By boosting cloning efficiency, scientists unlock the potential to 'mass-produce' valuable animal strains

Jun 07, 2013
Figure 1: Cloning begins with the injection of the nucleus of a somatic cell from the animal being cloned into an oocyte from which the nucleus has been removed. Credit: 2013 Teruhiko Wakayama, RIKEN Center for Developmental Biology

Long before humans understood the principles of genes and heritability, they were already shaping animal evolution through selective breeding. The various domesticated species we cultivate today are the product of a centuries-long project of gradual selection and mating to generate strains with optimized physical and behavioral characteristics.

Nowadays, scientists have amassed considerable insight into . Additionally, cloning technology theoretically offers the potential to replicate of livestock or research animals with identical, desirable traits. In reality, however, most efforts in this area have so far met with disappointment. Now, recent progress made by a research team led by Teruhiko Wakayama at the RIKEN Center for suggests that multigenerational cloning may soon become a feasible option.

For over a decade, Wakayama's team has pursued the serial recloning of mice using a technique called (SCNT), which allows generation after generation of identical mice to be produced from a single-source donor. The mouse is an extremely well characterized and should therefore be ideal for testing such strategies. However, Wakayama and his colleagues previously achieved only limited success. "Nobody had succeeded in continuous recloning for more than six generations," he says.

In general, SCNT is plagued by inefficiency, requiring a substantial investment to successfully obtain healthy cloned animals. Although steady progress in cloning technology has improved the odds, the root causes of failure in the recloning process remain obscure. Despite the difficulties, however, Wakayama was committed to overcoming this challenge. "I am always trying difficult studies where nobody has succeeded previously, and so I wanted to try this again," he explains.

Growing an unusual family tree

SCNT involves extracting the nucleus from an adult and transferring it into a recipient oocyte from which the nucleus has been removed (Fig. 1). The environment of the oocyte induces a series of 'reprogramming' events in the donor nucleus, which subsequently behaves as if it were the nucleus of a newly fertilized egg. If successful, the resulting developmental process yields an embryo that is a clone of the donor animal.

Figure 2: Mice obtained from generations 23, 24 and 25 of the serial recloning of a single donor animal. Credit: 2013 Teruhiko Wakayama, RIKEN Center for Developmental Biology

The reprogramming process requires selective enzymatic addition of chemical modifications to targeted sites on the chromosomes, which in turn modulate expression of nearby genes through 'epigenetic' regulation. Certain other enzymes can undermine cloning success by removing these epigenetic marks, prematurely terminating the reprogramming process. Such enzymes can be inhibited by drugs like trichostatin A (TSA), and SCNT success rates can be boosted as much as fivefold using this TSA-facilitated strategy.

By employing TSA treatment, Wakayama and colleagues have been able to improve their SCNT success rate and achieve a breakthrough in serial recloning. Over the past eight years, the team has repeatedly cloned a single female donor mouse through 25 generations and beyond(Fig. 2). From each subsequent generation, the researchers collected the from one of the 'cumulus cells' that surrounds the oocyte, and transferred it into a recipient oocyte. In this manner, they were able to successfully derive a new and healthy clone from every new generation.

The cloning success rate varied considerably across—and even within—generations: in some cases the rate was as low as 3% and in others as high as 20%. To identify factors that might be altering the rate, the researchers used a variety of control experiments and even accounted for the variability in experimental technique that would inevitably arise across an eight-year experiment. Ultimately, they were unable to identify any direct contributing factors. "There are too many possibilities," says Wakayama. "Even the season can affect the success rate."

Nevertheless, the cloned mice that were generated proved to be healthy, physiologically normal and exhibited typical lifespans. Indeed, a set of clones from generation 20 were each sufficiently fertile to yield normal-sized litters of healthy pups when bred. The animals proved equally healthy at the cellular level, with no evidence of accumulated genetic damage or abnormalities in gene expression relative to first-generation clones. Wakayama compares this achievement to duplicating a DVD versus a videotape. "Copying a videotape will decrease its quality, but copying a digital file does not," he says. "Thus, cloning by nuclear transfer is more similar to digital than analog copying."

A new beginning

Following the publication of their findings, the team of researchers are continuing to generate clones from each new generation. Wakayama notes that they have reached generation 27 and are collecting data from these animals at present.

In principle there appears to be no inherent generational limit. As long as TSA is applied to facilitate proper nuclear reprogramming, each round of cloning is no less likely to succeed than the previous round. This suggests that earlier failures in serial recloning were simply the result of an extremely low base success rate, rather than the aggregate effect of cellular defects acquired during each new round of SCNT.

As TSA and other chemicals with similar inhibitory effects can also dramatically boost the success of SCNT in other species, it is anticipated that serial recloning should prove similarly feasible in larger animals such as cows or pigs. Wakayama also notes that their technique could revive long-lost animal populations. "We plan to use the mouse as a model for resurrecting extinct species," he says. "For example, we have successfully generated clones from frozen mice, and are trying to make clones from taxidermied animals or from the fur of a mouse."

Explore further: Geneticists offer clues to better rice, tomato crops

More information: Wakayama, S. et al. Successful serial recloning in the mouse over multiple generations, Cell Stem Cell 12, 293–297 (2013).

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Clones of clones can make clones

Apr 01, 2013

Since the first reports of successful cloning of mammals by somatic cell nuclear transfer, concerns have been raised about the efficiency and repeatability of cloning techniques, and the health of cloned ...

Not all clones the same

Nov 05, 2010

Despite their name, not all clones are created equal. This is especially true for the products of somatic cell nuclear transfer (SCNT), which entails the transplantation of the nucleus from a mature somatic ...

Recommended for you

The microbes make the sake brewery

Jul 24, 2014

A sake brewery has its own microbial terroir, meaning the microbial populations found on surfaces in the facility resemble those found in the product, creating the final flavor according to research published ahead of print ...

User comments : 0