Steganography is no laughing matter

Mar 12, 2013

It is possible to hide secret messages in simple jokes, according to US research published in the latest issue of the International Journal of Security and Networks.

Encrypting a message with a strong code is the only safe way to keep your communications secret, but it will be obvious to anyone seeing such a message that the sender is hiding something, regardless of whether they are encrypting their emails for legitimate or illicit purposes. Steganography on the other hand can hide a secret message in plain sight. Often a message is secreted within the binary strings of 0s and 1s in a compressed image or music . Prying eyes see only the original image or hear the song, whereas the recipient, knowing that a message is within uses software to extract it. Nevertheless, a putative might still take place; this kind of disguise also has the problem of requiring large file sizes.

An alternative to such steganography would be to hide a message in plain sight within a plain text document. Unfortunately, despite the much smaller file sizes that would be possible, secreting a message within normal text usually disrupts the grammar and syntax or the spelling and so immediately looks suspicious. Now, an approach that is far less obvious and is tolerant of poor grammar has been developed by computer scientist Abdelrahman Desoky of the University of Maryland in Baltimore County, USA and is described in the latest issue of the International Journal of Security and Networks.

Desoky suggests that instead of using a humdrum text document and modifying it in a codified way to embed a secret message, correspondents could use a joke to hide their true meaning. As such, he has developed an Automatic Joke Generation Based Steganography Methodology (Jokestega) that takes advantage of recent software that can automatically write pun-type jokes using large dictionary databases. Among the automatic joke generators available are: The MIT Project, Chuck Norris Joke Generator, Jokes2000, The Joke Generator dot Com and the Online Joke Generator System (pickuplinegen).

A simple example might be to hide the code word "shaking" in the following auto-joke. The original question and answer joke is "Where do milk shakes come from?" and the correct answer would be "From nervous cows". So far, so funny. But, the system can substitute the word "shaking" for "nervous" and still retain the humor so that the answer becomes "From shaking cows". It loses some of its wit, but still makes sense and we are not all Bob Hopes, after all.

Other examples where substitutions are possible might include the equally funny: What do you get when you cross a car with a sandwich? A traffic jam, which might use a well-known sandwich bar brand, "Subway" as an alternative answer. Similarly, Where is Dracula's American office? The answer being the Vampire State Building. The question could be substituted as Where is Dracula's American home? With the same answer. There are endless puns any one of which might be used in a similar setting. A collection of such jokes sent in a message with the non-obvious answer substituted for the wittier version could conceal a message using Jokestega. Desoky suggests that 8 bits of data might be hidden in a simple joke of the type discussed.

Explore further: Researcher develops method for monitoring whether private information is sufficiently protected

More information: "Jokestega: automatic joke generation-based steganography methodology" in Int. J. Security and Networks, 2013, 7, 148-160

Related Stories

Embedding spy secrets in the hard drive fragments

Apr 26, 2011

(PhysOrg.com) -- A new way to hide your secrets has been created, which is good news for both the spies and the generally duplicitous regular people of the world. This new system, instead of relying on traditional methods ...

Hide files within files for better data security

May 09, 2011

Steganography is a form of security through obscurity in which information is hidden within an unusual medium. An artist might paint a coded message into a portrait, for instance, or an author embed words in the text. A traditional ...

'Unfunny, unlike': The Onion joke raises eyebrows

Sep 29, 2011

The satirical news publication The Onion gets a lot of laughs by crossing the line. But even some of the most devoted fans of the popular humor outlet were complaining on Thursday that it may have gone too ...

Recommended for you

Tackling urban problems with Big Data

20 hours ago

Paul Waddell, a city planning professor at the University of California, Berkeley, with a penchant for conducting research with what he calls his "big urban data," is putting his work to a real-world test ...

Computer-assisted accelerator design

Apr 22, 2014

Stephen Brooks uses his own custom software tool to fire electron beams into a virtual model of proposed accelerator designs for eRHIC. The goal: Keep the cost down and be sure the beams will circulate in ...

User comments : 6

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

hylozoic
not rated yet Mar 12, 2013
old, old news. Still the best way to share secrets, though. It's fun to see how far you can go with a friend while out at a bar or coffee shop. Acknowledge beforehand the 'actual' subject, then publicly have a drawn out dialogue using metaphor, which seems to all listeners as though it is not metaphor.
NickFun
not rated yet Mar 12, 2013
So to find the hidden files just look for the worst jokes!
ValeriaT
1 / 5 (1) Mar 12, 2013
It would explain, why so many posters here are attempting for silly meaningless OT jokes. They're all hidden theorrist!
Whydening Gyre
1 / 5 (3) Mar 12, 2013
A ferret walks into a bar...
Isaacsname
not rated yet Mar 13, 2013
What's the best time to go to the dentist ?

2:30
AlexNRoss
not rated yet Mar 13, 2013
This is such an old method of stenography, see: The Riddler from Batman. Ideally, if you wanted to put a secret message into an image; you would user multiple image layers and each layer would contain a partial to the message and then send an encrypted key to put it together. Using the layers of imaging put together and a key it will describe a page out of a book (even a code book) to get the real message. Good luck breaking that!

More news stories

Google+ boss leaving the company

The executive credited with bringing the Google+ social network to life is leaving the Internet colossus after playing a key role there for nearly eight years.

Facebook woos journalists with 'FB Newswire'

Facebook launched Thursday FB Newswire, billed as an online trove of real-time information for journalists and newsrooms to mine while reporting on events or crafting stories.

Genetic legacy of rare dwarf trees is widespread

Researchers from Queen Mary University of London have found genetic evidence that one of Britain's native tree species, the dwarf birch found in the Scottish Highlands, was once common in England.