New opportunities for 3-D technology in medicine

Mar 06, 2013
A surgeon practices sewing up a wound without a direct view. Doing so is more effi cient with 3D screens. Credit: Fraunhofer HHI

Until now, physicians have largely been skeptical of the advantages of 3D technology. But this may be about to change: the findings of a new study show that even experienced surgeons stand to benefit from the third dimension.

While physicians have largely ignored 3D until now, it appears to be getting a second chance, according to a new study of the , Heinrich Hertz Institute HHI and Klinikum rechts der Isar university hospital in Munich. Thanks in particular to improved and screens, practical tests have recently shown that 3D systems used in medical technology have benefits that were once believed to be purely theoretical. The researchers showed that even experienced physicians could benefit from the latest generation of 3D devices. In the past, doctors have been rather skeptical of 3D images. In tests conducted over the course of the study, however, some 50 surgeons responded positively to 3D systems both with and without glasses. "While the technology still requires some fine-tuning, technology that does without the need to wear special glasses will increase the popularity of 3D systems in operating rooms. In the past, surgeons were hesitant to use the technology precisely because of the glasses," says Dr. Ulrich Leiner, head of the department at HHI.

Screen resolution continues to improve

The study was conducted as a result of current developments in 3D screen technology. 4K models for that offer quad HD resolution are already available. "The next step is ultra-high definition with 8K. This will mark a sixteen-fold improvement on the resolution of currently available full-HD images," says Michael Witte of HHI in explaining current trends. Mr. Witte is convinced that 3D without glasses will contribute to a lasting breakthrough. "This is why the researchers thought it was to carry out a scientific test that would assess whether 3D technology has reached the level of maturity required of sensitive hospital applications. They invited surgeons at Klinikum rechts der Isar's surgical hospital to test the latest generation of 3D devices."

Surgeons participating in the test tried a total of four different screen systems: 2D, 3D with and without glasses, and a mirror apparatus that served as the "ideal" 3D model. Images were delivered by endoscopic cameras that the doctors used during a simulated routine surgical procedure. Using a needle and thread, the physicians sewed up a wound with ten stitches in a model abdominal cavity. Just as would be the case in a minimally invasive surgical procedure, the surgeons did not have a direct view of their hands, and thus depended on the screen.

"The results were astonishing: with the glasses-based 3D system, the procedure was more than 15 percent shorter, and precision increased considerably. Hand movements were more targeted than with the 2D model. As far as I know, we have not observed this effect among our experienced surgeons in the past," says Professor Hubertus Feußner in describing the test winner. The surgeon, who has worked at Klinikum rechts der Isar for over 30 years, has conducted several thousand operations. "In the past, it was the most experienced physicians in particular who were very skeptical of 3D technology. And this was not only because it hardly offered any tangible benefits. Many physicians felt uncomfortable looking at the screens, and preferred to rely on their experience as a result," says PD Dr. Silvano Reiser, Feußner's colleague.

Model without glasses is the future of 3D

The model without glasses also made a positive impression: test participants considered its quality as comparable to 2D. "Unfortunately, the system we developed was unable to take the first place ranking. But the first 'hard' practical medical test showed great promise, as we were able to work on the fundamental eye-tracking technology. This is where, through eye-tracking, cameras follow both eyes, and each eye sees a separate image. This creates a 3D effect without glasses," Leiner says. Both researchers see a bright future for 3D: "The study demonstrated that 3D has become an option for surgeons as well. This will revive the discussion among skeptics. And now there is a need for tests in other medical disciplines."

Explore further: Magic Leap moves beyond older lines of VR

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Sony, Panasonic, Samsung in 3D glasses deal

Aug 09, 2011

Japan's Sony and Panasonic and South Korea's Samsung Electronics said Tuesday they will jointly develop new standards for glasses used to watch 3D images on television, computer and movie screens.

Toshiba to launch no-glasses 3D monitors

Apr 07, 2011

(PhysOrg.com) -- Rumors are flying out of Taiwan. Those rumors claim that Toshiba is working on a line of 3D laptops that do not require the users to have 3D glasses on their face. The concept of no-glasses 3D is something ...

The worlds smallest 3D HD display

May 16, 2011

(PhysOrg.com) -- It seems like small displays are all of the rage these days, and they just keep getting more and more advanced. In October of last year Ortus Technology created a 4.8-inch liquid crystal ...

Recommended for you

Magic Leap moves beyond older lines of VR

14 hours ago

Two messages from Magic Leap: Most of us know that a world with dragons and unicorns, elves and fairies is just a better world. The other message: Technology can be mindboggingly awesome. When the two ...

Oculus Rift users to see Moon live through robot

Oct 23, 2014

A group from Carnegie Mellon wants to send a robot to the Moon to beam live pictures of the Moon to Oculus Rift headset users, reported technology reporter Jane Wakefield of the BBC. Andy the robot is intended ...

Skin icons can tap into promise of smartwatch

Oct 21, 2014

You have heard it before: smartwatches are cool wearables but critics remind us of the fact that their small size makes many actions cumbersome and they question how many people will really have them on their ...

User comments : 0