Science keeps its eye on the (foot) ball

May 29, 2013
A FIFA officer displays a watch during a demonstration of goal-line technology by Hawk-Eye Innovations at Toyota Stadium in Toyota, Aichi prefecture on December 8, 2012. Science has entered the debate into the use of goal-line technology in football, with an article in a respected journal on Wednesday stressing it could not be foolproof.

Science has entered the debate into the use of goal-line technology in football, with an article in a respected journal on Wednesday stressing it could not be foolproof.

It was misleading to promise fans that the technology would eliminate errors like the denial of an apparently legitimate goal by England midfielder Frank Lampard in the 2010 World Cup, said the piece in Nature.

Goal-line technology will be introduced to the Confederations Cup tournament in Brazil next month, followed by the English Premier League in August.

The technology typically works with several cameras tracking the ball and sending a signal to match officials when it crosses the line.

Similar systems are already used in tennis and cricket.

"The introduction of goal-line technology to football is likely to perpetrate a mass deception on television viewers," science journalist and self-proclaimed Sheffield United fan Nic Fleming wrote in Nature—a journal better known for publishing in fields like astronomy, and neuroscience.

Many people would believe they were seeing an accurate, real-time snapshot of what happened, when in fact the images are a computer reconstruction of an array of two-dimensional pictures, he said.

"The technology is almost certainly better than human referees, however the crucial point is that they are not and cannot be 100 percent accurate," Fleming told AFP.

"They will still sometimes get it wrong, even if only occasionally."

He argued for a disclaimer on the graphics so that people will understand there was a scientific margin of error to consider.

"This would help people gain a clearer understanding that science is usually based on probabilities, not definitive answers," he said.

"Based on this we could have much better discussions about the role of science in public debates around climate change, nuclear power and , for example."

After years of debate, trials and several refereeing controversies, FIFA finally succumbed to pressure last year and gave the thumbs up to the introduction of goal-line technology.

The Confederations Cup will be the second FIFA-accredited competition in which the technology will be used to determine disputed goal-line incidents.

It was made available in last year's Club World Cup in Japan, albeit without ever having to intervene.

Explore further: UK body warns drone owners: Fly safely, or you'll be fined

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

FIFA pick GoalControl for Confederations Cup

Apr 02, 2013

Football's world governing body on Tuesday said that German company GoalControl will provide the goal-line technology at this year's Confederations Cup in Brazil.

Hawk-Eye firm hopes for 'phantom goal'

Dec 09, 2012

Hawk-Eye chiefs are hoping for a Frank Lampard-like "ghost goal" at the Club World Cup, its managing director said Saturday, as the goal-line technology prepares to make its competitive debut.

Recommended for you

GPS used to track some immigrants caught at border

Dec 24, 2014

The Homeland Security Department is experimenting with a new way to track immigrant families caught crossing the border illegally and then released into the U.S.: GPS-enabled ankle bracelets.

Report: FBI's anthrax investigation was flawed

Dec 19, 2014

The FBI used flawed scientific methods to investigate the 2001 anthrax attacks that killed five people and sickened 17 others, federal auditors said Friday in a report sure to fuel skepticism over the FBI's ...

User comments : 0

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.