Study shows students display 'visitor' and 'resident' characteristics when using social media for learning

Apr 29, 2013
This image shows network visualization diagrams of Google+ networks. Each dot is a person and each line represents an online connection between them. Credit: University of Leicester

University of Leicester-led research has shown that university students behave very differently when using social media as part of their academic learning.

Some happily use to about their course with their peers, in a similar way to how they might talk to friends on Facebook.

Others are much more targeted in their use of online tools – and will only log on to get the information they need, when they need it.

Visitors and Residents: mapping student attitudes to academic use of social networks, published in the journal Learning, Media and Technology, was conducted by Fiona Wright, a graduate of the University's School of Biosciences.

For the study, all 257 in the University's School of were asked to use the social media site Google+ as part of a key IT and numeracy skills module.

The students were able to discuss parts of the module on the site.

At the end of the term, the students had contributed thousands of posts and hundreds of thousands of words to +.

The researchers analysed these contributions, along with students' responses to a questionnaire about how they found the module.

This image shows network visualization diagrams of Google+ networks. Each dot is a person and each line represents an online connection between them. Credit: University of Leicester

They analysed the contribution to find out what users were talking about, and who was talking to whom. They also analysed the results from the questionnaire to find out why users communicated as they did.

They found that there were significant differences between students' use of social media – and individual participants displayed "Visitor" and "Resident" characteristics.

The Visitors and Residents model for online engagement was put forward by University of Oxford researchers David White and Dr Alison Le Cornu in 2011.

In this model, "Visitors" use the internet in functional terms as a tool, while "Residents" see the Internet as a social space.

The University of Leicester-led study suggests the Visitors and Residents model is valid – and is the first study to suggest this using statistical methods.

Fiona Wright conducted the study as part of her final year project of her Biological Science degree.

She said: "In order to know how to effectively teach using social media one needs to understand the student's motivation to use it. Such paradigms, if proven correct, help educators to approach this problem, increasing student engagement with tasks.

This image shows network visualization diagrams of Google+ networks. Each dot is a person and each line represents an online connection between them. Credit: University of Leicester

"Students of today often spend a large amount of their free time using social media, so if this tool could be used effectively for academic purposes it would be a great resource for teachers in higher education."

The paper was co-written with Dr Alan Cann, a senior lecturer in the Department of Biology – who leads the IT and Numeracy Skills for Biologists module.

Dr Alan Cann said: "Although forms a prominent part of most student's lives and is increasingly becoming part of academic environments, there has been little work investigating how students use and respond to social networks for formal academic purposes (as opposed to informal use).

"This is some of the first evidence which validates the Visitors and Residents model, and so it gives important insights into students reactions to social tools as part of a working environment.

"Although the Visitor and Resident labels only represent the extremes of a continuum of behaviour, this study has produced statistical evidence that Residents report to be more useful academically than Visitors do.

Explore further: Awarded a Pell Grant? Better double-check

More information: Fiona Wright, David White, Tony Hirst & Alan Cann (2013) Visitors and Residents: mapping student attitudes to academic use of social networks. Learning, Media and Technology, doi: 10.1080/17439884.2013.777077

Related Stories

Face-to-face or Facebook?

May 12, 2008

Can online networking sites, such as Facebook and MySpace, help new students settle into university social and academic life and minimise the chance of them withdrawing from their courses?

Facebook is 'social glue' for university freshers

Oct 14, 2008

The first few weeks at university can be a difficult time for freshers as they attempt to settle in to their new academic and social life. Researchers at the University of Leicester have found that a high proportion of freshers ...

GPA may be contagious in high-school social networks

Feb 13, 2013

High school students whose friends' average grade point average (GPA) is greater than their own have a tendency to increase their own GPA over the course of a year, according to research published February 13 in the open ...

Recommended for you

Awarded a Pell Grant? Better double-check

16 hours ago

(AP)—Potentially tens of thousands of students awarded a Pell Grant or other need-based federal aid for the coming school year could find it taken away because of a mistake in filling out the form.

Perthites wanted for study on the Aussie lingo

Jul 23, 2014

We all know that Australians speak English differently from the way it's spoken in the UK or the US, and many of us are aware that Perth people have a slightly different version of the language from, say, Melbournians - but ...

User comments : 0