Japan whale 'research' a flashpoint in global dispute

Apr 03, 2013 by Peter Brieger And Hiroshi Hiyama
Japanese fishermen slaughter a bottlenose whale east of Tokyo on June 25, 2008. Japan says the research that goes on behind locked doors is crucial for studying whale populations, but critics slam the practice as a loophole to get around an international ban on commercial whaling.

Japan says the work that goes on at the Institute of Cetacean Research is crucial for studying whale populations; critics counter it is a way to get around an international ban on commercial whaling.

The institute can be found in a nondescript white-brick office building in Tokyo's port district.

Down a hallway and through an unmarked door is a small lobby with a model ship, a poster showing various , and a sign that reads "Keep Out".

Captured whales are studied by the Institute, which refers to its work on them as "lethal research" before their meat is sold across Japan, including in restaurants in nearby Tsukiji market, where a sushi-style piece of the purple flesh costs a few dollars.

Telephone and fax requests for an interview went unanswered. An AFP reporter who visited the office recently was confronted by two men who did not identify themselves.

"What are you doing here? You are not supposed to be here. You have to leave," one said in English.

When told the taxpayer-funded institute had not responded to AFP's interview requests, he said: "That means no. It means we're not interested."

Norway and Iceland are the only other nations that hunt whales in open defiance of a 1986 , and Japan's annual hunt has drawn criticism from both activists and foreign governments.

But the Institute insists "anti-whaling is not 'world opinion'".

Graphic factfile on minke whales, main target of the Japanese Antarctic whale hunt. What Japan sees as research is at the heart of a bitter grudge match between militant activists intent on ending the nation's annual whale hunt and an equally determined Tokyo, which dismisses the campaigners as "terrorists".

"Rather, it is a predominantly Western phenomenon in amplified by anti-whaling fundraising NGOs (non-governmental organisations) and the Western media," it says on its website, pointing to hundreds of whaling .

"The purpose of Japan's research is science—science that will ensure that when is resumed it will be sustainable."

What Japan sees as research is at the heart of a bitter grudge match between militant activists intent on ending the nation's annual whale hunt and an equally determined Tokyo, which dismisses the campaigners as "terrorists".

Japan's whaling fleet left port in December aiming to catch about 1,000 whales in the icy waters of the Antarctic, where they are regularly pursued by militant environmentalist group Sea Shepherd. Activists said this year's hunt ended in March with no more than 75 whales killed.

They have clashed violently in exchanges that have in the past seen stink bombs thrown at Japanese crew and water jets trained on protesters. The bitter fight has also reached the legal arena with both sides launching lawsuits.

This handout photo taken on February 25, 2013 from the Japanese whaling ship Nisshin Maru shows an anti-whaling ship (C) coming between the Nisshin Maru and its fuel tanker. Japan's whaling fleet left port in December aiming to catch about 1,000 whales in the icy waters of the Antarctic, where they are regularly pursued by militant environmentalist group Sea Shepherd.

Tokyo says that researching the mammals is "perfectly legal" under international whaling rules, as is selling meat by-products. Organs including ovaries and stomach contents are crucial for research, the Institute says.

"Some indispensable data have to be collected by lethal means, which simply cannot be obtained by non-lethal means," it says, adding that death "is as rapid as possible".

"A large proportion of the whales taken are killed instantly by an explosive harpoon".

Critics question what remains for the Institute to conclude about sustainable after carrying out its research in the decades since the moratorium on international whaling was established.

"They (the Institute) don't really have an argument to justify themselves anymore," said Junichi Sato, executive director of Greenpeace Japan.

"If they can't get enough data by killing thousands of , then that is a failure of the science," he said.

But "it's about pride. Japan has been claiming this is part of Japanese culture. Once you raise that issue, it's very difficult to back down."

Questions remain about the economic viability of whaling given the decades-long decline in Japanese consumption of the meat. A report by the International Fund for Animal Welfare recently said the whaling programme costs Japanese taxpayers $10 million a year.

Crew of Japan's whale research vessels at a returning ceremony at Tokyo port on September 21, 2000. Questions remain about the economic viability of whaling given the decades-long decline in Japanese consumption of the meat.

There was little appetite among private firms to restart commercial whaling given the prohibitive expense, Sato said.

However, Fisheries minister Yoshimasa Hayashi recently told AFP in an interview that the hunt would continue, dismissing anti-whaling voices as "a cultural attack, a kind of prejudice against Japanese culture".

In the narrow streets around Tsukiji market, billed as the world's biggest fish emporium, that view was echoed by some who defended whaling as an important tradition, albeit a fading one.

Others feared job losses in the whaling sector if the hunt ended and criticised activists' in-your-face approach—even if they had little affection for whale meat itself.

"It is Japanese food culture," said 45-year-old Miuka Arita.

"People who decide they want to eat it should be allowed to do so. Just because () didn't grow up eating it does not justify the aggressive actions they take," she said.

Tamie Sawai doesn't think much of "dangerous actions" by conservationists either. But the 83-year-old added that she had not eaten whale meat in years.

"Its bacon was quite good, but I don't have any strong sense of nostalgia for whale meat," she said.

"I don't miss it at all."

Explore further: Invasive vines swallow up New York's natural areas

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Japan to continue Antarctic whaling: farm minister

Oct 04, 2011

Japan will go ahead with its annual whale hunt in Antarctica while boosting security to guard against possible harassment by environmental protesters, the agriculture and fisheries minister said Tuesday.

Japan vows to keep whale hunt after activist clash

Feb 21, 2013

Japan vowed to continue its whale hunt in the Southern Ocean after clashes with the militant conservationist Sea Shepherd group, which claimed Tokyo had been forced to end the mission.

Japan will never stop whaling, minister says

Feb 26, 2013

Japan's fisheries minister said Tuesday his country will never stop hunting whales, despite fierce criticism from other nations and violent clashes at sea with militant conservationists.

Recommended for you

Invasive vines swallow up New York's natural areas

17 hours ago

(Phys.org) —When Antonio DiTommaso, a Cornell weed ecologist, first spotted pale swallow-wort in 2001, he was puzzled by it. Soon he noticed many Cornell old-field edges were overrun with the weedy vines. ...

Citizen scientists match research tool when counting sharks

Apr 23, 2014

Shark data collected by citizen scientists may be as reliable as data collected using automated tools, according to results published April 23, 2014, in the open access journal PLOS ONE by Gabriel Vianna from The University of Wes ...

Researchers detail newly discovered deer migration

Apr 23, 2014

A team of researchers including University of Wyoming scientists has documented the longest migration of mule deer ever recorded, the latest development in an initiative to understand and conserve ungulate ...

How Australia got the hump with one million feral camels

Apr 23, 2014

A new study by a University of Exeter researcher has shed light on how an estimated one million-strong population of wild camels thriving in Australia's remote outback have become reviled as pests and culled ...

User comments : 7

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

Wolf358
1 / 5 (1) Apr 03, 2013
Doesn't the Japanese government know that eating whale meat makes your "private parts" shrink? Why aren't they telling their people?
C_elegans
1 / 5 (1) Apr 03, 2013
That's disgusting, Natello. Japanese are people, whales are whales.
ValeriaT
2.5 / 5 (4) Apr 03, 2013
And culture is culture...;-) You can justify all immoralities thinkable just with "culture specifics" of particular nation/social group and it actually did happen in the past regularly. And it still happens... After all, just the Japanese did use their people as a living sighting devices during kamikaze missions - which were undoubtedly "culturally specific" tradition too.
Sinister1811
1 / 5 (3) Apr 04, 2013
C_elegans sounds like someone who supports the Japanese whaling because (and I quote) "whales are whales". That just sounds a tad bit apathetic and human-centric.
C_elegans
1 / 5 (2) Apr 04, 2013
People before whales.

Why are we focusing on the Japanese so much? Other countries hunt whales as well. And we've killed just about every type of land animal known in the USA. Don't be racist in your ethical battles.

No one wants cute animals to die, but we must respect humanity first.
jibbles
1 / 5 (1) Apr 07, 2013
explosive harpoons? now that is traditional culture!
Sinister1811
2.7 / 5 (7) Apr 07, 2013
People before whales


Yes. A few thousand whales left in the ocean and 7 billion people on Earth, with that number set to double within the next 40 years. Which is more endangered, in terms of conservation status?

More news stories

Genetic code of the deadly tsetse fly unraveled

Mining the genome of the disease-transmitting tsetse fly, researchers have revealed the genetic adaptions that allow it to have such unique biology and transmit disease to both humans and animals.

Ocean microbes display remarkable genetic diversity

The smallest, most abundant marine microbe, Prochlorococcus, is a photosynthetic bacteria species essential to the marine ecosystem. An estimated billion billion billion of the single-cell creatures live i ...

Cell resiliency surprises scientists

New research shows that cells are more resilient in taking care of their DNA than scientists originally thought. Even when missing critical components, cells can adapt and make copies of their DNA in an alternative ...