Potential survival of extreme life forms on eccentric exoplanets

Sep 12, 2012 by Josh Rodriguez
While Earth and the other planets in our solar system travel around the sun in near-circular orbits, planets in other systems can have more comet-like orbits in which the distance from the planet to star varies. Such orbits, termed eccentric, would cause the planet to move in and out of the habitable zone. A habitable zone, shown in green here, is defined as the region around a star where liquid water, an essential ingredient for life as we know it, could potentially be present. Earth always remains in its habitable zone. The hypothetical planet is depicted here moving through the habitable zone and then further out into a long, cold winter. During this phase of the orbit, any liquid water on the planet will freeze at the surface; however, the possibility remains that life could, in theory, hibernate beneath the surface. Credit: NASA/JPL-Caltech

(Phys.org)—Astronomers have discovered a veritable rogues' gallery of odd exoplanets—from scorching hot worlds with molten surfaces to frigid ice balls.

And while the hunt continues for the elusive "blue dot"—a planet with roughly the same characteristics as Earth—new research reveals that might actually be able to survive on some of the many exoplanetary oddballs that exist.

"When we're talking about a , we're talking about a world where can exist," said Stephen Kane, a scientist with the Exoplanet Science Institute at the California Institute of Technology in Pasadena. "A planet needs to be the right distance from its star—not too hot and not too cold." Determined by the size and heat of the star, this temperature range is commonly referred to as the "habitable zone" around a star.

Kane and fellow Exoplanet Science Institute scientist Dawn Gelino have created a resource called the "Habitable Zone Gallery." It calculates the size and distance of the habitable zone for each exoplanetary system that has been discovered and shows which orbit in this so-called "goldilocks" zone. The Habitable Zone Gallery can be found at www.hzgallery.org . The study describing the research appears in the Astrobiology journal and is available at http://.org/abs/1205.2429 .

But not all exoplanets have Earth-like orbits that remain at a fairly constant distance from their stars. One of the unexpected revelations of planet hunting has been that many travel in very oblong, eccentric orbits that vary greatly in distance from their stars.

"Planets like these may spend some, but not all of their time in the habitable zone," Kane said. "You might have a world that heats up for brief periods in between long, , or you might have brief spikes of very hot conditions."

Though planets like these would be very different from Earth, this might not preclude them from being able to support . "Scientists have found microscopic life forms on Earth that can survive all kinds of extreme conditions," Kane said. "Some organisms can basically drop their metabolism to zero to survive very long-lasting, cold conditions. We know that others can withstand very extreme heat conditions if they have a protective layer of rock or water. There have even been studies performed on Earth-based spores, bacteria and lichens, which show they can survive in both harsh environments on Earth
and the extreme conditions of space."

Kane and Gelino's research suggests that habitable zone around stars might be larger than once thought, and that planets that might be hostile to human life might be the perfect place for extremophiles, like lichens and bacteria, to survive. "Life evolved on Earth at a very early stage in the planet's development, under conditions much harsher than they are today," Kane said.

Kane explained that many life-harboring worlds might not be planets at all, but rather moons of larger, gas-giant planets like Jupiter in our own solar system. "There are lots of giant planets out there, and all of them may have moons, if they are like the giant planets in the solar system," Kane says. "A moon of a planet that is in or spends time in a can be habitable itself."

As an example, Kane mentioned Titan, the largest moon of Saturn, which, despite its thick atmosphere, is far too distant from the sun and too cold for life as we know it to exist on its surface. "If you moved Titan closer in to the sun, it would have lots of water vapor and very favorable conditions for life."

Kane is quick to point out that there are limits to what scientists can presently determine about habitability on already-discovered exoplanets. "It's difficult to really know about a planet when you don't have any knowledge about its atmosphere," he said. For example, both Earth and Venus experience an atmospheric "greenhouse effect"—but the runaway effect on Venus makes it the hottest place in the solar system. "Without analogues in our own , it's difficult to know precisely what a habitable moon or eccentric planet orbit would look like."

Still, the research suggests that habitability might exist in many forms in the galaxy—not just on planets that look like our own. Kane and Gelino are hard at work determining which already-discovered exoplanets might be candidates for extremophile life or habitable moons. "There are lots of eccentric and gas giant planet discoveries," Kane says. "We may find some surprises out there as we start to determine exactly what we consider habitable."

Explore further: Partial solar eclipse over the U.S. on Thursday, Oct. 23

Related Stories

Habitable zones

Aug 22, 2011

(PhysOrg.com) -- The "habitable zone" is the region around a star where a suitable planet could sustain the conditions necessary for life. Most astronomers take it to be the region where the balance between ...

Do moons of gas giants affect the habitable zone?

Mar 07, 2012

(PhysOrg.com) -- If you aren’t familiar with the Drake Equation, or how it may actually apply to exomoons, continue reading to learn more about the famous equation. Additionally, what conditions could ...

Wobbly planets could reveal Earth-like moons

Dec 11, 2008

Moons outside our Solar System with the potential to support life have just become much easier to detect, thanks to research by an astronomer at University College London (UCL).

Greenhouse effect could extend habitable zone

Aug 26, 2011

The distant region beyond Saturn is too cold for liquid water, a necessity for life as we know it. But new research indicates that rocky planets far from their parent star could generate enough heat to keep ...

Recommended for you

Partial solar eclipse over the U.S. on Thursday, Oct. 23

Oct 17, 2014

People in most of the continental United States will be in the shadow of the Moon on Thursday afternoon, Oct. 23, as a partial solar eclipse sweeps across the Earth. For people looking through sun-safe filters, from Los Angeles, ...

A newborn supernova every night

Oct 17, 2014

Thanks to a $9 million grant from the National Science Foundation and matching funds from the Zwicky Transient Facility (ZTF) collaboration, a new camera is being built at Caltech's Palomar Observatory that ...

Scientists build first map of hidden universe

Oct 16, 2014

A team led by astronomers from the Max Planck Institute for Astronomy has created the first three-dimensional map of the 'adolescent' Universe, just 3 billion years after the Big Bang. This map, built from ...

User comments : 4

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

eachus
4.5 / 5 (4) Sep 12, 2012
The "Goldilocks" zone is way over-hyped. Consider Earth. There are areas which remain below freezing year-round. But ocean water near, even at, the North Pole stays liquid year round. Why? The dissolved minerals reduce the freezing point.

The same phenomena holds near the Equator. Dissolved minerals in sea water in this case increase the boiling point. In ocean floor "black smoker" regions, the temperature may be several hundred degrees above boiling at the surface. Life abounds there, so even if you limit your search to "life as we know it," the potentially habitable zone is very wide.

What about planets with elliptical orbits? There are desert creatures on Earth which dry out in hot dry conditions, but return to life (briefly) when the rains come. There are also plenty of lifeforms on Earth that can be frozen for years, and return to life when the landscape heats up. That heat can come from vulcanism not sunlight, which should be common on planets with such orbits.
Torbjorn_Larsson_OM
3 / 5 (1) Sep 12, 2012
When we start to move away from surface radiation habitability, a coarse description, to greenhouse atmospheric habitability and subsurface crustal & subsurface ocean habitability respectively, we also start to distinguish between environments suitable for mature biospheres vs abiogenesis.

Kane et al seems to prefer to conflate these, but it isn't certain that hibernation or "conditions much harsher" was present on Earth or is suitable for abiogenesis in general. Early life was much less internally well controlled, so reasonably more fragile.

Instead one could describe how often planets transition from habitable zones conducive for abiogenesis, mostly greenhouse surface habitables because of potential for oceans, towards habitable zones conducive for mature biospheres, say part time greenhouse surface habitables or subsurface crustal habitables.
Peteri
5 / 5 (2) Sep 12, 2012
Back in the 1980s Brian Aldiss wrote a SciFi trilogy (Helliconia Spring, Helliconia Summer, Helliconia Winter). "Helliconia, a planet located in a binary star system a thousand light-years distant from Earth. [Batalix and] Helliconia take 2,592 years to orbit Freyr in a highly elliptical orbit (Helliconia is three times further from Freyr at its most distant point than nearest), which results in seasons that last for centuries apiece. Helliconia's plants, animal and sentient lifeforms have all biologically adapted to this unusual arrangement..."

PinkElephant
4 / 5 (2) Sep 12, 2012
@Torbjorn,
Early life was much less internally well controlled, so reasonably more fragile.
I wouldn't be so sure. Early life was certainly much less efficient, and much less complex. But it could easily have been much more robust and resilient at the same time. Higher complexity necessarily results in heightened fragility and a need for more refined control.
Instead one could describe how often planets transition from habitable zones conducive for abiogenesis...
Assuming abiogenesis even requires either planets or any particular zone. Some postulate it could occur on asteroids or comets, and even when restricting the scope to planets, some postulate subterranean/subsurface processes that occur irrespective or orbital details or surface conditions.

Orbital particulars and surface conditions are far more important, IMHO, to the potential for emergence of intelligent life. Less complex life, not so much....