Plant eaters, and the flora they eat, give peace a chance

Jun 24, 2013 by Krishna Ramanujan
Plant eaters, and the flora they eat, give peace a chance
This image reveals the intimacy between the tupelo leafminer living and feeding inside a leaf of the tupelo tree. The larva is seen from behind a single-celled "window" of the leaf epidermis. Credit: Candace Low

(Phys.org) —Plants are often described as being in an evolutionary arms race with the creatures that eat them. Plant eaters develop new strategies for attacking, and plants acquire new ways to defend themselves.

But sometimes, non-conflict may be the best strategy for both plant eaters and plants, according to a new Cornell study that uses ideas from economics and in a . The research was published online June 20 in the American Naturalist.

"The model shows that both the herbivore and the plant develop strategies that optimize their benefits," said Candace Low, the paper's lead author and a visiting research scientist in the lab of co-author Stephen Ellner, professor of ecology and .

"For example, if you have a T-shirt that I want, you may be able to give it up to me when you are done with it," said Low. "But if I want it when you want it, then we are going to fight for it, and that will be more costly for both of us."

Take the tupelo leafminer moth (Antipila nysaefoliella), for example, whose eggs are dormant through summer until August when they hatch, and the larvae eat tupelo tree leaves (Nyssa sylvatica). By late summer, the of the leaf has diminished because the growing season is winding down, the leaf's lifespan is almost over and the shrinking daylight results in less . Since each leaf's value has become relatively low, the plant benefits by conserving its resources and tolerating more herbivory. It therefore raises its threshold for turning on its chemical defense system, which is triggered when leaves are eaten.

Low, who studies the 's biology, has been observing the moths and trees for years in northern Virginia. She has applied the natural history data to create a more biologically realistic model, and under almost every scenario, the model showed that the best outcome for both the and the tree was to allow feeding late in summer when the leaf's value diminishes.

"For the herbivore, it's not optimal to feed on the leaves when the plant's defenses are highest," said Low. "The herbivore often gets a better payoff from feeding when the leaf is undefended." As long as the plant has the capability for moderately lethal defense, the herbivore will modify its hatching rate to avoid plant defense, and the plant will never have to use those defenses, the paper states.

The findings question a basic ecological assumption that the plant-herbivore relationship is based on conflict, Low said.

"Our results show that plant and herbivore arrive at a conclusion that is ecologically neutral, when the plant doesn't care if it is fed on," she added.

Matthew Holden, a graduate student in the field of applied mathematics, is a co-author of the study.

Explore further: Rising temperatures can be hard on dogs

Related Stories

A tale of two fungi

Mar 05, 2013

(Phys.org) —In the February issue of New Phytologist, Tulane University biologists examine why leaf-cutting ants target some plants and avoid others, concluding that high levels of friendly fungi in the ...

Plants cry for help when an attack can be expected

Sep 07, 2012

Eggs of insect pests deposited on plants trigger the production of scents by plants that affect different plant community members probably helping the plant to get rid of the pest before it becomes harmful. ...

Invasion of the slugs—halted by worms...

May 12, 2013

The gardener's best friend, the earthworm, is great at protecting leaves from being chomped by slugs, suggests research in BioMed Central's open access journal BMC Ecology. Although they lurk in the soil, they seem to pro ...

Freefall -- aphids' survival strategy

Jul 12, 2011

As soon as aphids feeding on a plant sense the heat and humidity in a mammal's breath, they drop to safety before they are inadvertently ingested together with the plant the animal is feeding on. These findings by Moshe Gish ...

Recommended for you

Rising temperatures can be hard on dogs

23 minutes ago

The "dog days of summer" are here, but don't let the phrase fool you. This hot time of year can be dangerous for your pup, says a Kansas State University veterinarian.

Monkeys fear big cats less, eat more, with humans around

3 hours ago

Some Monkeys in South Africa have been found to regard field scientists as human shields against predators and why not if the alternative is death by leopard? The researchers found the monkeys felt far safer ...

User comments : 0