Astronomers hint that our Sun won't terminate as the typical planetary nebula

April 19, 2013 by Dan Majaess, Universe Today
An artist’s illustration of a planetary nebula engulfing its orbiting planets. Credit: Regulus36/deviantart, adjusted by DM to mitigate compression effects

Textbooks often cite that planetary nebulae (PNe, plural) represent an endstate for lower-mass single stars. But conversely, recent research suggests that most PNe stem from binary systems. The lowest mass star theorized to form the typical PN is near 1 solar mass, and thus without a companion the Sun may not surpass the mass limit required to generate the hot glowing (ionized) nebula typically tied to PNe. New research continues to question our original understanding of how the Sun's life may end.

A new study spearheaded by G. Jacoby aimed in part to test that binary hypothesis by searching for PNe in star clusters occupying M31. The team remarked that, "while the binary interaction model explains some of the anomalies associated with the observed population, this theory awaits final confirmation."

"The traditional theory states that the progenitors of PNe are low- to intermediate-mass single stars … However, this theory does not provide a natural explanation for the non-spherical morphologies observed for the great majority of PNe, nor their low rate of formation. For these and other inconsistencies, a has been developed, wherein most PNe are shaped via the interaction … with a ," said Jacoby et al. 2013.

The advantage of finding a PN in a star cluster is that its fundamental parameters (e.g., progenitor mass, age, ) can be inferred from cluster membership. "It is difficult to probe the different PN formation scenarios using field stars, since one has almost no prior information about the properties of the PN progenitors. However, within star clusters, the situation is different, as both the age and of the progenitor can be accessed," said the Jacoby team.

The problem with using PNe in the field is that their parameters are poorly constrained, in part because distances to the objects are notoriously uncertain. "… the situation in distance determinations for Galactic PNe is not very satisfactory. It is estimated that this distance scale can be accurate on average to 35-50%," said Zhang 1995.

In recent years parallax measurements from the Hubble Space Telescope (Benedict et al. 2009) and the US Naval Observatory (Harris et al. 2007) have provided improved distances for some of the nearest PNe, and certain refined methods for estimating PNe distances may yield uncertainties as good as 20 to 30% (Frew and Parker 2006, Frew 2008, Stanghellini et al. 2008).

Jacoby et al. 2013 surveyed M31 in search of PNe that are members of star clusters. A positive detection would enable the fundamental parameters (e.g., progenitor mass, age) for the PN to be ascertained. Credit: Noel Carboni and Greg Parker

In many instances the distances to star clusters can be determined more precisely (better than 15%), which provides an impetus for finding cluster PNe. The team note that, "[In particular,] the low turnoff mass of old globular clusters (GCs) provides a tool with which to probe the [planetary nebula] binary formation scenario directly. Because GCs generally have turnoff masses less than 1 [] … Any PN detected in [globular clusters] must therefore come from an alternate evolutionary channel, such as a common-envelope interaction or a mass augmentation process (i.e., a stellar merger)." PNe are suspected to stem from 1 to 8 solar mass stars.

Jacoby et al. 2013 note that, "out of 130 Galactic GCs surveyed, only four host PNe: Ps 1 in M15, GJJC-1 in M22, JaFu1 in Pal 6, and JaFu2 in NGC 6441. Two of these PNe have high mass central stars more appropriate to PNe within [younger] open clusters, while the others have highly non-spherical nebulae. These facts, along with the observation that three of the four PNe are located in clusters that are rich in X-ray sources, suggest that interacting binaries play a role in the formation of cluster PNe."

“The locations of … the targeted M31 clusters, superposed on a mosaic of [OIII] images.” Credit: Jacoby et al. 2013/arXiv/ApJ, extracted by DM

The team observed 467 star clusters in M31 with the WIYN telescopes, which are stationed at Kitt Peak. The team identified PNe by searching for their signature nebular emission lines. The team likewise examined whether the and PNe exhibited common velocities. "The better the velocity resolution of the survey, the easier it is to separate embedded PNe from chance superpositions, and to distinguish a clusterbound PN from other unrelated emission-line sources along the line of sight, such as H II regions, SNRs, and diffuse emission," said Jacoby et al. 2013.

The team conclude that, "Of the 270 M31 globular cluster candidates observed with sufficient velocity precision, five show evidence for a candidate PN. Given the luminosity limits of the survey, the uncertainties in the velocity measurements, and the potential for confusion with other emission-line sources … These numbers are also marginally consistent with the binary hypothesis for PN formation …"

However, the Jacoby team notes that the, "… five PN candidates [identified] among the young [open] clusters in our sample … are likely superpositions." A similar conclusion was reached by researchers surveying Galactic PNe found along the sight-line of open clusters (e.g., PN NGC 2438 in the cluster M46, Kiss et al. 2008).

Indeed, merely a few promising cases of PNe in Galactic were reported recently (e.g., PN Abell 8/Bica 6, PHR 1315-6555/Andrews-Lindsay 1; Bonatto et al. 2008, Parker et al. 2011), and a team led by astronomer Christian Moni Bidin (VVV survey) aims to soon publish another promising Galactic pair. However, further research is needed to independently confirm such cases given their importance.

Lastly, Jacoby et al. 2013 emphasize that, "[their M31 PNe are] candidates only. Hubble Space Telescope narrow-band images are needed to confirm their existence … However, once confirmed, these targets represent a new source of material for understanding the physics of PN formation, and the chemistry of their parent clusters."

Do most of the observed PNe stem from ? Will the Sun become a canonical PN? Answers to those questions are presently uncertain, and additional research is needed to understand such a crucial stage in the evolution of stars like the Sun.

The Jacoby et al. 2013 findings have been accepted for publication in the Astrophysical Journal (ApJ), and a preprint is available on arXiv.

Explore further: Hubble Sees Star Cluster 'Infant Mortality'

More information:

Related Stories

Hubble Sees Star Cluster 'Infant Mortality'

January 10, 2007

Astronomers have long known that young or "open" star clusters must eventually disrupt and dissolve into the host galaxy. They simply don't have enough gravity to hold them together, unlike their much more massive cousins, ...

Help! My stars are leaking!

September 16, 2011

Star clusters are wonderful test beds for theories of stellar formation and evolution. One of the key roles they play is to help astronomers understand the distribution of stellar masses as stars form (in other words, how ...

VISTA finds new globular star clusters

October 19, 2011

( -- Two newly discovered globular clusters have been added to the total of just 158 known globular clusters in our Milky Way. They were found in new images from ESO’s VISTA survey telescope as part of the ...

First low-mass star detected in globular cluster

December 15, 2011

Even the most powerful high-tech telescopes are barely able to record remote low-mass and thus faint stars. Together with researchers from Poland and Chile, an astrophysicist from the University of Zurich has now detected ...

Hubble sees an unexpected population of young-looking stars

November 2, 2012

(—The NASA/ESA Hubble Space Telescope offers an impressive view of the center of globular cluster NGC 6362. The image of this spherical collection of stars takes a deeper look at the core of the globular cluster, ...

Recommended for you

Blue skies, frozen water detected on Pluto

October 8, 2015

Pluto has blue skies and patches of frozen water, according to the latest data out Thursday from NASA's unmanned New Horizons probe, which made a historic flyby of the dwarf planet in July.

Orbiter views Mars surface fractures

October 8, 2015

The High Resolution Imaging Science Experiment (HiRISE) camera aboard NASA's Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter often takes images of Martian sand dunes to study the mobile soils. These images provide information about erosion and ...

How to prepare for Mars? NASA consults Navy sub force

October 5, 2015

As NASA contemplates a manned voyage to Mars and the effects missions deeper into space could have on astronauts, it's tapping research from another outfit with experience sending people to the deep: the U.S. Navy submarine ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.