The scientific legacy of 'undiscovering' an island

Apr 17, 2013
The scientific legacy of 'undiscovering' an island
Dr Maria Seton recently wrote an 'obituary' for Sandy Island in the journal 'EOS'.

The 'undiscovery' of an island by a team of scientists led by the University of Sydney resulted in worldwide scientific debate, the correction of databases and a re-evaluation of the infallibility of certain information.

"The mystery of Sandy Island called into question how well humanity really knows our own planet," said Dr Maria Seton, from the University's School of .

Dr Seton, was chief scientist on the RV Southern Surveyor last year when it undertook a voyage aimed at understanding the tectonic evolution of the eastern .

During the trip the team of Australian and 'undiscovered' Sandy Island, a 25km long and 5km wide feature, that appeared in numerous scientific data sets and in Earth but was absent from the hydrographic charts used onboard ship for navigation.

"The island was not there. The data we collected on the voyage and subsequently obtained from the Australian Hydrographic Service confirmed what we suspected - data sets showing the island were wrong."

There was intense global interest from traditional and social media and in Australia it became the most read story of 2012 on the Sydney Morning Herald's news website.

The scientific legacy of 'undiscovering' an island
The supposed 'Sandy Island' as seen on Google Earth.

Extensive scientific debate followed, as the undiscovery appeared to contradict some of the most fundamental data sets used by the , including global coastlines, water depths and products from including Google Earth.

"The response to the 'Sandy Island' story highlighted the strength and enthusiasm of the scientific community in coming together to resolve a controversy through crowd‐sourced research," Dr Seton said.

The outcome was that databases on which the scientific community rely are being updated and others are in the process of being corrected.

In a recent 'obituary' for Sandy Island written for the journal EOS, Dr Seton and her colleagues explain that Sandy Island was first sighted by the whaling ship Velocity in 1876 and first appears on a British admiralty map in 1908. Over the years a failure to spot the charted island resulted in its removal from hydrographic charts.

The answer to why it persisted in other data sets lies in the freely accessible World Vector Shoreline Database, originally developed by the American military and widely used by the scientific community.

"During the conversion from hard-copy charts to digital formats the 'Sandy Island' error was entrenched," said Dr Seton. "Inconsistencies in this data set exist in some of the least explored parts of our planet, a result of both human digitising errors and errors in the original maps from which the digitising took place."

Dr Seton reflects that the experience demonstrated the genuine interest the general public has in marine science and Earth exploration.

"It also underscores that although global data sets are an invaluable resource, users must be aware of the uncertainties of raw data inputs and it points to the invaluable contribution of marine scientific research voyages for accurately mapping the oceans."

As to the origin of the non-existent island first sighted by Velocity one possibility is that the crew may have sighted a vast pumice raft, large areas of floating pumice formed as result of volcanic eruptions.

"Whether originally pumice or a figment of a whaling crew's imagination 'Sandy Island' has been a valuable mythbusting adventure for all involved," Dr Seton said.

Explore further: Remnants of Tropical Depression Peipah still raining on Philippines

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Aussie scientists un-discover Pacific island

Nov 22, 2012

A South Pacific island identified on Google Earth and world maps does not exist, according to Australian scientists who went searching for the mystery landmass during a geological expedition.

Missing Pacific island riddle solved, researcher says

Dec 03, 2012

A New Zealand researcher Monday claimed to have solved the riddle of a mystery South Pacific island shown on Google Earth and world maps which does not exist, blaming a whaling ship from 1876. ...

Slab of Barrier Reef sea floor breaking off

Dec 21, 2012

A huge slab of sea floor near the Great Barrier Reef is in the early stages of collapse and could generate a tsunami when it finally breaks off, researchers warned Friday.

NASA Wallops recovery continues from Hurricane Sandy

Mar 06, 2013

(Phys.org) —Hurricane Sandy came ashore in northern New Jersey Oct. 29, 2012, and as the powerful storm made its way along the East Coast it brought damage to NASA's Wallops Flight Facility in Wallops Island, ...

Recommended for you

Agriculture's growing effects on rain

19 hours ago

(Phys.org) —Increased agricultural activity is a rain taker, not a rain maker, according to researchers at Pacific Northwest National Laboratory and their collaborators at the University of California Los ...

Asian air pollution affect Pacific Ocean storms

Apr 14, 2014

In the first study of its kind, scientists have compared air pollution rates from 1850 to 2000 and found that anthropogenic (man-made) particles from Asia impact the Pacific storm track that can influence ...

User comments : 0

More news stories

UN weather agency warns of 'El Nino' this year

The UN weather agency Tuesday warned there was a good chance of an "El Nino" climate phenomenon in the Pacific Ocean this year, bringing droughts and heavy rainfall to the rest of the world.

Low Vitamin D may not be a culprit in menopause symptoms

A new study from the Women's Health Initiative (WHI) shows no significant connection between vitamin D levels and menopause symptoms. The study was published online today in Menopause, the journal of The North American Menopa ...

Astronomers: 'Tilt-a-worlds' could harbor life

A fluctuating tilt in a planet's orbit does not preclude the possibility of life, according to new research by astronomers at the University of Washington, Utah's Weber State University and NASA. In fact, ...