Minnesota woman loses music downloading appeal

Sep 11, 2012 by Steve Karnowski

(AP)—A woman accused of sharing songs online owes record companies $222,000 for willful copyright violations, a federal appeals court said Tuesday, reversing a lower court's ruling in a long-running lawsuit over music downloading.

A three-judge appeals panel ruled that Chief U.S. Michael Davis erred when he cut the award against Jammie Thomas-Rasset to $54,000.

The Minnesota woman's case was one of only two to go to trial out of more than 30,000 filed by the in a drive to stop the unauthorized free downloading of copyrighted music, which the industry says has cut deeply into its revenues. The vast majority settled for about $3,500 apiece. The U.S. Supreme Court in May refused to hear an appeal by former Boston University student Joel Tenenbaum of a $675,000 award in the other case, but he has vowed to keep fighting.

Juries ruled against Thomas-Rasset in three separate trials since the industry sued her in 2006. Davis said the last award, of $1.5 million dollars, was "severe and oppressive."

But the appeals court said the high award was not unreasonable. It sent the case back to Davis for an order that she pay $222,000—the award from her original trial—and for an injunction barring her from making the plaintiffs' recordings available to the public via online media distribution systems in the future.

Thomas-Rasset said she plans to appeal again as long as her attorneys remain with her for the long haul, and they've assured her they are. She has said she can't afford to pay anyway.

The industry presented evidence that Thomas-Rasset made available over 1,700 songs to other computer uses via the file sharing service , though the lawsuit targeted only 24 songs.

For tactical reasons, the appeals court noted, the industry didn't seek reinstatement of the third jury's award and were content with the original $222,000—$2,250 per song—from her 2007 trial.

Thomas-Rasset got a second trial in 2009 after Davis concluded he made a legal error in her first. After Davis cut the second 's $1.92 million award to $54,000, the industry won a third trial that resulted in a $1.5 million award, which Davis again cut to $54,000.

Explore further: Digital dilemma: How will US respond to Sony hack?

3 /5 (2 votes)
add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Record companies plan music downloading appeal

Aug 22, 2011

(AP) -- Recording industry attorneys are appealing a recent ruling that reduced the amount of money a Minnesota woman must pay for willfully violating the copyrights of 24 songs.

Industry wants to ban Minn. woman from downloading

Jul 06, 2009

(AP) -- Just weeks after a federal jury ruled that a Minnesota woman must pay $1.92 million for illegally sharing copyright-protected music, the recording industry wants to make sure she doesn't do it again.

Atty: MN woman can't pay for sharing songs

Nov 05, 2010

(AP) -- A Minnesota woman ordered to pay a recording industry trade group $1.5 million for illegally sharing music online doesn't plan to pay those damages as her attorneys continue to argue the amount is unconstitutional, ...

Judge slashes 'monstrous' fine in music piracy case

Jan 25, 2010

Condemning a two-million-dollar fine meted out to a Minnesota woman for illegally downloading music over the Internet as "monstrous and shocking," a judge has slashed the penalty to 54,000 dollars.

Minnesota song-sharing case heads for 3rd trial

Jan 28, 2010

(AP) -- A trade group representing the major music labels said Wednesday it will reject a reduced penalty for a central Minnesota woman found guilty of sharing 24 songs over the Internet, and will instead begin preparing ...

Recommended for you

Digital dilemma: How will US respond to Sony hack?

19 hours ago

The detective work blaming North Korea for the Sony hacker break-in appears so far to be largely circumstantial, The Associated Press has learned. The dramatic conclusion of a Korean role is based on subtle ...

UN General Assembly OKs digital privacy resolution

22 hours ago

The U.N. General Assembly has approved a resolution demanding better digital privacy protections for people around the world, another response to Edward Snowden's revelations about U.S. government spying.

Online privacy to remain thorny issue: survey

23 hours ago

Online privacy will remain a thorny issue over the next decade, without a widely accepted system that balances user rights and personal data collection, a survey of experts showed Thursday.

Spain: Google News vanishes amid 'Google Tax' spat

Dec 16, 2014

Google on Tuesday followed through with a pledge to shut down Google News in Spain in reaction to a Spanish law requiring news publishers to receive payment for content even if they are willing to give it away.

User comments : 3

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

LariAnn
5 / 5 (4) Sep 11, 2012
While agreeing that the free distribution of copyrighted music is to be discouraged, the idea of a company that has made billions of dollars by selling grossly overpriced products crushing one person with such exorbitant fines is unconscionable. IMHO music buyers should support and purchase from artists who market their music privately and not through the "labels" - in that way the artists get compensated fairly and the middlemen and leeches are left twisting in the breeze. When "big music" steals from customers by way of overpricing, that is just as bad as free downloading, maybe even more so.
VendicarD
5 / 5 (4) Sep 11, 2012
In celebration of the verdict, I will download some music tonight and add it to my collection.

Death to the RIAA.
enigma13x
not rated yet Sep 13, 2012
but think about those poor producers that cant add another wing to their mansion those poor bastards have to work hard at screwing everyone else its not all champagne and partys they have to file law suits to screw poor students as well

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.