Research shows that financial analysts can stifle innovation

Jul 02, 2013 by Matt Weeks

( —Any number of things can affect a company's ability to innovate: talent, commitment, luck and funding all play big roles. But new research from the University of Georgia shows that one factor outside a company has dramatic effects on its creativity: financial analysts.

In a paper recently published in The Journal of Financial Economics, researchers at UGA's Terry College of Business show, contrary to , how can hamper companies' likelihood to innovate.

"Before starting this project, we originally thought that analysts could perform two roles. One is good: Reducing information asymmetry. One is bad: Putting too much pressure on managers to be myopic and focus on only short-term projects," said Jie (Jack) He, lead author of the research and an assistant professor of finance at the Terry College. "Our findings support that the negative effect dominates the positive."

The findings show that the more financial analysts are monitoring a firm, the fewer patents it produces—and the patents it does produce tend to elicit fewer citations.

To find out why, He and co-author Xuan Tian of Indiana University studied data from all industries spanning from 1993 to 2005.

"We see that analysts are not just an information producer; they also have other functions," He said. "And one of those other functions is that they set external benchmarks for the managers to meet. For example, they forecast the earnings for the next quarter or next year and they make recommendations so they kind of put some pressure on the managers to meet these external expectations. So if a firm is followed by more and more analysts, at some point the managers will feel pressure to meet these short-term targets. Basically, they want to beat the earnings expectations set by these analysts. So how do they meet these expectations? One way is to cut down on some long-term projects and focus more on the short-term projects, the easy and routine tasks the firm is engaging in."

In other words, investing in innovation is a big commitment for firms. It requires lots of time and money, and results aren't guaranteed. When firms are under the magnifying glasses of financial analysts, managers can find themselves under pressure to put more resources toward that offer quick and certain returns.

The researchers also studied what happened when the number of analysts covering a firm changed due to reasons unrelated to the firm itself.

"We looked at when brokerage firms merged together. For example if Goldman Sachs acquired a smaller brokerage firm," He said. "If both firms had analysts covering the same stock, the firms would usually get rid of one analyst or move that analyst to cover other stocks. This decision to change analyst coverage is not due to the firm's characteristics. It is driven by the brokerage firms. What we found is that when the affected firms lose analysts due to exogenous shocks, their innovations outcomes improve. They generate more patents than comparable, similar firms, and also the received by these patents are also higher. They generate more important or innovative patents. This is the main takeaway from our paper."

The effect holds for tech-sector industries, those that are very active in terms of innovation. It's also stronger among smaller firms that are only followed by a few analysts to begin with.

He explains it this way: "Perhaps when a firm is covered by more analysts, the firm becomes more transparent and that attracts some short-term, institutional investors. Those investors, like some hedge funds that try to chase short-term profit, only invest in stocks they think will give them very quick returns. If you have these guys coming in, firm managers will have stronger incentives to focus on short-term profits. But some investors are long-term oriented, and these investors tend to understand the long-term goals of firms."

The findings, while seemingly negative, could actually mean good news for many firms in near future, He said.

"On average, the number of sell-side analysts in the U.S. is declining over recent years, so hopefully that can encourage firms to do more innovative activities," He said. "But at the same time, the economy is going down so that will effect the available capital to support innovation as well."

Explore further: Narcissistic CEOs and financial performance

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Corporate hoarding of cash has roots in CEO's past

Jun 04, 2013

( —As some U.S. corporations rankle investors by holding unprecedented levels of cash, research from the University of Michigan indicates that the CEO's prior job experience could have something to do with it.

It all hinges on the bottom line

Mar 22, 2013

Determining the financial health of a company is no easy task. But new research from Concordia University's John Molson School of Business, recently published in the Journal of Corporate Finance, demonstrates that a comp ...

Recommended for you

How science can beat the flawed metric that rules it

1 hour ago

In order to improve something, we need to be able to measure its quality. This is true in public policy, in commercial industries, and also in science. Like other fields, science has a growing need for quantitative ...

Decoding ethnic labels

2 hours ago

If you are of Latin American descent, do you call yourself Chicano? Latino? Hispanic?

Local education politics 'far from dead'

23 hours ago

Teach for America, known for recruiting teachers, is also setting its sights on capturing school board seats across the nation. Surprisingly, however, political candidates from the program aren't just pushing ...

First grade reading suffers in segregated schools

23 hours ago

A groundbreaking study from the Frank Porter Graham Child Development Institute (FPG) has found that African-American students in first grade experience smaller gains in reading when they attend segregated schools—but the ...

Violent aftermath for the warriors at Alken Enge

Jul 29, 2014

Denmark attracted international attention in 2012 when archaeological excavations revealed the bones of an entire army, whose warriors had been thrown into the bogs near the Alken Enge wetlands in East Jutland ...

Why aren't consumers buying remanufactured products?

Jul 29, 2014

Firms looking to increase market share of remanufactured consumer products will have to overcome a big barrier to do so, according to a recent study from the Penn State Smeal College of Business. Findings from faculty members ...

User comments : 1

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Jul 02, 2013
Keep the bean counters out of the lab!