Study shows increased aggression between evenly matched teams

August 16, 2012 by Bob Yirka report

( -- Over the years, research has shown that when two people, or animals, are evenly matched opponents, both tend to resort to more savagery to win than if one is clearly superior to the other. Now new research by a team in the Netherlands has shown that the same appears to be true for groups, or teams of people engaged in sports. In a study, the researchers found, as they describe in their paper published in the journal Biology Letters, when two teams are evenly matched, they tend to resort to more illegal tactics resulting in more penalties, than do players on teams that are not so evenly matched.

The researchers, led by Gert Stulp of the psychology department at the University of Groningen, looked at two sports, football (aka soccer) and American basketball (the NBA). The first study group was made up of teams in the German Bundesliga soccer division. To come up with a way of defining parity of , the team used what they refer to as Resource Holding Potential (RHP) which was derived by looking at past success. The closer two teams were in RHP, the closer they were in skill levels, thus it could be used as a measure of teams when playing together.

After looking at statistics for 1,530 matches over a five year span, the researchers found a clear pattern developing. Average fouls overall were 38.76 per match. When the teams were close in rank, however, the number jumped to 39.15, compared to a low of 34.2 when really good teams played really bad ones. What’s perhaps more revealing however were stats for more serious fouls, those that occur when a player does something intentionally that might result in an injury to the other player. For teams with nearly equal RHP skill levels, 4.3 cards were issued per match, versus just 3.57 for unmatched teams, suggesting that resorting to more aggressive tendencies seems to be the norm when teams are very evenly matched.

In the study, the researchers found nearly identical patterns, and thus assert that not only do people resort to more aggressive tendencies when two individuals compete (or fight), but they do so as well when operating as a team. The results overall show, they say, that not only do grow more aggressive and/or violent when playing equally matched , but that their behavior can be predicted due to general tendencies.

Explore further: Best Team Not Guaranteed World Cup Success

More information: Increased aggression during human group contests when competitive ability is more similar, Biology Letters, Published online before print August 15, 2012, doi: 10.1098/rsbl.2012.0591

Theoretical analyses and empirical studies have revealed that conflict escalation is more likely when individuals are more similar in resource-holding potential (RHP). Conflicts can also occur between groups, but it is unknown whether conflicts also escalate more when groups are more similar in RHP. We tested this hypothesis in humans, using data from two professional sports competitions: football (the Bundesliga, the German first division of football) and basketball (the NBA, the North American National Basketball Association). We defined RHP based on the league ranks of the teams involved in the competition (i.e. their competitive ability) and measured conflict escalation by the number of fouls committed. We found that in both sports the number of fouls committed increased when the difference in RHP was smaller. Thus, we provide what is to our best knowledge the first evidence that, as in conflicts between individuals, conflicts escalate more when groups are more similar in RHP.

Related Stories

Best Team Not Guaranteed World Cup Success

June 11, 2010

The World Cup offers fans of the globe's most popular sport the chance to thrill and agonize over the ups and downs of their nations' teams. For scientists, whether or not they are fans, it's another chance to collect data ...

Big playoffs don't mean big payoffs

May 4, 2011

Two of Boston’s professional sports teams — the Celtics and the Bruins — have reached the second round of their league playoffs for the third consecutive season. We asked John Kwoka, Neal F. Finnegan distinguished ...

Weight, height, and experience key to Rugby World Cup success

February 20, 2012

Rugby teams with the tallest backs, heaviest forwards, and greatest amount of collective experience are likely to be the most successful at World Cup level, reveals research published online in the British Journal of Sports ...

Recommended for you

Automating DNA origami opens door to many new uses

May 27, 2016

Researchers can build complex, nanometer-scale structures of almost any shape and form, using strands of DNA. But these particles must be designed by hand, in a complex and laborious process.

In changing oceans, cephalopods are booming

May 23, 2016

Humans have changed the world's oceans in ways that have been devastating to many marine species. But, according to new evidence, it appears that the change has so far been good for cephalopods, the group including octopuses, ...

A 100-million-year partnership on the brink of extinction

May 24, 2016

A relationship that has lasted for 100 million years is at serious risk of ending, due to the effects of environmental and climate change. A species of spiny crayfish native to Australia and the tiny flatworms that depend ...

Rare evolutionary event detected in the lab

May 23, 2016

It took nearly a half trillion tries before researchers at The University of Texas at Austin witnessed a rare event and perhaps solved an evolutionary puzzle about how introns, non-coding sequences of DNA located within genes, ...

Is aging inevitable? Not necessarily for sea urchins

May 25, 2016

Sea urchins are remarkable organisms. They can quickly regrow damaged spines and feet. Some species also live to extraordinary old ages and—even more remarkably—do so with no signs of poor health, such as a decline in ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

1 / 5 (2) Aug 16, 2012
Peace through strength and superior firepower is validated.
1 / 5 (1) Aug 16, 2012
It's known, the wars occur mostly between countries which differ with their power (although these very small ones are annexed in quiet too). A similar effect can be observed inside of mixture of bubbles and/or droplets, where larger objects expanding into account of these smaller ones. An equally sized dispersions are conditionally stable.
not rated yet Aug 17, 2012
Wow, when teams were evenly matched the average fouls jumped by 0.4/game!!!!!! Why bother even mentioning that when the average was alomst 39 (increase of ~1%).

The real result is for the cards (serious fouls). Here the increase was about 20%.
5 / 5 (1) Aug 17, 2012
In the NBA study, the researchers found nearly identical patterns, and thus assert that not only do people resort to more aggressive tendencies when two individuals compete (or fight), but they do so as well when operating as a team.

Seems reasonable. There are always many strategies at your disposal. So you select (intuitively or consciously) the ones that are the least risky first - which are the non-aggressive strategies. Especially if opponents aren't evenly matched such strategies will lead to 'easy victory' (or at least will not lead to extermination beyond the assured defeat for the weaker entity)

In evenly matched entities those strategies won't lead to any clear advantage, so you have to start altering the playing field
Aggression is aimed at taking away abilities from the opponent but the risk of retaliation is high.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.