The 'criminal' immigrant

February 6, 2013

Politicians often use rhetoric about "crime-prone" immigrants to support tough-on-immigration legislation.

But recent research suggests immigrants do not increase crime and may actually help reduce it, according to University of Dayton sociologist Jamie Longazel.

So why does the crime stereotype persist?

"I call it a subordinating myth," Longazel said. "It's an effort to put immigrants in a lower social status. When the dominant population perceives a threat, they will do things to minimize that threat."

In a new article in Sociology Compass released Feb. 4, Longazel writes that casting Latino immigrants as criminals is a method of racial hoarding—excluding this group from access to material, cultural and political resources.

He identifies four ways the criminalization of immigrants, specifically , contributes to their exclusion and subordination:

  • Profiting from immigration detention
  • Political scapegoating
  • Degrading efforts
  • Literal control of exploitable populations through fear of deportation
Currently, just under 400,000 immigrants are detained each year in the U.S., an all-time high. Almost half, most of whom are Latino, are housed in . In fact, the private prison industry was pulled out of financial peril in the late 1990s by a surge in immigrant detention, Longazel said.

"Immigrants have thus quite literally become the 'raw materials' of a now booming for-profit prison industry," he said.

Politicians use immigrants as a scapegoat for working class whites to blame for failed economic policies. Longazel's hometown of Hazleton, Pa., passed the Relief Act after officials induced a panic prompted by unproven allegations that two undocumented Latino men murdered a white resident. The local media coverage of that murder was far more hysterical than it had been following the murder of a Latino man seven months prior.

The mayor was able to rally support to pass an anti-immigrant law, depicting all of Hazleton's problems as caused by undocumented immigrants. Yet crime rates in Hazleton actually declined in the period between immigrant arrival and the passage of the law, Longazel said.

Meanwhile, officials had offered massive tax incentives to attract a meatpacking plant to Hazleton in 2001 that Longazel said exploited immigrant labor, hiring 1,300 workers—90 percent of whom were Latino—for low-paying, non-union jobs.

"Politically positioning oneself as 'tough on immigration,' in other words, has proved beneficial to politicians across the nation and quelled dissent on economic policies that negatively affect native-born workers and exploited immigrant laborers alike," he said.

The subordinating myth of criminalization also degrades immigrants, who often feel targeted simply for looking or sounding a certain way, which can take an emotional and physical toll on a person's health. Longazel cites research that found "appearing Mexican"—even for American citizens—emerged as the best predictor of being mistreated by immigration authorities.

As a result of this profiling and suspicion, immigrant populations are often afraid to expand their social circles and do not feel free. Many will not report crimes to the police, leading to a great irony: falsely labeling immigrants as criminals ultimately leads to their increased vulnerability as crime victims.

In Longazel's assessment, immigration policies and enforcement agencies are neither equipped nor intended to actually keep the undocumented out. On the contrary, he says, their purpose is to facilitate the creation of vulnerability, which enables exploitation.

"From this perspective, there exists no contradiction: the criminalization of is clearly and explicitly a racial project."

Explore further: Post-9/11 immigration enforcement lowered demand for undocumented workers

Related Stories

Immigration growth in Spain has not caused more crime

June 25, 2012

Society tends to perceive an increase in the immigrant population with an increase in crime. But, according to a new study, it is not possible to infer this cause-effect relationship in the case of Spain.

Recommended for you

An inflexible diet led to the disappearance of the cave bear

August 23, 2016

Senckenberg scientists have studied the feeding habits of the extinct cave bear. Based on the isotope composition in the collagen of the bears' bones, they were able to show that the large mammals subsisted on a purely vegan ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

5 / 5 (2) Feb 06, 2013
Sounds about right pretty much everywhere, not just in the US. Governments have to work pretty hard to manipulate statistics to make it look like immigrants are a crime problem. In Japan they include the crime of not carrying your foreigner registration card with you to boost the numbers.
5 / 5 (1) Feb 07, 2013
If Immigrants aren't responsible for America's crime waves then why do Conservative news outlets claim that they are?

Shouldn't America secure it's borders with deadly force to keep out these murderous illegal immigrant criminals?

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.