A physicist's best friend: Quantum coherence in diamond augments fluorescence thermometry

Jun 14, 2013 by Stuart Mason Dambrot feature
Nitrogen vacancy center in diamond. (A) Depiction of a nitrogen vacancy (NV) center in the diamond lattice. The wavy green arrow represents the 532-nm laser used for optical excitation and the wavy red arrow represents the phonon-broadened fluorescence used to measure the spin state. (B) Fine structure of the NV center ground state as a function of axial magnetic field. The light bulbs represent the relative fluorescence difference for the ms = 0 and ms = ±1 states. Temperature changes shift the crystal field splitting (D), whereas magnetic fields (Bz) split the ms = ±1 sublevels. This difference enables dynamical decoupling pulse sequences that move the spin between all three states to selectively measure temperature shifts and mitigate magnetic noise. (C) Ramsey measurement performed on the ms = 0 to ms = −1 transition (Bz = 40 G). Inset illustrates the pulse sequence. The short inhomogeneous spin lifetime (T2*) limits the sensitivity of conventional NV center thermometry. The uncertainties in IPL, estimated from the photon shot noise, are ∼0.003. The microwave carrier frequency was detuned from the mI = 0 hyperfine resonance by ∼3.5MHz to induce oscillations in IPL. The fluorescence signal exhibits a beating caused by the three hyperfine resonances and weak coupling to a nearby 13C spin. Gray dashed lines show the fluorescence intensity of ms = 0 and ms = −1 as determined by independent measurements. Copyright © PNAS, doi:10.1073/pnas.1306825110

(Phys.org) —Thermometry – the measurement of temperature – is critical to a wide range of applications, including many industrial processes, biomedical monitoring, and environmental regulatory systems. However, measuring temperature in the presence of high RF (radio frequency) or other electromagnetic fields – such as are found in aerospace, automotive and medical systems – cannot be accomplished using electrical thermometric probes. In these cases, optical sensors that allow scientists to perform thermometry based on thermally-driven changes in fluorescence (brightness) are the instrument of choice. While typical fluorescence thermometers use millimeter-scale optical probes, smaller devices are needed to measure temperatures in intracellular and other nanoscale environments. As a result, the field has witnessed the development of nanoscale fluorescence thermometers based on quantum dots, rare-earth ions and nanogels.

Recently, scientists at the University of California, Santa Barbara, Ames Laboratory, and the University of Chicago have demonstrated extremely sensitive fluorescence thermometry techniques based on nitrogen vacancy (NV) centers in diamond – paramagnetic defects in which electron spins can be manipulated at room temperature by applying a combination of microwave radiation and light. This results in sharp resonances in the defects' intensity as a function of the frequency of the , with the frequency dependent on external variables such as magnetic fields, electric fields, and, in this work, temperature. The researchers also showed that these techniques can be applied over a broad temperature range and in both finite and near-zero magnetic field environments, suggesting that single spin quantum coherence could be leveraged for sensitive thermometry in a broad range of biological and microscale systems.

Prof. David D. Awschalom discusses the research that he, graduate students David M. Toyli, Charles F. de las Casas, David J. Christle, and Ames Laboratory scientist Viatcheslav V. Dobrovitski conducted. While Awschalom tells Phys.org that fluorescence thermometry is a well-established technique, and that millimeter-scale fluorescence thermometers are mature technologies, most recently-developed nanoscale lack sufficient sensitivity for intracellular thermometry and other target applications. However, Awschalom notes that the researchers' new approach leverages the fact that the diamond NV center's fluorescence correlates with the quantum state of its intrinsic magnetic moment, or spin, to achieve much better thermal sensitivities than are offered by conventional approaches.

The scientists also demonstrated that their techniques are extremely versatile, in that that they can be applied over a broad temperature range spanning room temperature to 500 Kelvin (440° Fahrenheit), as well as in both finite and near-zero magnetic field environments. "It's quite unique to have a technology that operates based on the principles of quantum physics at these temperatures," notes Awschalom, "since most quantum devices are restricted to operate only near absolute zero." Moreover, he points out, it may be possible in future experiments to use the NV center as a multifunctional probe capable of measuring both magnetic fields and temperature.

Thermal echo (TE) and thermal CPMG-N (TCPMG-N) pulse sequences in finite magnetic fields. (A) Diagram showing the pulse sequences. Here a π pulse has a duration such that it will invert the spin population between the two sublevels that are resonantly addressed. The subscripts indicate the spin transition being addressed. (B) Hahn echo measurement (ms = 0 to ms = −1 transition) at Bz = 30 G showing IPL as a function of the free evolution time (2τ for the Hahn echo and TE, 4τ for TCPMG, and 8τ for TCPMG-2). The measurement demonstrates the coherence collapse caused by the incoherent precession of the 13C spin bath. The width of the shaded gray region represents T2*. C, D, and E show TE, TCPMG, and TCPMG-2 measurements, respectively, performed at 297.00 K (SI Appendix). The uncertainties in IPL, estimated from the photon shot noise, are ∼0.005. To induce oscillations in IPL to clearly observe the signal envelope, the average microwave carrier frequency (ΩREF) was detuned from D by ∼0.5 MHz. The solid red lines are best fits to the data and the 1/e decay times (τ1/e) are noted on the plots. The observed coherences are in good agreement with numerical modeling (solid green lines). For the TCPMG-2 sequence the coherence time is ninefold greater than T2*. For these experimental conditions we infer the thermal sensitivity (η) is 54 ± 1 mK·Hz−1/2. Enhancements in the photon collection efficiency could improve η to ∼15 mK·Hz−1/2 (Methods). Copyright © PNAS, doi:10.1073/pnas.1306825110

"Just ten years ago the idea of using single spins for sensing applications at 500 Kelvin was probably unthinkable," says Awschalom. "These scientific studies have now advanced to the point where we can start to apply these new quantum technologies to a variety of challenging and compelling applications."

As mentioned above, a key innovation that fueled their research, notes Awschalom, was working with Dobrovitski in developing protocols for manipulating the NV center's spin that mitigate its interactions with its magnetic environment while maintaining sensitivity to thermally induced changes in the spin states. As the magnetic environment is the primary noise source in these measurements, mitigating its effects allowed them to convert small changes in temperature into large changes in NV center's fluorescence. "The idea of using the quantum states of a single spin for thermometry is very exciting," says Toyli. "What we're really doing is adapting ideas from quantum information science to enable sensitive temperature measurements at the nanoscale."

In addition, the researchers' findings suggest that the of single spins could be practically leveraged for sensitive thermometry in a wide variety of biological and microscale systems, such as probing intracellular thermal gradients. "Our work showed that one can use an atomic-scale impurity in diamond to measure temperature shifts of much less than 0.1 K through the defect's fluorescence. If similar results could be obtained with NV centers in nanoscale volumes of diamond – that is, in nanodiamonds – then this would enable sensitive thermometry in a wide variety of biological and microscale systems."

In such a system, Awschalom explains, the sensor's spatial resolution is defined by the size of the nanodiamonds, which have been shown to have NV centers in particles as small as five nanometers. Diamond's properties – biocompatibility, mechanical hardness and high thermal conductivity – make this system a very promising thermal sensor. "One can imagine applications where nanodiamonds are inserted into living cells and used to image intrinsic thermal gradients, introduced into microfluidic circuits and used to monitor the temperature of chemical reactions in the circuits," Awschalom illustrates, "or where NV centers are incorporated in nanoscale pillars as part of a scanning probe system – as are already being built for magnetometry applications – and used to map out thermal gradients on a surface."

Looking forward, says Awschalom, a primary challenge for the field is to achieve better spin properties for NV centers in nanodiamonds, since these typically have comparably worse properties than the NV centers in bulk diamond studied in this work. However, while conventional nanodiamond fabrication methods are quite crude, Awschalom notes that recent advances suggest it may be possible to use top-down-fabrication methods to produce nanodiamonds with high-quality spins.

The researchers are also focused on optimizing the delivery of the gigahertz-frequency magnetic fields used to manipulate the spin in order to minimize unintentional heating of fluidic samples.

"We're excited by the prospect of applying spin-based thermometers in a variety of applications," Awschalom concludes. "Specific examples include not just noninvasive thermometry in cellular and microfluidic environments, but also high-temperature scanning thermal microscopy."

Explore further: Longer distance quantum teleportation achieved

More information: Fluorescence thermometry enhanced by the quantum coherence of single spins in diamond, PNAS May 21, 2013 vol. 110 no. 21 8417-8421, doi:10.1073/pnas.1306825110

Related Stories

Spintronics approach enables new quantum technologies

Jun 04, 2013

(Phys.org) —A team of researchers including members of the University of Chicago's Institute for Molecular Engineering highlight the power of emerging quantum technologies in two recent papers published ...

A new spin in diamonds for quantum technologies

Dec 20, 2011

(PhysOrg.com) -- To explore the future potential of diamonds in quantum devices, researchers from Macquarie University have collaborated with the University of Stuttgart and University of Ulm in Germany towards ...

Nanoscale MRI being developed

Feb 01, 2013

(Phys.org)—Two independent groups of scientists in the U.S. and Germany have reduced magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) down to the nanoscale, which may enable them in the future to non-destructively detect ...

Recommended for you

Quantum mechanics to charge your laptop?

Sep 18, 2014

Top scientists from UC Berkeley and MIT found the expertise they lacked at FIU. They invited Sakhrat Khizroev, a professor with appointments in both medicine and engineering, to help them conduct research ...

Physicists design zero-friction quantum engine

Sep 16, 2014

(Phys.org) —In real physical processes, some energy is always lost any time work is produced. The lost energy almost always occurs due to friction, especially in processes that involve mechanical motion. ...

User comments : 1

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

lORENTZBOOST
not rated yet Jul 02, 2013
This is fantastic material! I have been contemplating macro molecular structures, covelent bonds and their applications towards new technologies. The properties of covelent bonds are fascinating to me. There are implications there that I haven't fully grasped as of yet. It is wonderful to come across other thoughts along the lines of this new Quantum applied science! Thanks for the GREAT articles!