Review: A solar home isn't for everyone

Apr 28, 2013 by Troy Wolverton

As someone who considers himself an environmentalist, I'd love to get a solar array for my home. But I'm finding that it may not make a lot of sense - at least right now. My wife and I drive fairly fuel-efficient cars. Our house is lit almost entirely with compact fluorescent and LED light bulbs. And our entertainment center is connected to a power strip that turns off all of our various game consoles and digital set-top boxes whenever the TV is off.

So getting a would be right in character for us. And with solar panel prices plunging and the sizable still available, now would seem a good time. With many of my neighbors installing systems, I figured I'd start shopping for one also.

But I quickly discovered our house is far from an ideal candidate for a solar system. First, we just don't use a lot of electricity. In fact, in the more than two years since we moved into our house, our electrical bill has topped $40 in a month only once.

I'd like to claim credit for that, but I can't. Yes, we try to be energy-efficient, but our real secret is that we don't have an or anything else in our house that sucks a lot of . The other big things that often boost - furnace, stove, clothes dryer and water heater - are all powered by gas.

While I'm happy to have a low electric bill, it means that installing a doesn't make a lot of financial sense. The general rule of thumb that installers give you is that switching to solar generally makes sense if you are spending at least $100 a month on electricity.

Even if you figure that we wouldn't need that large of a system to meet most of our electrical needs, it would still likely take us more than 20 years to break even on the system. And that's if we paid for it outright. If we financed it or got into one of the leasing options, it almost certainly would take longer. Given that we may not be in this house in 20 years, there's a decent chance that we'd never see the financial benefits of going solar.

I was still determined, in part for the psychological benefit of knowing that I was doing my small part to fight global warming. But there was another problem: Many installers won't install a system as small as the one we'd likely need.

And if that weren't enough, our house has another problem - shade.

Our neighbors have a two-story home that sometimes casts a shadow on the southwest side of our house. Worse yet, they have a tree in their front yard that's even taller than the house and shades parts of both the southwest and southeast sides of our house.

Those shadows are great for keeping our house cool, but they fall on the sides of the house that are the sweet spots for solar panels.

In fact, after reviewing satellite shots of our house, a representative of one installer I spoke with - SolarCity - said that the shadows were so significant that they wouldn't even consider putting in a system at our house.

I haven't given up hope yet. Other contractors I spoke with weren't as concerned about the shade issue. It's possible that they or someone else could design a system for our that's more cost-effective.

And solar may make more sense for us in the future if prices continue to fall or if we get that electric car I'm pining for. Assuming we bought a fully electric model, it could easily double the amount of electricity we use each month, meaning that a solar system might pay off much, much faster. But right now, as much as I hate to admit it, it's looking like solar isn't for us.

Explore further: Imaginative ideas for a 'greenlight district' in Amsterdam

2.9 /5 (9 votes)
add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Californians bask in solar energy

Jan 04, 2007

Soaring energy costs, environmental consciousness and financial incentives have combined to make solar panels part of the California housing landscape.

Harnessing the sun

Oct 05, 2009

The American Solar Energy Society's 2009 National Solar Tour took place Oct. 3 in 3,000 communities.

Checklist for going solar

Dec 04, 2009

With the sun setting before 5 p.m., solar power may be the last thing on your mind these days. But declining panel prices ans a federal tax credit make now a good time to at least investigate whether solar power might make ...

Nissan says electric car can power family home

Aug 02, 2011

Nissan's Leaf electric car can feed power from its battery back into a family home and run appliances for up to two days under a new project the Japanese car-maker unveiled Tuesday.

Recommended for you

Image: Testing electric propulsion

11 hours ago

On Aug. 19, National Aviation Day, a lot of people are reflecting on how far aviation has come in the last century. Could this be the future – a plane with many electric motors that can hover like a helicopter ...

Where's the real value in Tesla's patent pledge?

12 hours ago

With the much-anticipated arrival next month of electric vehicle manufacturer Tesla's Model S to Australian shores, it's a good time to revisit Tesla's pledge to freely share patents. ...

New type of solar concentrator doesn't block the view

Aug 19, 2014

(Phys.org) —A team of researchers at Michigan State University has developed a new type of solar concentrator that when placed over a window creates solar energy while allowing people to actually see through ...

Asian inventions dominate energy storage systems

Aug 19, 2014

In recent years, the number of patent applications for electrochemical energy storage technologies has soared. According to a study by the Technical University Munich, the largest volume of applications is ...

User comments : 1

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

yoatmon
5 / 5 (1) Apr 29, 2013
@ Troy:
Why did you marry your wife? Because everyone else around you was getting married or because you cared for here more than for any other and wanted to spend the rest of your life together with her??
The reasons you stated for not going solar are understandable but they are not justifiable.