Disputed fish quota cuts lead to tough EU talks

Dec 18, 2012
French fishermen fish for scallops off Quiberon, western France, on October 30, 2012 after a three-year ban. EU fishery ministers began difficult talks Tuesday on the vexed question of 2013 quotas as they sought to balance conflicting demands from environmentalists and fishermen alike.

EU fishery ministers began difficult talks Tuesday on the vexed question of 2013 quotas as they sought to balance conflicting demands from environmentalists and fishermen alike.

The European Commission is proposing to cut quotas for some 47 in the Atlantic and because many stocks are over-exploited.

In October, they agreed to maintain controversial fishing subsidies for the industry, opposed by environmental groups who say they only encourage overfishing of already stressed stocks.

The subsidies pay for modernising existing vessels or taking older boats out of the fleet and are jealously guarded by the main fishing powers—France, Portugal and especially Spain.

"The negotiations are going to go on all day, into the night, to tomorrow and no doubt, tomorrow night as well," said Cyprus Agriculture, Natural Resources and Environment Minister Sofocilis Aletraris as he went in to chair the talks.

Cyprus Agriculture, Natural Resources and Environment Minister Sofoclis Aletraris (R) speaks to his Spanish counterpart Miguel Arias Canete before the Agriculture and Fisheries Council at EU headquarters in Brussels on December 18, 2012. EU fishery ministers began talks Tuesday on the vexed question of 2013 quotas as they sought to balance conflicting demands from environmentalists and fishermen.

are pressing for reforms to allow stocks to recover above so-called Maximum Sustainable Yields (MSY), the EU benchmark, while major fishing groups claim ministers were caving in to Green demands.

Europeche, which represents EU national fishery organisations, said the planned quota cuts go beyond the scientific recommendations and put environmental over social and economic considerations.

To accept them would undercut the viability of companies and lead to job losses across the industry, Europeche said in a statement.

Spanish Agriculture Minister Miguel Arias Canete said the proposed quota cuts, some of more than 30 percent, were not justified by scientific research and would harm his country's .

The Fisheries Committee of the European Parliament meanwhile approved measures to rebuild stocks above MSY levels, to ban the practice of fish discards and control subsidies.

The WWF said the vote would prove to be the cornerstone of a new EU Common Fisheries Policy (CFP) Basic Regulation, meeting all its five goals of reform.

The committee has shown "through this milestone vote that the is listening to scientific advice and wants to recover."

Small artisanal fishermen meanwhile said any quota cuts should not hurt those who practice traditional methods which harm the environment least.

Explore further: How wise is the woolly bear caterpillar's wintry weather prediction?

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

EU keeps controversial fishing subsidies

Oct 24, 2012

The EU agreed on Wednesday to maintain controversial fishing subsidies, sparking a sharp response from environmental groups who say the payments contribute to overfishing of already stressed stocks.

EU fish discard ban agreed -- for 2019

Jun 13, 2012

After 20 hours of talks into the early hours Wednesday, Europe's fisheries ministers finally struck a compromise deal to save the oceans from overfishing -- but failed to satisfy environmentalists.

No sea change for European fishing

Jun 08, 2012

An ambitious reform of Europe's fishing sector to help replenish shrinking fish stocks appears likely to be watered down substantially by European Union nations, diplomats said Friday.

European fish stocks to be counted

Nov 12, 2012

Counting every single fish in the European seas may sound as likely as finding a mermaid, but it seems the world of technology has no boundaries.

Recommended for you

Study finds tropical fish moving into temperate waters

4 hours ago

Tropical herbivorous fish are beginning to expand their range into temperate waters – likely as a result of climate change – and a new international study documents the dramatic impact of the intrusion ...

Warming leads to more run-ins with polar bears

7 hours ago

Word spread quickly: a polar bear, then two, were spotted near this remote Inuit village on the shores of Hudson Bay, about 1,800 kilometers (1,120 miles) north of Montreal.

User comments : 0

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.