With shark fin ban, a slice of Asian culture ends in California

Jun 30, 2013 by Louis Sahagun

An ancient Asian dining tradition comes to an end in California on Monday, and grocer Emily Gian is none too happy.

Gian has slashed prices on shark fins, the astoundingly expensive ingredient of a coveted and ceremonial soup, in hopes she will sell out before a California ban on sale or possession of the delicacy takes effect.

"The law is unfair," said Gian, whose store in Los Angeles' Chinatown sells shark fins for $599 a pound. "Why single out Chinese people in California when shark fins are legal in many other states?"

Across town, retired science teacher Judy Ki offers an answer.

Ki grew up in a wealthy Hong Kong family that served steaming bowls of to honor guests at birthdays, banquets and weddings. These days, she sees the delicacy in historical context.

Shark fin soup dates to the Ming Dynasty, when it was reserved for emperors as a symbol of status and power over the most dangerous predators. "Back when it was quite a physical feat for a to land a shark, it was the ultimate symbol of yang, or male energy," said Ki, a spokeswoman for the Asian Pacific American Ocean Harmony Alliance.

It certainly wasn't prized for its flavor, which is almost nonexistent. Its chief culinary merit is an ethereal, gelatinous texture, achieved through careful drying, precise trimming and a complex preparation method that takes several days. For flavor, cooks often add chicken or ham.

As China's grew in recent decades, the number of people who could afford the delicacy rose sharply. To meet growing demand, the found a particularly cruel way to harvest several million fins each year. Fishermen slice the fins off live sharks and throw the crippled animals back into the sea to drown.

An estimated 73 million sharks are killed each year for their fins, which can sell for more than $2,000 a pound in California. The International Union for Conservation of Nature estimates that the populations of some shark species, such as hammerheads, have been reduced by as much as 90 percent in recent years.

Ki finds that morally wrong. "It is not right to slaughter massive numbers of sharks for a bowl of soup that lasts five minutes," Ki said. "Culture evolves. Extinction lasts forever."

Gian and others who are skeptical of the ban do have a point, however. It can seem unfair to ban shark fins in California while chefs and grocers in other states continue sales unfettered.

The state, and supporters of the ban, hope that will change.

"This is an important milestone in the global campaign to end shark finning," said Aimee David, director of conservation policy at the Monterey Bay Aquarium. "California's example has inspired several states to act, and we hope many others will follow suit."

So far, Hawaii, Washington, Oregon, Illinois, Maryland and Delaware, and the Pacific territories Guam, American Samoa and the Northern Mariana Islands, have also enacted legislation prohibiting the sale of shark fins. New York is pursuing similar legislation.

Korean Airlines Co. and Cathay Pacific Airways Ltd. have stopped carrying shark fins as cargo. Even the Chinese government has announced that it will phase out fins from official functions within three years, according to the U.S. Humane Society.

Despite protests from some Chinese American leaders, California Gov. Jerry Brown outlawed the possession, sale and distribution of shark fins 18 months ago. Stores were allowed to sell existing stocks until Monday. Violators could face penalties of up to six months in prison and fines up to $1,000, authorities said.

In January, a legal challenge in federal court by San Francisco merchants who claimed that the ban is unconstitutional and discriminatory toward Chinese culture was resolved in favor of the ban. The court found that the law was within the state's authority, based on findings that the decline of is a threat to the marine ecosystem and that the ban would help eliminate the demand for shark fins.

Since then, the state Department of Fish and Wildlife and supporters of the ban - including the Humane Society and the Asian Pacific American Ocean Harmony Alliance - have been reaching out to Chinese American communities across the state, reminding them about the new law and its consequences.

Chinatown is in the last days of preparation.

Across the street from Gian's shop, Wing Hop Fung Ginseng & China Products was down to its last three bins of dried , including one marked by an eye-catching sign: "Father's Day Special! 20 percent off. $999 a pound."

At the nearby Ocean Seafood, where shark fin soup costs $42 a bowl - $138 when combined in a pot with a whole chicken - manager Dennis Fong said the restaurant was changing its menus this week to remove the item.

Some Chinese restaurants are cooking up "faux" recipes that replace shark fin with non-endangered seafood.

As for Gian, she still had a lot of fins to move.

"Maybe we'll reduce the prices even more, or eat them ourselves, or maybe move them to a state where they are still legal," she said.

Explore further: Prized sea snail not at risk of extinction, federal officials say

4.5 /5 (2 votes)
add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

S.Korean airlines ban shark fin as cargo

Jun 20, 2013

South Korea's two largest airlines, Korean Air and Asiana, said Thursday they had both decided to ban shark fin from their cargo flights as part of a growing global campaign against the Asian delicacy.

EU closes shark finning loophole

Jun 06, 2013

The European Union on Thursday closed a last loophole in its ban on shark finning, the long-contested practice of fisherman slicing the fins off and then throwing the still live sharks back overboard to die.

Costa Rica tightens ban on shark fins

Oct 11, 2012

Costa Rica has banned the import of shark fins, closing a legal loophole and targeting a link in a global production chain stretching to Asian markets, where shark fin soup is seen as a delicacy.

New York eyes shark fin trade ban

Feb 21, 2012

A group of New York legislators on Tuesday unveiled a draft law banning trade in shark fins, saying the practice, which serves the market for Chinese shark fin soup, was decimating the ocean predators.

Outrage over Hong Kong's 'shark fin rooftop'

Jan 03, 2013

Hong Kong conservationists expressed outrage on Thursday after images of a factory rooftop covered in thousands of freshly sliced shark fins emerged, as they called for curbs on the "barbaric" trade.

Recommended for you

Wildlife groups seek help for California owl

Dec 24, 2014

Loggers cutting down forests burned in wildfires could bring about the extinction of California spotted owls, wildlife advocates said Tuesday as they sought protection for the birds under the federal Endangered ...

User comments : 4

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

Shootist
1 / 5 (5) Jun 30, 2013
America the totalitarian state. What bidness is it of the State whether people eat shark fin or not?

Someone somewhere is using the police power of government to impose their personal belief system on everyone else. The solution is Tar and Feathers applied liberally to the liberal.
nowhere
5 / 5 (1) Jul 01, 2013
America the totalitarian state. What bidness is it of the State whether people eat shark fin or not?

The International Union for Conservation of Nature estimates that the populations of some shark species, such as hammerheads, have been reduced by as much as 90 percent in recent years.

Can you even read? Maybe you think god will protect such ecosystems in the states absence?
alfie_null
5 / 5 (1) Jul 01, 2013
America the totalitarian state. What bidness is it of the State whether people eat shark fin or not?

Maybe the same "business" that made the government enact a ban on DDT some years back. So we still have species like the Bald Eagle around.

And "totalitarian"? That you are posting, being critical, is certainly an indication not so. We get that government is doing something you don't agree with.
KnowledgeAndTruth
5 / 5 (1) Jul 01, 2013
"Culture evolves. Extinction lasts forever." says it all...

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.