 1914, although technically, China prohibited marriages between Chinese students abroad and foreign women.

The couple's oldest child, a son born in the United States, had American citizenship. But their two daughters, born in China, could not gain American citizenship until the 1940s. And Mae Watkins Franking, for her part, accepted her new national and , which she described in a ghostwritten memoir published in the 1920s.

"She did fully embrace her Chinese identity," says Teng, the T.T. and Wei Fong Chao Associate Professor of Asian Civilizations. "She considered herself to be Chinese."

For the Frankings and many other mixed families, identity is a complicated matter played out in evolving legal, cultural and political arenas. As Teng writes in her book—"Eurasian: Mixed Identities in the United States, China, and Hong Kong, 1842-1943," published this month by the University of California Press—that has been the case for more than 150 years.

'Of good to both sides'

Views on multiracial people differ from country to country. Americans have often tended to label people as non-Caucasian if either parent is from another ethnicity, but in China, children were traditionally assigned the same ethnic identity as their fathers. As Teng recounts in the book, these definitions shaped lives and led to unusual circumstances for many people. The prominent Hong Kong businessman and philanthropist Robert Ho Tung, for one, was born in 1862 to a Dutch father and Chinese mother, then became a dual Chinese and British subject; choosing to affiliate himself with the Chinese, he used a Chinese surname, and strictly upheld Chinese traditions within his family.

By then, the subject of multiethnic mixing was actually the subject of some public debate, as Teng details. Soon after the acceleration of China's interaction with the outside world in the 1840s, a series of Chinese intellectuals—including Kang Youwei, Wu Tingfang, Pan Guangdan and Wu Jingchao—started making the case in favor of mixed Euro-Asian lineages, which would be "productive of good to both sides," in Wu Tingfang's words.

Such views were rarer in the United States and Europe, although Teng did locate a handful of English-language scholars and missionaries who advocated Eurasian mixing at roughly the same time—as well as texts such as Franking's, which are based on firsthand experience.

Indeed, Teng's book synthesizes research from memoirs and a wide variety of archival materials to reconstruct the Eurasian experience in Shanghai, Hong Kong, California, New York and other places.

As Teng acknowledges, her work is not intended to be a comprehensive history; among other things, the archival record contains proportionately more evidence about the well-off and literate than it does about, say, uneducated and more transient workers.

"Most of the working-class people didn't leave written records," Teng acknowledges. That would include the thousands of Chinese workers who came to the United States in the 1860s to complete the first transcontinental railroad, for instance. Yet Teng had the good fortune to meet one source whose great-grandfather, one of the early "railroad Chinese," married an Irish-American woman during his time in San Francisco.

Students and teaching driving research

To a significant extent, Teng says, the genesis of the project came from her experiences with students at MIT, where she has taught since 1995. This is her second book; her first, on Chinese colonial travel writing, was published in 2004.

Scholars have responded positively to "Eurasian." Evelyn Hu-Dehart, a historian at Brown University, calls it a "truly transnational and multicultural intellectual project" that draws on English and Chinese sources "with facility and depth," while Kornel Chang, a historian at Rutgers University at Newark, calls it "beautifully written and thoughtfully crafted."

For her part, Teng says she hopes the book will help people think critically about the assumptions we still make today when discussing ethnicity and identity. As she puts it, "I don't think we've moved away as much as we should from biology" as a way of categorizing people. Even "the very discussion of mixed races" as a common feature of today's world, Teng says, still implies that ethnic populations were simply homogenous 50 or 100 years ago. As her book reminds us, history says otherwise.

Explore further: Sniffing out a partner at a London pheromone party

Related Stories

Prized mushroom collection returns to China

Nov 07, 2009

(AP) -- A Chinese scholar persecuted during the Cultural Revolution for smuggling a rare collection of mushrooms out of China before World War II was honored Saturday when the collection was returned more than 70 years later.

US, China see progress on investment treaty

Jul 12, 2013

The United States and China said Thursday they had moved forward on a treaty that would ramp up investment but the two countries clashed over hacking and the case of fugitive Edward Snowden.

Culture counts in making Chinese maths-smart

Feb 26, 2013

Chinese Australians consistently outperform their peers in mathematics and according to QUT researcher Michael Mu this is not only because of pushy parents or motivated students.

China discovers primitive, 5,000-year-old writing

Jul 10, 2013

Archaeologists say they have discovered a new form of primitive writing in markings on stoneware excavated from a relic site in eastern China dating about 5,000 years back. The inscriptions are about 1,400 years older than ...

Pakistan adopts Chinese rival GPS satellite system

May 18, 2013

Pakistan is set to become the fifth Asian country to use China's domestic satellite navigation system which was launched as a rival to the US global positioning system, a report said Saturday.

Recommended for you

How to win a Tour de France sprint

Jul 22, 2014

The final dash to the line in a Tour de France sprint finish may appear to the bystander to be a mess of bodies trying to cram into the width of a road, but there is a high degree of strategy involved. It ...

User comments : 1

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

mosahlah
1 / 5 (4) Jul 20, 2013
Wanna see something interesting? Watch the faces of white women in Seattle when they meet my Asian wife for the first time. (I'm white). It's almost funny, but it did cost me a job back in the 90s. My kids seem to handle their identify well, now that we've spent more than a few years overseas living within mixed communities. We actually have greater acceptance within our own predominantly white small rural community. My sons dominate their school academically, and that earned quite a bit of respect for the family. (know many 11/12 yr olds studying calculus and programming?). Also, there's a lot to be said for educated "tiger moms" balanced with an American military father, and a Christian upbringing.