New research exposes limitations of environmental models and data sets

Apr 17, 2013 by Martin Ince
Credit: Chris Smith

Our data on the natural world is uncertain. And so are the models we use to make sense of it. The Uncertweb project, funded by the EU, aims to clarify both of these sources of doubt. The project is designed to ensure that users appreciate the uncertainties contained within the environmental data and models. Many of these are increasingly found on the web and come without much indication as to their limitations. "If we don't have procedures that prevent anyone doing anything they like with data and models, you get a mashup, not reliable outputs, says project investigator Lucy Bastin, a software developer with a special interest in environmental data at Aston University in the UK. This approach has a wide range of applications in areas such as remote sensing and ecological forecasting.

Bastin points, as an example, to the series of models and data which is needed to calculate how much people are exposed to. "This requires data on the atmosphere and on human activity, both of which have to be modelled even before the results are combined. The same applies to and food production," she tells youris.com. " It is easy to download information on soil types and on the weather, but it has to be chained with a series of models to see whether a given area would still grow wheat with a particular level of climate change."

The project has produced a range of web tools to help. Some are used to quantify uncertainty in measurements. Others show how uncertainty in data propagates through models. The key, says Bastin, is to produce a series of that are simple to use and which "lower the barriers to visualising and communicating uncertainty."

As a result le, uncertainty will be built into Modelweb, a global project intended to improve our mapping of the world environment, according to Stefano Nativi, a division head at the Institute of Research at project partner CNR, the national Italian research agency, based in Rome.

Independent experts can only welcome this application, which is long overdue. "The project addresses a very fundamental problem," Alexis Comber, reader in geographic information at the University of Leicester in the UK tells youris.com. "Uncertainty is embedded in every data set, even about apparently simple issues such as sea level. You might think it is obvious where the sea is, but sea level is measured in different ways around the world."

Users need to be able to decide whether data is appropriate for the use they want to make of it. It is now simpler to do this. The same applies to models, which, Comber says, are approximations just as data is. He said: "Data quality is relative, depending on the use you want to put the data to, and Uncertweb allows you to get a handle on that. It'll be very interesting to see how this work progresses in future years."

This initiative is welcomed because it addresses a significant and difficult problem. "There is an increasingly active community of people taking models and data from the web, and we need to know more about the uncertainty that results when you use a chain of models in succession," explains a UK professor of tropical forestry, who asked not to be named. He concludes: "At the moment there are very few rules for the use of global data."

Explore further: Last month was hottest August since 1880

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Tropical clouds hold clues for the global water cycle

Jan 16, 2012

(PhysOrg.com) -- To study the wellspring of atmospheric water, you have to start with tropical clouds. Scientists at Pacific Northwest National Laboratory showed that global climate models are not accurately ...

Central European summer temperature variability to increase

Dec 18, 2012

More extreme heat waves have been observed in central Europe in recent years as summer temperature variability has increased on both daily and interannual timescales. Models project that as the climate warms throughout the ...

Recommended for you

Rio's Olympic golf course in legal bunker

9 hours ago

The return of golf to the Olympics after what will be 112 years by the time Rio hosts South America's first Games in 2016 comes amid accusations environmental laws were got round to build the facility in ...

User comments : 3

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

ScooterG
1 / 5 (2) Apr 23, 2013
"If we don't have procedures that prevent anyone doing anything they like with data and models, you get a mashup, not reliable outputs,"

So in other words, since such procedures are not yet in place, "scientists" are likely manipulating data and models...

I don't believe any set of procedures will correct a lack of personal integrity, but I'm pleased the author recognizes the inherent unreliability of climate change claims - some of us have been saying this very thing for years and years and years..
Howhot
not rated yet Apr 24, 2013
I think what it means Scooter is that as people ask more from computer models, more refined information is needed. For example, when a temperature rise of 2C happens to certain area, what will happen to the vegetation? Answering that question needs a lot more information than atmospheric reading. You need to know the type vegetation, it's environmental temperament, and weather the plant's eco-support system can handle the 2C change. Then you might have a better predictor. Computer modeling is not easy. Nor is understanding all of the nuances of an eco system easy.
ScooterG
1 / 5 (1) Apr 24, 2013
I think what it means Scooter is that as people ask more from computer models, more refined information is needed. For example, when a temperature rise of 2C happens to certain area, what will happen to the vegetation? Answering that question needs a lot more information than atmospheric reading. You need to know the type vegetation, it's environmental temperament, and weather the plant's eco-support system can handle the 2C change. Then you might have a better predictor. Computer modeling is not easy. Nor is understanding all of the nuances of an eco system easy.


Thank you - you just agreed with me in that climate change claims are unreliable.