A coal economy has multiple health and social risks, says major review

October 29, 2012

A major review of evidence on the impact of coal mining has highlighted serious, ongoing health and social problems and an urgent need for improvements in government coal mining policy.

The research by the University of Sydney has also revealed a critical lack of local studies investigating the effect has on Australian communities.

The report, which analyses 50 peer-reviewed research papers from 10 countries, will be launched at the University today.

"This comprehensive review of Australian and international and medical literature underlines the pressing need for Australia to re-evaluate whether the overall health and social costs of Australia's reliance on a coal economy will ultimately outweigh its ," said lead author Associate Professor Ruth Colagiuri, from Sydney Medical School.

The purpose of the report (PDF, 1.8MB), commissioned by Beyond , is to provide an overview of the available evidence on the health effects and social justice impacts of coal mining on local communities and relate these issues to the Hunter Region of New South Wales. The Hunter region has more than 30 mostly open-cut coal mines and six active coal-fired power stations.

Studies from coal mining regions of the US, the United Kingdom, Canada, Turkey, Israel, and Asia indicate serious health impacts for communities living near coal mines and coal combusting power stations.

"Among the problems identified in children and infants in these communities are impaired growth and , high blood levels of , higher prevalences of any birth defects and a greater chance of being of low birth weight, which is a risk factor for future obesity, diabetes and heart disease," Associate Professor Colagiuri said.

Adults have been shown to have higher rates of death from lung cancer and chronic heart, respiratory and kidney diseases. They also have increased chances of developing other cancers and hypertension. Some studies also show higher rates of miscarriages and stillbirths.

"Although there are differences in mining practices and standards across countries that may account for some of this excess death and illness, it is hard to imagine that at least some of this evidence would not apply to Australia," Professor Colagiuri said.

Studies from the US, the UK, Russia and Queensland found social injustices associated with coal mining such as environmental degradation, including water pollution and slurry spills. Also identified were the inability of communities to grasp financial benefits and the distortion of the local economy and infrastructure, including labour and accommodation shortages and increased pressure on local emergency services.

Studies of social impacts in the Hunter Region acknowledge similar issues.

"Communities in the Hunter report feelings of powerlessness and distress and have no formal avenue for input into the granting of mining licences," Professor Colagiuri said.

"The available international and local evidence about the health and social harms of living near coal mines or stations highlights the need for an urgent policy response to ensure transparency in arrangements between government and the mining industry and community safeguards such as mandatory health impact assessments.

"We also urgently need well designed local studies from Australia's coal areas to generate evidence for the most informed decision possible about the future health of mining communities. The negative impacts we have identified have implications not only for this generation but future ones," Professor Colagiuri said.

Explore further: Coal industry fumes as US revokes mining permit

More information: media.beyondzeroemissions.org/coal_health_Report_FINAL.pdf

Related Stories

Coal industry fumes as US revokes mining permit

January 14, 2011

The withdrawal of a permit for a controversial "mountaintop removal" coal mining operation has sparked outrage in the US industry, but was hailed as a victory for environmental protection and the health of nearby communities.

Australian mining tycoon blasts coal seam gas

August 28, 2011

Australian mining tycoon Clive Palmer on Saturday hit out at the country's growing coal seam gas industry, saying there were concerns it could lead to environmental contamination.

Miner Xstrata wins Australia climate test case

March 28, 2012

Swiss mining giant Xstrata has won a test case against what is set to be Australia's largest open-cut coal mine, with a court ruling that the economic benefits outweighed its climate change impacts.

Recommended for you

First nationwide survey of climate change education

February 11, 2016

How is climate change being taught in American schools? Is it being taught at all? And how are teachers addressing climate change denial in their classrooms, schools, and school districts?

1 comment

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

1 / 5 (1) Oct 30, 2012
Where are all the Big Coal shills? Kibitzing?

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.