NASA pursues atom optics to detect the imperceptible

Oct 18, 2012 by Lori Keesey
Goddard physicist Babak Saif, along with researchers from Stanford University and AOSense Inc., a Sunnyvale, Calif.-based company, has received NASA funding to advance a potentially revolutionary technology -- atom optics -- to detect theoretically predicted gravitational waves. Credit: NASA/Pat Izzo

(Phys.org)—A pioneering technology capable of atomic-level precision is now being developed to detect what so far has remained imperceptible: gravitational waves or ripples in space-time caused by cataclysmic events including even the Big Bang itself.

A team of researchers at NASA's Goddard Space Flight Center in Greenbelt, Md., Stanford University in California, and AOSense, Inc., in Sunnyvale, Calif., recently won funding under the NASA Innovative Advanced Concepts (NIAC) program to advance atom-optics technologies. Some believe this emerging, highly technology is a technological panacea for everything from measuring gravitational waves to steering submarines and airplanes.

"I've been following this technology for a decade," said Bernie Seery, a Goddard executive who was instrumental in establishing Goddard's strategic partnership with Stanford University and AOSense two years ago. "The technology has come of age and I'm delighted NASA has chosen this effort for a NIAC award," he said.

This video is not supported by your browser at this time.
Einstein predicted gravity waves in his general theory of relativity, but to date these ripples in the fabric of space-time have never been observed. Now a scientific research technique called Atomic Interferometry is trying to re-write the canon. In conjunction with researchers at Stanford University, scientists at NASA Goddard are developing a system to measure the faint gravitational vibrations generated by movement of massive objects in the universe. The scientific payoff could be important, helping better clarify key issues in our understanding of cosmology. But application payoff could be substantial, too, with the potential to develop profound advances in fields like geolocation and timekeeping. In this video we examine how the system would work, and the scientific underpinnings of the research effort. Credit: NASA/Goddard Space Flight Center

The NIAC program supports potentially revolutionary, high-risk technologies and mission concepts that could advance NASA's objectives. "With this funding and other support, we can move ahead more quickly now, Seery said, adding that the U.S. military has invested heavily in the technology to dramatically improve navigation. "It opens up a wealth of possibilities."

Although the researchers believe the technology offers great promise for a variety of space applications, including navigating around a near-Earth asteroid to measure its gravitational field and deduce its composition, so far they have focused their efforts on using Goddard and NASA Research and Development seed funding to advance sensors that could detect theoretically predicted gravitational waves.

Predicted by 's , gravitational waves occur when massive celestial objects move and disrupt the fabric of space-time around them. By the time these waves reach Earth, they are so weak that the planet expands and contracts less than an atom in response. This makes their detection with ground-based equipment more challenging because environmental noise, like ocean tides and earthquakes, can easily swamp their faint murmurings.

Although astrophysical observations have implied their existence, no instrument or observatory, including the ground-based Laser Interferometer Gravitational-Wave Observatory, has ever directly detected them.

Should scientists confirm their existence, they say the discovery would revolutionize astrophysics, giving them a new tool for studying everything from inspiralling black holes to the early universe before the fog of hydrogen plasma cooled to give way to the formation of atoms.

The team believes atom optics or atom interferometry holds the key to directly detecting them.

Atom interferometry works much like optical interferometry, a 200-year-old technique widely used in science and industry to obtain highly accurate measurements. It obtains these measurements by comparing light that has been split into two equal halves with a device called a beamsplitter. One beam reflects off a mirror that is fixed in place; from there, it travels to a camera or detector. The other shines through something scientists want to measure. It then reflects off a second mirror, back through the beamsplitter, and then onto a camera or detector.

Because the path that one beam travels is fixed in length and the other travels an extra distance or in some other slightly different way, the two light beams overlap and interfere when they meet up, creating an interference pattern that scientists inspect to obtain highly precise measurements.

Cataclysmic events, such as this artist's rendition of a binary-star merger, are believed to create gravitational waves that cause ripples in space-time.

Atom interferometry, however, hinges on quantum mechanics, the theory that describes how matter behaves at sub-microscopic scales. Just as waves of light can act like particles called photons, atoms can be cajoled into acting like waves if cooled to near absolute zero. At those frigid temperatures, which scientists achieve by firing a laser at the atom, its velocity slows to nearly zero. By firing another series of laser pulses at laser-cooled atoms, scientists put them into what they call a "superposition of states."

In other words, the atoms have different momenta permitting them to separate spatially and be manipulated to fly along different trajectories. Eventually, they cross paths and recombine at the detector—just as in a conventional interferometer. "Atoms have a way of being in two places at once, making it analogous to light interferometry," said Mark Kasevich, a Stanford University professor and team member credited with pushing the frontiers of atom optics.

The power of atom interferometry is its precision. If the path an atom takes varies by even a picometer, an atom interferometer would be able to detect the difference. Given its atomic-level precision, "gravitational-wave detection is arguably the most compelling scientific application for this technology in space," said physicist Babak Saif, who is leading the effort at Goddard.

Since joining forces, the team has designed a powerful, narrowband fiber-optic laser system that it plans to test at one of the world's largest atom interferometers—a 33-foot drop tower in the basement of a Stanford University physics laboratory. Close scientifically to what the team would need to detect theoretical , the technology would be used as the foundation for any atom-based instrument created to fly in space, Saif said.

During the test, the team will insert a cloud of neutral rubidium atoms inside the 33-foot tower. As gravity asserts a pull on the cloud and the atoms begin to fall, the team will use its new laser system to fire pulses of light to cool them. Once in the wave-like state, the atoms will encounter another round of laser pulses that allow them to separate spatially. Their trajectories then can be manipulated so that their paths cross at the detector, creating the interference pattern.

The team also is fine-tuning a gravitational-wave mission concept it has formulated. Similar to the Laser Interferometer Space Antenna (LISA), the concept calls for three identically equipped spacecraft placed in a triangle-shaped configuration. Unlike LISA, however, the spacecraft would come equipped with atom interferometers and they would orbit much closer to one another—between 500 and 5,000 kilometers apart, compared with LISA's five-million-kilometer separation. Should a gravitational wave roll past, the interferometers would be able to sense the miniscule movement.

"I believe this technology will eventually work in space," Kasevich said. "But it presents a really complicated systems challenge that goes beyond our expertise. We really want to fly in space, but how do you fit this technology onto a satellite? Having something work in space is different than the measurements we take on Earth."

That's where Goddard comes in, Saif said. "We have experience with everything except the atom part," he said, adding that AOSense already employs a team of more than 30 physicists and engineers focused on building compact, ruggedized atom-optics instruments. "We can do the systems design; we can do the laser. We're spacecraft people. What we shouldn't be doing is reinventing the atomic physics. That's our partners' forte."

Explore further: New method for non-invasive prostate cancer screening

Related Stories

Scientists make quantum breakthrough

Apr 20, 2011

(PhysOrg.com) -- Scientists have demonstrated for the first time that atoms can be guided in a laser beam and possess the same properties as light guided in an optical communications fiber.

The music of gravitational waves

Nov 24, 2010

A team of scientists and engineers at NASA's Jet Propulsion Laboratory has brought the world one step closer to "hearing" gravitational waves -- ripples in space and time predicted by Albert Einstein in the ...

Measuring the universe

Aug 25, 2010

A unique antenna which could help unveil a new window on the universe by observing thousands of gravitational waves should be one of NASA's next space missions according to a group of leading US experts.

Developing more accurate cold atom accelerometers

Sep 26, 2011

For the first time, a team of French physicists, supported by CNES and ESA, has succeeded in developing a vibration-resistant cold atom accelerometer. Tested in parabolic flight, this prototype was able to ...

Watching an electron being born

May 15, 2012

Atomic processes take place on extremely short time scales. Measurements at the Vienna University of Technology (TU Vienna) can now visualize these processes.

Recommended for you

New method for non-invasive prostate cancer screening

14 hours ago

Cancer screening is a critical approach for preventing cancer deaths because cases caught early are often more treatable. But while there are already existing ways to screen for different types of cancer, ...

How bubble studies benefit science and engineering

15 hours ago

The image above shows a perfect bubble imploding in weightlessness. This bubble, and many like it, are produced by the researchers from the École Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne in Switzerland. What ...

Famous Feynman lectures put online with free access

16 hours ago

(Phys.org) —Back in the early sixties, physicist Richard Feynman gave a series of lectures on physics to first year students at Caltech—those lectures were subsequently put into print and made into text ...

Single laser stops molecular tumbling motion instantly

20 hours ago

In the quantum world, making the simple atom behave is one thing, but making the more complex molecule behave is another story. Now Northwestern University scientists have figured out an elegant way to stop a molecule from ...

User comments : 7

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

packrat
1 / 5 (1) Oct 18, 2012
I don't believe they are ever going to have any luck with this until they can setup a measurement system in space. There are just too many possible things that would have to be taken into account on Earth and the measurement needed is so small. We need a bigger space station with room for stuff like this.
Husky
not rated yet Oct 18, 2012
i wonder if they could use it for testing the Mach effect and or measure if antimatter has antigravitational effects.
that_guy
not rated yet Oct 18, 2012
Often times the greatest discoveries are made when scientists are looking for something else.

This is doubtlessly a technology that will reveal many new things while they are shaking it down to get it ready for gravity wave detection.

@husky - I'm not sure how you think this would apply to mach bands or the woodward effect. I can basically guarantee you that they will be using neutral charged noble gas, not ions.
guillaume_pussetto
not rated yet Oct 18, 2012
Regarding Laser Interferometer Space Antenna (LISA) , according to wikipedia "On April 8th 2011, it was announced in a press release made through NASA's LISA Project Office,[3] that, based on the United States President's Fiscal Year 2012 Budget Request,[11] NASA would likely be unable to continue participating in the LISA project. As a result, the European Space Agency has ended its study of LISA as a partnership at the scale initially proposed in the New Worlds New Horizons decadal survey. Revised mission concepts will be considered in a selection process commencing in February 2012. A decision is expected in April 2012.[12]"
So maybe this technology can take the place of LISA. I wonder was decision was taken (if any) on April 2012...
Husky
not rated yet Oct 19, 2012
Well, i can imagine voor instance a penning trap with anti-hydrogen orbiting around earth and have a second control chamber with ordinary matter to compare the interference effects during the orbital trajectory for wich we now have mapped out finely tuned gravity charts already by previous satellite measurements.
ValeriaT
1 / 5 (1) Oct 20, 2012
IMO the gravitational waves are all around us, they do manifest with omnipresent CMBR noise. This is an analogy of sound waves spreading from underwater explosions along water surface. It manifests itself like wave of noise too, because these waves are spreading faster, than the surface (transverse) waves. This idea is not very new: Eddington (who did understand the relativity pretty well) realized that the reference frame in general relativity is defined with space-time curvature only, i.e. in similar way, like the gravitational wave itself. In this sense, the gravitational waves are serving as a reference frame for itself and their speed is therefore not defined: such a wave would propagate like the noise from general relativity perspective.
ValeriaT
1 / 5 (2) Oct 20, 2012
Relativists use a simplified form of Eistein field equations to calculate gravitational waves, which are based on the Einstein's pseudo-tensor (linearised field equations). They do this because field equations are highly non-linear (implicit actually) and impossible to solve analytically. So they use the linearized form, simply assuming that they can do so. However Hermann Weyl proved in 1944 already, that linearizion of the field equations implies the existence of a Einstein's pseudo-tensor that, except for the trivial case of being precisely zero, does not otherwise exist: http://www.jstor..../2371768

Therefore we have both theoretical, both intuitive indicia for complete understanding of the gravitational waves for many years, but the lobby of physicists engaged in search of gravitational waves never admit, they wasted billions of dollars for finding of something, which everyone can detect with his analogue TV set.