Alternative-fuel cars are no carbon cure-all

Jun 12, 2013
Alternative-fuel cars are no carbon cure-all

(Phys.org) —Making cars more fuel-efficient is great for reducing greenhouse gas emissions, but rather than promoting sales of electric and other alternative-fuel vehicles, policymakers should turn their focus to cutting emissions in other energy sectors—from oil wells and power plants to farms and forests affected by biofuels production—says a University of Michigan researcher.

"While the rush to get on the road has become dogma in many policy circles, such haste cannot be justified by careful analysis," said John DeCicco, a research professor at the U-M Energy Institute and professor of practice at the School of Natural Resources and Environment.

have been promoted for decades—plug-in electric cars as well as those powered by , natural gas, hydrogen or other nonpetroleum fuels. Federal tax credits for range up to $7,500 per car and many other alternative fuels are also subsidized.

A new study by DeCicco affirms that research and development are important to create better options for the future. But at least for reasons of climate protection, moving beyond R&D into public subsidies, mandates and other costly programs to prop up alternative fuel sales "is not warranted on the basis of current data," he says.

The study, appearing online in Energy Policy, examines expected increases in driving for both the U.S. and China. It compares those projections to data on the carbon emissions associated with different fuels and the efficiency gains in vehicles that still burn liquid fuels (including hybrids that don't plug in).

"Gasoline vehicle efficiency is already improving by nearly 4 percent per year, while emissions from U.S. electric power generation are not even declining by 1 percent per year," DeCicco said.

"If you think that will be needed someday, you first have to greatly cut carbon emissions from power generation. If you think that biofuels are going to be important, then you need to remove more carbon from the air at farms or forests than we're already doing today."

DeCicco's research shows that as long as carbon emissions in those other locations remain poorly controlled, there are no compelling climate advantages to alternative fuels and cars that use them. The most effective approaches, he says, are steadily improving vehicle efficiency and limiting travel demand.

"Higher fuel economy—that's one good track the country is already on, and we should stay the course on that," he said. "Reducing the demand for car travel makes sense in urban areas, where policymakers can do more to encourage efficient land use, better mass transit and making it easier to walk and bike or otherwise minimize traffic congestion."

Beyond transportation efficiency, the next priorities lie outside the transportation sector, DeCicco says.

"The missing link for really cleaning up cars is not about the car at all," he said. "It's about limiting net carbon impacts in the energy and natural resource sectors that supply motor fuel, whatever form that fuel may take."

Explore further: Website shines light on renewable energy resources

More information: www.sciencedirect.com/science/… ii/S0301421513002309

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Electric cars slow to gain traction in Germany

May 28, 2013

Germany plans to have one million electric vehicles on its roads by 2020, but so far that goal seems remote as the nation's motorists have shown little love for the quietly humming vehicles.

California exceeds low-carbon fuel standard targets

May 01, 2013

Since California's Low Carbon Fuel Standard went into effect in 2011, low carbon transportation fuels have displaced roughly 2.14 billion gallons of gasoline and 77 million gasoline gallon equivalents of diesel, according ...

Report presents best policy options to reduce petroleum use

Jun 23, 2011

It will take more than tougher fuel economy standards for U.S. transportation to significantly cut its oil use over the next half century. It will likely require a combination of measures that foster consumer and supplier ...

Recommended for you

Website shines light on renewable energy resources

4 hours ago

A team from the University of Arizona and eight southwestern electric utility companies have built a pioneering web portal that provides insight into renewable energy sources and how they contribute to the ...

Better software cuts computer energy use

4 hours ago

An EU research project is developing tools to help software engineers create energy-efficient code, which could reduce electricity consumption at data centres by up to 50% and improve battery life in smart ...

Cook farm waste into energy

Dec 17, 2014

It takes some cooking, but turning farm waste into biofuels is now possible and makes economic sense, according to preliminary research from the University of Guelph.

Developing a reliable wind 'super grid' for Europe

Dec 17, 2014

EU researchers are involved in the development of a pan-European 'super grid' capable of dispersing wind power across Member States. This will bring more renewable energy into homes and businesses, help reduce ...

Boeing 737 factory to move to clean energy

Dec 16, 2014

Boeing said Tuesday it plans to buy renewable energy credits to replace fossil-fuel power at the factory in Washington state where it assembles its 737 commercial airplanes.

User comments : 0

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.