Housing recovery: Why certain states are getting out of the crisis faster

Nov 27, 2012 by Debbie Freeman

(Phys.org)—America's housing market is finally starting to really recover from the Great Recession, but some areas of the country are fighting back faster than others. New research from the W. P. Carey School of Business at Arizona State University indicates one reason: Different states have dramatically different mortgage laws, and some make it easier to push through tough times.

"The laws across states use different legal theories as the basis for mortgages, and they balance the rights of and very differently," explains Andra Ghent, assistant professor of real estate in the W. P. Carey School of Business. "The variations started early in America's history, and they're not really based on economic reasons, but they're still having a major influence on what's happening now with the housing market."

Ghent runs through a few main issues playing a role in whether a state already has gotten through the worst of the housing crisis or whether it's still plodding along:

  • Some states require judicial involvement in foreclosures, while others don't.
  • Some states require a massive amount of paperwork, including the original promissory note, in order for a lender to foreclose.
  • Some states require a longer "redemption period" of time, during which the borrower can be behind on payments, before a foreclosure can happen.
Ghent says, in general, many of the states that don't require judicial involvement or tons of paperwork have already run through the bulk of their foreclosures and are finally seeing rising property values. That's because the flood of cheap, foreclosed properties onto the market has stopped.

Arizona is one of the states in which the damage happened relatively quickly, and there's no longer a big backlog of foreclosures to go through the process. Phoenix-area home prices have been rising dramatically since last fall.

"The key is quick resolution of the situation," says Ghent. "For example, if a state requires a longer period before foreclosures can happen, then that generally means the homes deteriorate more as the borrowers realize they're going to have to leave and stop taking care of the property. This is bad for the neighbors and the property values."

Ghent adds she doesn't see much renegotiation during the times leading up to the foreclosures. The rules just allow for drawing out the situation.

"New York and Florida, for example, have very slow foreclosure processes," Ghent says. "Properties can sit around without any maintenance for two to four years while they work their way through the maze, before they finally get a new owner."

Ghent also doesn't think that making more foreclosures go through the judicial process will help prevent problems like robo-signing. That's where some lenders didn't properly review all the individual details of the cases or follow all of the required procedures.

"In most of those cases, the borrowers were really behind on their payments and would eventually have lost the homes, anyway," Ghent says. "Fraud is unacceptable, but it was also a case of sheer volume. If those particular states had required less paperwork, that's what might actually have helped prevent more robo-signing."

Ghent emphasizes that getting rid of the patchwork of different state laws would ultimately benefit the as a whole.

"Can you imagine how much money, time and resources we could save, if we didn't have 50 different sets of laws, paperwork and legal-expertise requirements?" she asks. "Again, there appears to be no real economic reason for the differences. Many of these laws date all the way back to the 1800s, and some were changed just after the Great Depression."

Overall, Ghent has one big message for those who can influence the process in the future.

"Nobody pays attention to mortgage laws for 50 to 60 years at a time," she says. "They only examine these laws after a major event, so the time to change is now."

Explore further: Entrepreneurs to venture capitalists: Don't be a Scrooge

More information: papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cf… ?abstract_id=2166656

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

ASU report: Foreclosures still cloud housing market

Feb 12, 2010

(PhysOrg.com) -- Foreclosures continue to play a major role in the Phoenix-area housing market. Almost half of the existing-home transactions in the Valley last month -- 45 percent -- were foreclosures. That's according to ...

Report: Foreclosures still dominate housing market

Mar 17, 2010

Despite signs of economic recovery across the country, the Phoenix-area housing market continues to be driven by foreclosures. Last month, almost two-thirds of the existing-home transactions in the market were either foreclosures ...

Phoenix-area foreclosure rate drops slightly

Apr 20, 2011

A little bit of good news is coming to the Phoenix-area housing market. Foreclosures accounted for just under 38 percent of the existing-home transactions in the area in March. A new report from the W. P. Carey School of ...

Foreclosure crisis and metropolitan crime rates

Aug 17, 2012

The housing foreclosure crisis has been blamed for widespread economic and social problems in the United States, including reduced property values, depressed consumer spending and a decline in government services. Some observers ...

Recommended for you

Over-identifying restrictions in economic analysis

Nov 25, 2014

The analysis of empirical economics has long made use of a tool called the generalized method of moments (GMM). This method is used as a generic way of estimating parameters in an empirical model where the ...

Tracking Chinese aid to Africa

Nov 24, 2014

Is a fancy new school in an African government official's hometown a coincidence, or evidence of systematic favouritism in the distribution of aid?

User comments : 0

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.