Training soldiers to disobey 'illegal' orders

March 27, 2013
QUT legal expert Dr Carmel O'Sullivan's study looked at the legal liability of soldiers obeying the unlawful orders of their commander in combat.

The military should be cautiously training soldiers to disobey unlawful superior's orders as a way of legally protecting them against a criminal conviction, according to QUT legal expert Dr Carmel O'Sullivan.

Dr O'Sullivan, who has completed her PhD examining The Legal Position of the Obedient Soldier: The Defence of Superior Orders as an Effective and Practical Standard, recommended a cautious approach be taken to introduce reality-based training that conditions to defy illegal orders.

"Obedience is a central element of ," Dr O'Sullivan said.

"As such, training conditions unquestioning obedience, which significantly increases the likelihood that the reasonable soldier in combat will obey the orders of his superior irrespective of the order being legal or illegal.

"While this conditioned response contributes to important military purposes, they also affect the application of the defence of superior orders."

Dr O'Sullivan's study looked at the of soldiers obeying the unlawful orders of their commander in combat.

Specifically, it focused on whether the current legal standard for determining a soldier's liability was an effective and practical standard, given the effects of military training and the realities of .

"I wanted to see if the current standard we hold soldiers accountable to, is actually a practical one," she said.

Dr O'Sullivan focused her study on the Rome Statute of the - which was set up as a permanent criminal court to try soldiers and civilians who engage in war crimes and crimes against humanity and .

"From a legal perspective, what the ICC says is that a soldier can only raise a defence of superior orders to a war crime and that the defence can be used only if they didn't know the order was illegal or if it wasn't manifestly unlawful," she said.

"Military training that promotes obedience without question or delay is incompatible with the doctrine of superior orders, which requires soldiers to question the legality of orders.

"International law and the military aim to offset this incongruity by providing that soldiers are obliged to obey lawful orders only. Yet soldiers are generally not trained to disobey illegal orders.

"There does not appear to be simulated and scenario training where soldiers are issued illegal orders that they must identify and disobey."

Dr O'Sullivan said instead of merely informing soldiers of the legal duty to disobey, the identification and disobedience of illegal orders should be incorporated into daily training.

She said reality-based training, such as realistic scenario and situational training, had been very successful in improving soldiers "fighting performance and should be utilised to improve the soldiers" identification and disobedience of illegal orders.

But Dr O'Sullivan warned this had the potential to present its own challenges and dangers.

"Disobedience may breed a sense of uncertainty as the soldiers may feel that they cannot rely on the orders of their superiors," she said.

"It may also weaken the obedience of the soldier, which is a cornerstone of the military. For this reason, the military should implement this recommendation with caution and sensitivity.

"Therefore, it is recommended that the military uses reality-based training techniques to train soldiers to identify and disobey illegal orders. However, the military must implement this with caution in order to prevent excessive disobedience or uncertainty."

Explore further: US soldiers in Iraq fighting drug-resistant bacteria after injuries

Related Stories

Army personnel show increased risk for migraine

August 27, 2008

Two new studies show that migraine headaches are very common among U.S. military personnel, yet the condition is frequently underdiagnosed. The studies, appearing in Headache, the peer-reviewed journal of the American Headache ...

Recommended for you

Early human diet explains our eating habits

August 31, 2015

Much attention is being given to what people ate in the distant past as a guide to what we should eat today. Advocates of the claimed palaeodiet recommend that we should avoid carbohydrates and load our plates with red meat ...

Just how good (or bad) is the fossil record of dinosaurs?

August 28, 2015

Everyone is excited by discoveries of new dinosaurs – or indeed any new fossil species. But a key question for palaeontologists is 'just how good is the fossil record?' Do we know fifty per cent of the species of dinosaurs ...

Fractals patterns in a drummer's music

August 28, 2015

Fractal patterns are profoundly human – at least in music. This is one of the findings of a team headed by researchers from the Max Planck Institute for Dynamics and Self-Organization in Göttingen and Harvard University ...

2 comments

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

Argiod
2 / 5 (4) Mar 27, 2013
So long as a soldier is not allowed to challenge orders; the individual soldier should not be held responsible for carrying out such orders; rather, the responsibility should rest squarely upon the officer issuing the orders. The only exception is that officers should be trained to evaluate orders of their superiors in light of appropriateness to the situation at hand. In other-words; an officer should consider the situation and interpret higher command's orders and their intent in light of the in-the-field observations the officer perceives that cannot be appreciated by command. And, in fact, in the American Armed Forces, the commanding officer always has 'discretionary latitude' to interpret and execute his orders according to the situation he is dealing with.
ValeriaT
1 / 5 (1) Mar 28, 2013
Theoretically it could enable you to dismiss your participation in war, because most of wars have no support in existing laws of countries in conflict.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.