Controversial dam removals founded on value conflicts

Feb 22, 2013
Removal of the Kuba dam on the Nätra river in March 2007. Credit: Håkon Söderberg

Researchers at Umeå University conclude that public opposition to dam removal is not based on knowledge deficiency, as is sometimes argued in dam removal science. It is instead a case of different understandings and valuation of the environment and the functions it provides. The findings are now published in the journal Ecology and Society.

Dam removal is an increasingly common practice as old splash dams and small hydropower dams have become obsolete. Although the removal of these dams has by restoring rivers to their former courses, local residents sometimes contest dam removals.

"We wanted to understand how the proponents and opponents of dam removal think about the function of two contrasting ecosystems – an existing dam with a pond and a potential running stream without the pond. The local people who fight to have a dam remain in place have often been dismissed as unknowledgeable," says Dolly Jørgensen, environmental historian at the Department of Ecology and .

Together with ecologist Birgitta Malm-Renöfält, she investigated the types of arguments made for and against dam removal in newspaper articles about dams in the Swedish towns Alby, Hallstahammar, Orsa, and Tallåsen.

They found that those who want to remove the dam place a high value on the return of game fish to the ecosystem, , and restoration in general. Opponents want the dam to remain because of recreational opportunities for bathing and beaches, the aesthetics of the pond's still water, and the of the pond and the historic dam.

"The is not based on knowledge deficiency, where more information would lead to better ecological decision-making. The locals simply value different aspects of the environment than scientists or that want the dam removed, " says Dolly Jørgensen.

As the number of dam removal projects continues to grow in Sweden and other places in the world, controversies are likely to become more common. Because a decision to remove or keep the dam will result in one side losing the ecosystem services they value, compromise solutions may be difficult to reach.

Explore further: California becomes first state to ban plastic bags

More information: Jørgensen, D. and Renöfält, B. 2013. Damned If You Do, Dammed If You Don't: Debates on Dam Removal in the Swedish Media. Ecology and Society 18 (1): 18.
www.ecologyandsociety.org/vol18/iss1/art18/

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Dam removal increases property values

Apr 17, 2008

Two new studies appearing in Contemporary Economic Policy explore the impact of dam removal on local property values and find that property values increase after dams are removed.

Dams -- what goes up must come down, and then what?

Nov 07, 2011

Time can take its toll on a dam. As dams age, they are more costly to repair and the risk of a catastrophic dam break increases--putting property and lives at risk. But, removing them can mean big changes to the community, ...

Small dams need better management

Feb 14, 2012

Many small dams around the world are poorly maintained and represent a safety hazard, according to Pisaniello et al. Better oversight of small dams is needed, the authors argue. The researchers reviewed literature, conducted ...

Brazil court orders work on Amazon dam suspended

Aug 14, 2012

A federal court in Brazil has ordered the suspension of work on the huge Belo Monte hydro-electric dam in the Amazon, the third largest dam in the world, a court official said Tuesday.

Building a better dam map

Jun 02, 2011

Humans have been building reservoirs and dams for thousands of years. Over the past few decades, their construction has spiked as our need to harness water – critical in flood control, irrigation, recreation, navigation ...

Thai villagers in legal challenge against Laos dam

Aug 07, 2012

Thai opponents of a planned multi-billion dollar dam in Laos submitted a lawsuit to a court in Bangkok on Tuesday seeking to prevent their country buying power from the hydropower project.

Recommended for you

Can fair trade plastic save people and the planet?

5 hours ago

(Phys.org) —It's old news that open-source 3D printing is cheaper than conventional manufacturing, not to mention greener and incredibly useful for making everything from lab equipment to chess pieces. ...

User comments : 1

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

Shootist
1 / 5 (1) Feb 22, 2013
small hydropower dams have become obsolete


Small hydroelectric dams do not become obsolete, they succumb to idiot greens and their toady politicians. Take a look at what Boulder, CO has done with their 100 year old hydro plant.