The Rio Scale: Quantifying the consequences of an ET discovery

May 3, 2013 by Bruno Martini,
In 1977 NASA's Voyager 1 and 2 spacecraft launched into space carrying phonographs called the Golden Records containing pictures and sounds meant to show extraterrestrials a glimpse of life on Earth. Credit: NASA

Among the mysteries of the Universe that are able to be investigated by science, the possibility of extraterrestrial intelligence remains one of the most fascinating.

Ancient cultures around the globe have already speculated on that possibility, but we may now finally have the right tools to conduct serious research.

Probably the best example of this present-day capability is the (SETI) Program, which aims to detect of extraterrestrial technological communication. Another is the Search for Extraterrestrial Artifacts (SETA), which looks for space probes or stellar-energy orbital plants (so-called "Dyson spheres"). Finding an unmistakable sign of alien technology would be evidence for alien intelligence, even if we never found any living species.

Scientists agree that even though the discovery of an is an event of low probability, if it ever happens it would have deep social, political, religious, intellectual and scientific consequences. But can we quantify the severity of such an event? Can we compare the effects of different alien contact situations?

Aiming to quantify and compare events, scales are a familiar scientific tool. For instance, scales such as Celsius, Fahrenheit or Kelvin are used to quantify temperature. The Beaufort scale expresses the strength of storms by wind speed, while the Saffir-Simpson scale classifies the power of hurricanes and Fujita does the same for tornadoes.

Iván Almár from Konkoly Observatory in Budapest, Hungary and Jill Tarter from the SETI Institute in California developed a similar scale to quantify the potential significance of any announcement of the discovery of extraterrestrial intelligence.

What if we detected city lights on an alien world? In this image, the International Space Station (ISS), shows how the night skies on Earth are illuminated with light from many sources. Credit: Expedition 29 crew/Johnson Space Center

Their scale was initially presented at the 51st International Astronautical Congress, 29th Review Meeting on the Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence, in October 2000. The event was hosted in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, so it was called the Rio Scale. The actual scientific paper was published in 2011 in Acta Astronautica. Later that year, another paper by Almár and Margaret Race from the reported in the Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society a few improvements on the Rio Scale, after thorough discussions within the scientific community during the last decade.

The Rio Scale is somewhat similar to the two-dimensional Torino Scale published in 1997, which quantifies the consequences of an encounter with an approaching asteroid. The Torino Scale takes into account the potential damage of an asteroid impact and the probability of its collision with the Earth. It was the first attempt to combine on an ordinal scale the effects of two equally important parameters, resulting in a range of 0 (no hazard for mankind) to 10 (certain collision inducing global catastrophe).

The Rio Scale index (RSI) was originally described as: RSI = Q x δ

Where Q is an estimated level of consequences obtained from the sum of three parameters: class, discovery type and distance of the phenomenon, δ represents the discovery credibility, a more subjective factor likely to vary with time. High values always represent potentially more important consequences.

Table of the three parameters which result on a Q value and the reliability factor δ. The class of phenomenon has six indices, the type of discovery has 5 indices and the distance of the claimed extraterrestrial intelligence or artifact has 4 indices. Finally, the reliability factor posses 5 possible indices. Credit: Table based on Almár and Race (2011)

In the table shown below, the Rio Scale has a value for each of the three categories of Q, which have a number ranging from 3 to 15. The estimated reliability of the claimed discovery, δ, has five possible values and it may decrease or increase with time and among different observers. A claim verified by many experts in multiple and unrelated ways is a case of δ = 4/6. An unequivocal fake signal means δ = 0.

The product of Q and δ is the potential effect on humankind of an announcement of the discovery of an extraterrestrial intelligence. It ranges from 0 to 10 (for eleven levels total).

How would we react if we encountered an alien civilization? Image from the movie, “Close Encounters of the Third Kind.” Credit: Columbia Pictures

The difference between the class of "Earth-specific" versus "omni-directional" messages indicates whether the extraterrestrial intelligence knows about our planet Earth.

While SETI and SETA aim to hunt for signals of aliens, other observations may include serendipitous detections made inadvertently (more likely by astronomers). For the classes "leakage" and "astroengineering," the former means electromagnetic radiation that escapes out into space, while the latter means any other kind of technological activity.

Transient phenomena are those verified once but never repeated, while steady phenomena can be verified by repeated observation or investigation. Re-evaluation of archival data would come from old collections of data, and such accounts may be hard to verify. The 50 light-years distance is an arbitrary distance to allow round-trip communication through the speed of light during a human lifetime.

The Rio Scale: Quantifying the consequences of an ET discovery
The Rio Scale addressing the potential consequences of an announcement about the discovery of an extraterrestrial civilization. Credit: IAA SETI Permanent Committee

Even when we face an event of possible huge consequences (high Q value), if the claim of detecting an extraterrestrial civilization is not credible (low δ value), this will drop the actual significance of the discovery.

The International Academy of Astronautics (IAA) SETI Permanent committee adopted the Rio Scale with a decennial level of significance, taking the example from the more famous Richter Scale that quantifies an earthquake's magnitude. On the IAA SETI Permanent Committee website, you can calculate the Rio Scale for different scenarios by yourself:

Iván Almár and Jill Tarter noted "the discovery of as a high-consequence, low-probability event" and suggested their Rio Scale could be used by the media as a tool to avoid misinterpretation and sensationalism over claims about extraterrestrial intelligences. It will be the task of a group of independent experts to calculate the Rio Scale index for any putative discovery.

Explore further: Widening the search for extraterrestrial intelligence

More information: Original work from Almár & Tarter (2011):

Original paper from Almár & Race (2011):

Related Stories

Widening the search for extraterrestrial intelligence

March 1, 2010

"The Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence (SETI) has been dominated for its first half century by a hunt for unusual radio signals. But as he prepares for the publication of his new book The Eerie Silence: Are We Alone?," ...

SETI may be looking in the wrong places: astronomer

August 24, 2010

( -- A senior astronomer with the Search for ExtraTerrestrial Intelligence (SETI) Institute, Dr Seth Shostak, has reported in an article published online that perhaps we should be seeking alien "life forms" that ...

Jodie Foster helps keep search for aliens alive

August 17, 2011

"Contact" star Jodie Foster was among donors helping to revive the 42 radio telescope dishes at a key California institute searching for extraterrestrial life, the group said Tuesday.

Analysis of the First Kepler SETI Observations

January 9, 2012

As the Kepler space telescope begins finding its first Earth-sized exoplanets, with the ultimate goal of finding ones that are actually Earth-like, it would seem natural that the SETI (Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence) ...

At last, how many alien civilizations are there?

December 3, 2012

During the space age, 1961 was a special year: the Russian cosmonaut Yuri Gagarin became the first man to orbit Earth, while the American astronomer Frank Drake developed the now famous Drake Equation. This equation estimates ...

Recommended for you

NASA's space-station resupply missions to relaunch

November 29, 2015

NASA's commercial space program returns to flight this week as one of its private cargo haulers, Orbital ATK, is to launch its first supply shipment to the International Space Station in more than 13 months.

The hottest white dwarf in the Galaxy

November 25, 2015

Astronomers at the Universities of Tübingen and Potsdam have identified the hottest white dwarf ever discovered in our Galaxy. With a temperature of 250,000 degrees Celsius, this dying star at the outskirts of the Milky ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

1 / 5 (3) May 03, 2013
Among the mysteries of the Universe that are able to be investigated by science, the possibility of extraterrestrial intelligence remains one of the most fascinating.

And least likely to find, yet it won't stop the sci-fi community from invading science.
2.3 / 5 (3) May 03, 2013
This might be the first time I actually agree with you cantdrive.

This story is almost hillarious. We don't have a single credible instance of extraterrestrial intelligence being detected, but we need a classification system to classify instances??????

Ummmm, how about waiting until there's like more than one, then worry about classification. Until there's more than one, the only classification needed is "the event".
1 / 5 (2) May 03, 2013
Imagine a tribe in Brazil protected by international law from from outside influence. That tribe will evolve naturally. Now imagine one of the members of the tribe is sent out into the world to see whats out there and report back. The international law would no longer matter. The tribe would be, for the most part open game to the good and bad of society at large. We may regret sending those probes out there.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.