EU backs Apple in Google's Motorola patent move (Update 2)

May 06, 2013
EU anti-trust officials said Monday that Google-owned Motorola was abusing its leading position in Germany's mobile phones market by filing a patent injunction against Apple over certain core smartphone functions.

EU anti-trust officials said on Monday that Google-owned Motorola was abusing its leading position in Germany's mobile phone market by filing a patent injunction against Apple over some core smartphone functions.

A statement said that the European Union had reached a "preliminary view" on a competition investigation opened in April 2012.

It had decided that Motorola Mobility's action "amounts to an abuse of a dominant position prohibited by EU anti-trust rules."

The Commission spelt out that "while recourse to injunctions is a possible remedy for patent infringements, such conduct may be abusive where standard-essential patents (SEPs) are concerned and the potential licensee is willing to enter into a licence on Fair, Reasonable and Non-Discriminatory (so-called "FRAND") terms."

EU Competition Commissioner Joaquin Almunia said: "The protection of intellectual property is a cornerstone of innovation and growth. But so is competition.

"I think that companies should spend their time innovating and competing on the merits of the products they offer—not misusing their intellectual property rights to hold up competitors to the detriment of innovation and consumer choice."

A spokeswoman for Motorola, Katie Dove, said: "We agree with the European Commission that injunctions should only be sought against unwilling licensees and, in this case, Motorola Mobility followed the procedure established," referring to a German Supreme Court ruling.

"Apple had to make six offers before the court recognised them as a willing licensee," she said in an e-mailed reaction.

Almunia's spokesman said no view had yet been reached on a related complaint by Microsoft, but spelt out when pressed on Google's involvement—Motorola Mobility is a wholly-owned subsidiary—that "most of the behaviour in question took place before the company was acquired by Google."

He said the row centred on "general packet radio services technology" involving "intermediate technologies between 2G and 3G standards," in other words older mobile phone functioning.

In April 2013, the US International Trade Commission tossed out a Motorola Mobility patent claim that threatened to block the importation of some Apple iPhone models into the United States.

Motorola had accused Apple of infringing on patented technology that makes touch screens ignore fingers when people are holding smartphones to their ears for calls.

Also in April 2013, Germany's patent court invalidated a patent held by Apple—and contested by rivals Motorola and Samsung—on its "slide to unlock" function for smartphones. It concluded that the horizontal swiping gesture was not a technical innovation in itself and therefore did not meet requirements of European patent law.

The aim of the function was to make it easier for users to unlock their smartphone and not solve a specific technical problem, the court said.

Explore further: Facebook CEO wants more students to explore tech

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

EU probes Motorola in patent war with Apple, Microsoft

Apr 03, 2012

European regulators opened Tuesday two antitrust investigations against Motorola Mobility, bought by US Internet giant Google, in the latest chapter of an escalating patent war with Apple and Microsoft.

Microsoft hits Motorola, Google with EU complaint

Feb 22, 2012

Microsoft on Wednesday lodged a formal complaint with the European Union's competition regulator against Motorola Mobility and its soon-to-be owner Google, saying Motorola's aggressive enforcement of patent ...

EU: Samsung injunctions against Apple breach rules

Dec 21, 2012

The European Commission said Friday that South Korea's Samsung Electronics was abusing its dominant market position in certain technologies when it took out injunctions against fierce rival Apple.

Recommended for you

Alibaba prices IPO at $68 per share

5 hours ago

Alibaba, the Chinese e-commerce powerhouse named after a fabled, poor woodsman who discovers a thieves' den full of treasures, is ready to strike it rich on the New York Stock Exchange.

Larry Ellison releases helm of mighty Oracle ship

8 hours ago

Tycoon yachtsman Larry Ellison on Thursday stepped down as Oracle's chief executive, trusting a pair of lieutenants to steer the titanic business software firm he helped launch decades ago.

Alibaba's plan: Today, China. Tomorrow, the world.

12 hours ago

Amazon and eBay should watch their backs. As Chinese e-commerce powerhouse Alibaba readies what could be the biggest initial public offering ever on the New York Stock Exchange, it is quietly hinting at plans ...

User comments : 0