Why sticking around is sometimes the better choice for males

Mar 26, 2013
Burying beetles, unlike humans, stop caring for young when females mate with other males because this happens frequently and providing care reduces their survival. Credit: Per Smiseth

Researchers from Lund University and the University of Oxford have been able to provide one answer as to why males in many species still provide paternal care, even when their offspring may not belong to them. The study finds that, when the conditions are right, sticking around despite being 'cuckolded' actually turns out to be the most successful evolutionary strategy. The study, by Charlie Cornwallis and colleagues, is published 26 March in the open access journal PLOS Biology.

In many species, males put a lot of effort into caring for offspring that are not their own. At first glance this makes little sense, because should dictate that males only care for the offspring that carry their genes. However, this study suggests that the males are both more tolerant and more astute than previously assumed, and in fact adjust their care according to how likely it is that females are unfaithful, whilst also judging whether caring will potentially reduce the number of offspring they can have in the future.

The researchers conducted a meta-analysis of 62 studies across 48 different species including insects, fish, birds and . Overall, the researchers found that promiscuous copulations by females reduced the investment of males by 12%. Although parental care is highly variable across these species, the researchers were able to find a general explanation for why sticking around to care for the offspring is the better choice for some males that have been usurped. The reason is that males tend to be more accepting of fathered by other males in species where the risk of cuckoldry is generally low, or when caring does not harm their future .

"This, to me, shows the strength of natural selection, with its footprints clear in species from burying —which care for young over a few weeks by regurgitating dead mice—to humans, who spend years providing for their children", says Charlie Cornwallis, researcher at the Department of Biology, Lund University. "These are complex calculations that males are making," he adds, "and it has been difficult to measure the relevant factors correctly, but looking across species has helped us work out what is going on. Moreover, a comparative study like this can guide researchers to the types of species and experimental cues that are likely to provide the most insight into paternal care in the future."

The study therefore opens up the possibility of more targeted research in the area. Now that the researchers know what factors are important, they can design studies to further test their findings and predict what males will do in species that have not yet been studied. For example, in species where the cost of caring is very low, males would not be expected to adjust their level of parental care even if the females are promiscuous. Rather than these males being 'duped', such tolerance has actually been favoured by natural selection.

Explore further: Aging white lion euthanized at Ohio zoo

More information: Griffin AS, Alonzo SH, Cornwallis CK (2013) Why Do Cuckolded Males Provide Paternal Care? PLoS Biol 11(3): e1001520. doi:10.1371/journal.pbio.1001520 www.plosbiology.org/article/in… journal.pbio.1001520

Related Stories

Why birds of a feather lek together

Feb 29, 2012

Certain kinds of male birds gather into small clusters of land called leks to perform their courtship dances, and according to science, who they choose to associate with matters. A new study by University ...

Recommended for you

A vegetarian carnivorous plant

Dec 19, 2014

Carnivorous plants catch and digest tiny animals in order and derive benefits for their nutrition. Interestingly the trend towards vegetarianism seems to overcome carnivorous plants as well. The aquatic carnivorous bladderwort, ...

User comments : 5

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

VendicarE
1 / 5 (1) Mar 26, 2013
This is interesting to me because it parallels the plight of American society.

Now that Americans have been screwed by Corporations, those corporations have fled the nation and refusing to pay for the results of their policies.
Whydening Gyre
1 / 5 (3) Mar 27, 2013
Interesting (and apt) observation...
FainAvis
5 / 5 (1) Mar 27, 2013
I do not understand how a beetle is supposed to determine his paternity or not of this or that grubby little offspring.
Jimbaloid
not rated yet Mar 27, 2013
I do not understand how a beetle is supposed to determine his paternity or not of this or that grubby little offspring.


He doesn't need to, it's all a numbers game played out across the entire population and many generations. Think of it as the 'average behaviour' for beetles of that type. Individuals will have variation in their behaviour and ultimately it is this variation that drives the evolutionary process.
d3bug
1 / 5 (1) Mar 27, 2013
Sometimes I think the animal world has it right... After all, a male Praying Mantis will never be nagged to death.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.